Boulder City Council · Document
Call-Up Agenda Memo
Special Meeting, November 12, 2026 · item 3C: Consideration of a Nonconforming Use Review for the property located at 969 10th Street. The application proposes expansion of an existing d… · 18 pages
This is the text extracted from the file, without its layout, tables, or images. Use the original for anything that matters.
City of Boulder City Council Agenda Item Meeting Date: November 12, 2026
Agenda Title Consideration of a Nonconforming Use Review for the property located at 969 10th Street. The application proposes expansion of an existing duplex by converting interior attic space to habitable floor area and the addition of one new bedroom to each unit through interior renovations. No exterior expansion or addition to the building is proposed. Reviewed under case number LUR2025-00091. Applicant: K Works Studio; Owner: Monticello Ventures – Hardees, LLC
Staff Contact • •
Alex Pichacz, Senior City Planner, Planning and Development Services Brad Muller, Planning Director, Planning and Development Services
Draft Motion Language Staff requests council consideration of this matter and recommends action in the form of the following motion: Motion to approve Use Review application #LUR2025-00091, adopting the staff memorandum as findings of fact, including the attached analysis of review criteria, subject to the recommended conditions of approval.
Executive Summary The purpose of this item is for the City Council to hold a public hearing, review and take action on the Nonconforming Use Review application. The Planning Board approval
was called up to a public hearing by City Council at the September 17, 2026 council meeting. The application proposes expansion of the existing duplex at 969 10th Street through interior renovations to add one new bedroom to each unit and conversion of interior attic space into habitable floor area. No exterior modification or expansion to the building is proposed. Through a Nonconforming Use Review, the floor area of a structure may by expanded up to 10 percent, and the applicant is proposing to expand the existing floor area of the duplex by 95 square feet which is an increase of 3.6 percent. A Nonconforming Use Review is required because the duplex is an existing legal nonconforming use located in the RL-1 zoning district. The duplex is on a lot that is 6,250 square feet and does not conform to the typical density requirements of Chapter 9-8 Intensity Standards, B.R.C. 1981 which otherwise requires a minimum lot area per dwelling unit of 7,000 square feet. The existing duplex was recognized as a legal nonconforming use in 1971 according to city building permit records. The nonconformity is based on the existing number of dwelling units per lot area, rather than the number of occupants or bedrooms. To reduce the degree of nonconformity, an existing dwelling unit would need to be removed. The applicant originally requested that a decision be made on this application by the Planning Board through a public hearing. Planning Board approved the application with conditions as indicated below under “Planning Board History.” Staff recommends approval of the Nonconforming Use Review application finding the proposal consistent with relevant Use Review Standards and Additional Criteria for Expansion of a Nonconforming Use, as outlined within this memorandum, subject to conditions of approval. A full staff analysis of the review criteria for the approval recommendation by staff can be found in Attachment A. The Planning Board disposition on the item can be found in Attachment B. The applicant’s proposed plans can be found in Attachment C. Public comments provided during the review process can be found in Attachment D.
Council Action Options Option
Outcome
If Council finds that the application meets the review criteria with the recommended conditions of approval, approve the application with conditions as recommended by staff.
If the application is approved, the applicant will be able to proceed with the proposal.
If Council finds that the Application does not meet the review criteria but would meet them subject to amended or additional conditions of approval, approve the Application with amended or additional conditions of approval.
Council will need to draft any modifications to the draft motion language and approval, based on the criteria for review. Upon approval, the applicant would be able to proceed with the proposal subject to the revised conditions of approval.
If Council finds that the application does not meet the review criteria (even with conditions of approval), Council must deny the application.
If the application is denied, the applicant will not be able to proceed with the proposal.
Planning Board History At the public hearing on August 18, 2026, the Planning Board held a quasi-judicial hearing to review the proposed Nonconforming Use Review application. Following staff and application presentations and a public hearing, the Board deliberated on the applicable review criteria and asked clarifying questions to staff pertaining to interpretations of the review criteria. M. McIntyre, seconded by K. Nordback, moved to deny the application for failure to meet criteria 9-2-15(f)(1) and (2) B.R.C. 1981. The motion failed on a vote of 2:6 (ML Robles was absent) and additional deliberation followed. The Planning Board approved the request with the following motions: Motion by C. Hanson Thiem and seconded by M. Roberts to approve Use Review application #LUR2025-00091, adopting the staff memorandum as findings of fact, including the attached analysis of review criteria, subject to the recommended conditions of approval recommended in the staff memorandum, as amended by the planning board with the following motions: Motion to amend the main motion by K. Nordback, seconded by C. Hanson Thiem, to add a condition of approval to require that the applicant submit a trash management plan including separate trash cans for each unit, subject to city manager approval, and ensure that the development is in compliance with the approved trash management plan. Additionally, the owner will be required to post on the property prominent signage visible from the public way listing the property manager or management company and contact information. Planning Board voted 6-0. Motion passed.
