Boulder Politics

Boulder City Council · Document

Appendix A - Staff Criteria Analysis

Special Meeting, November 12, 2026 · item 3C: Consideration of a Nonconforming Use Review for the property located at 969 10th Street. The application proposes expansion of an existing d… · 5 pages

Open the original file

This is the text extracted from the file, without its layout, tables, or images. Use the original for anything that matters.

Attachment B - Staff Criteria Analysis

CRITERIA CHECKLIST AND COMMENT FORM USE REVIEW SECTION 9-2-15(e) & (f) LUR2025-00091 ADDRESS: 969 10th Street DATE: 8/11/26

CRITERIA APPLICABLE TO ALL USE REVIEW APPLICATIONS (e) Criteria For Review: Meets criteria No use review application will be approved unless the approving agency finds all of the following:

(1) Rationale: Yes The use either: (A) Provides direct service or convenience to or reduces adverse impacts to the surrounding uses or neighborhood; (B) Provides a compatible transition between higher intensity and lower intensity uses; (C) Is necessary to foster a specific city policy, as expressed in the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan, including, without limitation, historic preservation, moderate income housing, residential and nonresidential mixed uses in appropriate locations and group living arrangements for special populations; or (D) Is an existing legal nonconforming use or an expansion that is permitted under Subsection (f) of this section; Yes Staff Response: The project is an existing legal nonconforming use that is being expanded, subject to section 9-2-15(f). The property is zoned RL-1 and contains two dwelling units. The property is nonconforming to the density requirements of the RL-1 zone because the lot area is 6,083 square feet where a minimum lot area of 7,000 square feet per dwelling unit is required per Section 9-8-1, B.R.C. 1981. The structure has been a permitted duplex since at least 1971, according to city building permit records. The project is considered an expansion of a nonconforming use per the definition in Chapter 9-16, because of the proposed 95 sq ft increase in floor area (3.6%) and addition of two bedrooms to the dwelling units.

(2) Compatibility: Yes The location, size, design, and operating characteristics of the use will be reasonably compatible with and have minimal negative impact on the use of nearby properties, or, for residential uses or community, cultural, and educational uses in industrial zoning districts, the proposed development reasonably mitigates the potential negative impacts from nearby properties; Staff Response: The proposal is to convert existing attic space to habitable floor area for one of the duplex units without structurally enlarging the building. Interior renovations will create two additional bedrooms, one in each duplex unit. The lower-level unit will go from three to four bedrooms, and the main level unit will go from four to five bedrooms with a new staircase leading to a living room added to the attic space. The size, design, and operating characteristics of the duplex will otherwise remain substantially the same. The property will continue to operate as a duplex in a residential neighborhood. While zoned RL-1, the neighborhood contains several properties with greater densities than allowed by right in the zone. Staff

Attachment B - Staff Criteria Analysis

finds that adding two additional bedrooms and living space without expanding the number of units on site is reasonably compatible with the use of nearby properties, as several duplexes exist currently within the neighborhood. The zoning code does not limit the number of bedrooms or occupants allowed within a dwelling unit. Legally findings cannot be based on occupancy or potential tenants other than as regulated in the Property Maintenance Code for purposes of fire and life safety concerns. Staff has reviewed the project against standards of the Property Maintenance Code and finds the proposal to comply with those standards. To mitigate some of the concerns about potential impacts raised by neighbors, the applicant proposes to provide long-term bike parking in the existing converted garage / office accessory structure which will encourage bike use and reduce traffic impacts, and reduce the capability of using the space as an illegal bedroom. As such, staff find that the size, design, and operating characteristics of the proposal will be consistent with the current conditions and have minimal negative effects on surrounding properties.

(3) Infrastructure: Yes The use will not significantly adversely affect the infrastructure of the surrounding area, including, without limitation, water, wastewater and storm drainage utilities and streets, compared to an allowed use in the zoning district, or compared to the existing level of impact of a nonconforming use; Staff Response: No new infrastructure is proposed or necessary for the project.

(4) Character of Area: Yes The use will not change the predominant character of the surrounding area or the character established by adopted design guidelines or plans for the area; and Staff Response: There are fifty properties within 300 feet of 969 10th Street that have lot sizes ranging from approximately 2,300 to 12,500 square feet, and all of them contain one or more dwelling units. The average parcel size is 6,190 square feet, and there are only eight lots that meet the minimum 7,000 square foot lot area requirement in the RL-1 zone. Thirty-two of the properties have issued or pending rental licenses. Seventeen properties contain two dwelling units, one property has three dwelling units, and two properties have four dwelling units. See figure 1, below, for a map of properties within 300 feet of the site. Of the fifty properties, forty-two are considered “nonstandard lots,” and twenty properties are potentially “nonconforming uses” due to density, consistent with the definitions found in Chapter 9-16, B.R.C. 1981. Staff find that the predominate character of the area consists of primarily rental properties with a mix of detached style dwellings operating as single-unit, duplex, triplex, and quadplex configurations. As proposed in this project, 969 10th Street will remain a duplex and the proposed interior renovations to expand the floor area and add one new bedroom to each unit will not change the predominate character of the surrounding area.

Attachment B - Staff Criteria Analysis

Figure 1. Properties with rental licenses within a 300' buffer (blue line) around 969 10th St. are highlighted in magenta.