Motion to amend by C. Hanson Thiem, seconded by M. McIntyre, to add a condition to require the accessory office/studio space have a dedicated use as bike parking and storage, and that this use be recorded with the County (similar to what is being required for the attic space), to meet the criteria in 9-2-15(f)(1) requiring reasonable measures to reduce or alleviate the effects of the nonconformity. Planning Board voted 6-0. Motion passed. The board voted on the main motion made by C. Hanson Thiem, as amended with the additional conditions of approval noted above. Planning Board voted 5-1 (M. McIntyre dissenting, M. Robles absent). Motion passed. Staff incorporated Planning Board’s conditions into the conditions of approval recommended for adoption by Council.
Public Input Process Consistent with Section 9-4-3, “Public Notice Requirements,” B.R.C. 1981, staff provided notification to all property owners within 600 feet of the subject location of the application, and signs were posted by the applicant. Staff received comments from several neighbors as part of the Use Review process. Concerns were regarding existing nuisance issues in the neighborhood and with previous tenants, neighborhood safety, the increased density of students in the neighborhood, investor-owned rental properties, traffic impacts, and broader housing policy questions for the City. Written public comments received during the review process are included in Appendix D.
Project Description and Analysis – Alignment with Relevant Portions of Boulder Revised Code Background Location. The site is in the University Hill neighborhood and consists of a 6,250 squarefoot lot developed with an existing brick structure containing two dwelling units, on the west side of 10th Street, between Euclid and Aurora Avenues. Refer to Figure 1 below. The property also contains a detached garage that was converted into an office/studio space through a building permit process in 1993 and a small storage shed. The property takes access from an existing driveway off 10th street. At the rear of the property is an alley used for garbage and recycling collection. There is no vehicular access taken from the alley.
A streetview image of the property is shown below, in Figure 2. Access to the main floor unit is taken from the front door, and access to the lower-level unit is taken from the sidewalk on the north side of the building, to the right side of the front porch.
Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan (BVCP) Land Use Designation. The application was submitted prior to the 2025 BVCP major update and reviewed under the previous version of the comprehensive plan. As shown in Figure 3, the BVCP designation at time of application was Low Density Residential.
The Low Density Residential land use designation is defined as:
The property is not located within any adopted area or subcommunity plans, nor is it located in a historic district or floodplain area. Zoning. As shown in Figure 4, the property is located in the Residential-Low 1 (RL-1) zoning district, which is described in 9-5-2(c)(1)(A), B.R.C. 1981, as “Primarily detached dwelling units with some duplexes and attached dwelling units at low to very low residential densities.” The intensity standards in Chapter 9-8, B.R.C. 1981, allow for one dwelling unit per 7,000 square feet of lot area. In the RL-1 zone, duplexes or two detached dwelling units are allowed by-right if the property is within 350-feet of a transit corridor and the lot or parcel is at least 3,500 square feet. However, this standard does not apply to 969 10th Street as it is 750 feet from College Avenue, the nearest designated transit corridor.
Surroundings. The site is surrounded by a mix of residential uses with primarily
detached dwelling style appearances. Most of the principal buildings were constructed in the early 1900s. As shown in Figure 5, there are fifty nearby properties within a 300foot radius of 969 10th Street. The age of the principal buildings on each lot ranges between 1895 and 1987, with the average building year of 1917. Of the fifty properties, the average lot size is 6,190 square feet and only eight lots meet or exceed the required 7,000 square foot minimum lot size of the RL-1 zone. Thirty-two out of the fifty properties have issued or pending rental licenses. Seventeen properties contain two dwelling units, one property has three dwelling units, and two properties have four dwelling units. As such, forty-two of the fifty nearby properties are considered “nonstandard lots” because they are less than 7,000 square feet in size, and twenty properties contain “nonconforming uses” because they exceed the density requirement of one dwelling unit per 7,000 square feet of lot area, as listed in Table: 8-1 Intensity Standards, B.R.C. 1981.
Site History. According to Boulder County tax assessor records, the principal building at 969 10th Street was constructed in 1909. In 1971 the building was first recognized through a City building permit zoning inspection record as a legal nonconforming duplex, shown in Figure 6, meaning it was legal at the time it was built. The zoning inspection record references a utility inspection indicating two units on the property dating back to 1953. The property and principal building have remained substantially the same according to the building permit history, with no significant changes to the structure. In 1993, the detached garage in the rear yard was converted to an office through building permit number 936778. No plumbing was included in the garage conversion.
Project Description Interior Changes. The existing duplex operates on two levels with an upper, main level unit and a lower-level unit. Access to the main level unit is taken from the front door and side door on the north side. The lower-level unit is accessed from the side door on the north side. The main level unit currently has four bedrooms and two bathrooms, and the lower-level unit currently has three bedrooms and one bathroom. Interior renovations to both units is proposed to reconfigure the existing floor area to include one new bedroom in each unit and a new bathroom in the main level unit. The proposed floor plan will include five bedrooms and three bathrooms in the main level unit, and four bedrooms and one bathroom in the lower-level unit. Refer to Figures 7 and 8 for the existing and proposed floor plans and Attachment C for the complete plan set. Floor Area. The proposal will expand floor area of the duplex by adding an interior staircase in the main level unit to access new upstairs living space. The floor area expansion will provide 238 feet of usable floor area in a previously uninhabitable space. The maximum allowed floor area for the property is 3,350 square feet. Through an expansion of a nonconforming use review, the existing floor area can be expanded up to 10 percent, or 2,879 square feet. The applicant is proposing a 3.6 percent increase for a proposed floor area of 2,713 square feet.