(5) Conversion of Dwelling Units to Nonresidential Uses: N/A There shall be a presumption against approving the conversion of dwelling units in the residential zoning districts to nonresidential uses that are allowed pursuant to a use review, or through the substitution of one nonconforming use with another nonconforming use. The presumption against such a conversion may be overcome by a finding that the use to be approved serves another compelling social, human services, governmental or recreational need in the community, including, without limitation, a use for a daycare center, park, religious assembly, social service use, benevolent organization use, art studio or workshop, museum, or an educational use. Staff Response: The proposal does not convert dwelling units to nonresidential uses. This criterion is not applicable.

(f) Additional Criteria for Expansion of a Nonconforming Use: No application for an expansion of a nonconforming use shall be granted unless all of the following criteria are met in addition to the criteria set forth above: Meets criteria (1) Reasonable Measures Required: The applicant has undertaken all reasonable measures to reduce or alleviate the effects of the nonconformity upon the surrounding area, including, without limitation, objectionable conditions, glare, adverse visual impacts, noise pollution, air emissions, vehicular traffic, storage of equipment, materials and refuse, and on-street parking, so that the expansion will not adversely affect the surrounding area. Staff Response:

Attachment B - Staff Criteria Analysis

The additional floor area and interior renovations within the duplex will not create any additional effects upon the surrounding property since there are no exterior improvements proposed to the duplex. The structure will maintain its existing appearance and not create any new objectionable conditions including glare or adverse visual impacts. There is no new HVAC or other equipment proposed that would result in additional noise pollution or air emissions associated with the residential use, nor is there any additional storage of equipment, materials, or refuse associated with the use. The proposal will maintain the existing driveway from 10th Street to allow for continued off-street parking. There is no minimum number of off-street parking spaces required by the zoning code. On-street parking along 10th Street is within the University Hill parking district and managed through the Neighborhood Parking Permit program. Any resident with a driver’s license living in the parking district is eligible for a residential neighborhood parking permit and can park anywhere throughout the district. Trip generation and traffic impacts for residential uses are typically based on the number of dwelling units. Since the number of dwelling units will remain the same it is not anticipated that a significant traffic increase will be generated by the proposal. The addition of long-term bike parking provided on site will encourage bike use to alleviate potential traffic impacts. The nonconformity is based on the existing number of dwelling units per lot area, rather than the number of occupants, and the structure will continue to operate as duplex, as it has since it was legally permitted in 1971. As the intensity and nature of the existing use is not increasing, it is not anticipated that the proposed 3.6% interior floor area expansion will adversely affect the surrounding area.

(2) Reduction in Nonconformity/Improvement of Appearance: Yes The proposed expansion will either reduce the degree of nonconformity of the use or improve the physical appearance of the structure or the site without increasing the degree of nonconformity. The property is nonconforming due to the number of dwelling units on the property. In order to reduce the degree of nonconformity, an existing dwelling unit would need to be removed. The lower-level unit is too large to qualify as an accessory dwelling unit. As such, it is not reasonable to reduce the degree of nonconformity. The proposal to convert the attic to additional floor area and add two new bedrooms through interior renovations does not increase the degree of nonconformity because the number of dwelling units will remain the same. The applicant proposes to improve the physical appearance of the structure by repairing damaged railing and steps at the front entry, repairing the fence along the rear property line, and adding new landscaping to the front yard. Additional modifications include removing a storage shed and reducing the size of the deck in the back yard to meet building coverage requirements of the RL-1 zone and providing new long-term bike parking in the existing garage accessory structure in the rear yard. Given the existing condition of the building and proposed improvements to the appearance of the building and the property, staff find this criterion to be met.

(3) Compliance With This Title: Yes The expansion complies with all other applicable requirements of this title. The proposed attic conversion to usable floor area and addition of bedrooms constitutes the expansion of the dwelling unit subject to this review. The proposal complies with the applicable requirements of Title 9, Land Use Code.

(4) Cannot Reasonably Be Made Conforming: Yes The existing building or lot cannot reasonably be utilized or made to conform to the requirements of Chapter 9-6, "Use Standards," 9-7, "Form and Bulk Standards," 9-8, "Intensity Standards," or 9-9, "Development Standards," B.R.C. 1981. This paragraph (4) shall not apply to reconstruction or restoration permitted pursuant to Paragraph 9-10-3(c)(4), B.R.C. 1981, with respect to density and other pre-existing nonconformities of the use or nonstandard features of the building.

Attachment B - Staff Criteria Analysis

The site is nonconforming to the density requirements because it contains two dwelling units where only one could be allowed under the current zoning requirements. The use cannot be made to conform to the requirements of this code criterion without eliminating a dwelling unit. As such, the legal nonconforming use cannot reasonably be made conforming.

(5) No Increase in Floor Area Over Ten Percent: Yes The expansion will not result in a cumulative increase in floor area of more than ten percent of the existing floor area. The additional proposed floor area will increase the overall floor area by 95 square feet, which is 3.6 percent of the existing floor area.

(6) Approving Authority May Grant Zoning Variances: N/A The approving authority may grant the variances permitted by Subsection 9-2-3(d), B.R.C. 1981, upon finding that the criteria set forth in Subsection 9-2-3(h), B.R.C. 1981, have been met. No zoning variances are requested in this proposal.