Occupancy. The Title 9 Land Use Code, B.R.C. 1981, does not regulate the number of occupants, interior layout, or number of bedrooms in dwelling units. Occupancy limitations are determined through the building permit process and regulated by the occupancy limitations of Chapter 10-2, "Property Maintenance Code," B.R.C. 1981.
Staff from the City’s building code division reviewed the proposed floor plans for preliminary compliance with Title 10 and the International Property Maintenance code and found the project to be generally consistent with the requirements. The proposed floor plans will be required to be reviewed again through a subsequent building permit process if the proposed expansion of a nonconforming use review is approved. Exterior Changes. There are no exterior expansion or structural modifications proposed to the duplex building. The applicant proposes to remove a small shed and reduce the size of the exterior deck in the back yard that was constructed by a previous owner without a permit to bring the site into compliance with the building coverage requirements of the RL-1 zone. The proposed landscaping improvements are shown below, in Figure 9.
Open Space – There is no minimum open space requirement in the RL-1 zone. Open space on the site will include landscaped areas in the front and back yards, a sidewalk
to the front door, and separate sidewalk on the south side of the lot to the side entrance and rear yard. The front yard landscaping will be updated to provide new low-water plantings including native shrubs and perennial grasses, and a new irrigation system in compliance with the landscaping standards of section 9-9-12, B.R.C. 1981. The existing landscaping in the rear yard will be maintained. A small storage shed and a portion of the elevated deck will be removed to meet the building coverage requirements of the RL-1 zone. Architecture and Massing – The proposal will maintain the existing one-story brick and wood structure as it has existed on the site since the early 1900s. The applicant proposes to repair the existing front porch stairs and railing to improve the appearance of the structure. Access and Parking – The existing driveway access from 10th Street will remain to provide off street parking. The proposal will provide long-term bike parking spaces in the detached garage that was converted to an office in 1993. Bike parking will be used for both dwelling units and includes 5 long-term bike parking spaces, consistent with parking standards found in Section 9-9-6, B.R.C. 1981.
Process Use Review. A Use Review is required because the property contains a legal nonconforming use. As described in the purpose statement in section 9-2-15(a), “nonconforming uses may be upgraded or expanded through a Use Review process if the change would not adversely affect the traffic and the environment of the surrounding area or if the change would reduce the degree of the nonconformity or improve the appearance of the structure or site without increasing the degree of nonconformity.” A Use Review for a nonconforming use is subject to the Use Review criteria in Section 9-2-15(e), B.R.C. 1981, and the Additional Criteria for Expansion of a Nonconforming Use in Section 9-2-15(f), B.R.C. 1981.
Analysis / Key Issues Key Issue #1: Is the proposal consistent with the Use Review and additional criteria for nonconforming use reviews of section 9-2-15(e) and (f), B.R.C. 1981? Staff finds that the proposed use is consistent with the applicable Use Review criteria in Section 9-2-15(e), B.R.C. 1981, and the Additional Criteria for Expansion of a Nonconforming Use in Section 9-2-15(f), B.R.C. 1981.
Use Review Criteria. The applicable Use Review criteria are intended to ensure that a use will be reasonably compatible with and have minimal negative impact on the use of nearby properties and will not change the character of the area. The nonconformity is based on the existing number of dwelling units per lot area, rather than the number of occupants or bedrooms. After the proposed floor area expansion, the structure will continue to operate as duplex as it has since it was legally permitted in 1971. Refer to the full staff analysis provided in Attachment A. Additional Criteria for Expansion of a Nonconforming Use. The nonconforming use criteria are broadly written to apply to any nonconforming use in any zoning district to allow for upgrades or expansions of nonconforming uses. Generally, they require that: • • • •
all reasonable measures are taken to reduce or alleviate the effects of the nonconformity upon the surrounding area, the project either reduces the degree of nonconformity of the use or improves the physical appearance of the structure or site, the project cannot reasonably be made conforming, and the floor area is not expanded over 10 percent of the existing floor area.
After the proposed 3.6 percent floor area expansion, the duplex would continue to operate in the same manner as it has for decades since it was recognized as a legal nonconforming use in 1971. There are no exterior expansions or modifications of the structure or changes to the nature of the duplex use that would create additional adverse effects on the surrounding area. The property is only nonconforming due to the number of dwelling units rather than occupancy since occupancy is not regulated by the zoning code. To reduce the degree of nonconformity, an existing dwelling unit would need to be removed. Limiting the number of occupants does not reduce the degree of nonconformity since it will still operate as a duplex. Eliminating a dwelling unit of the legally established nonconforming use is not a reasonable request. The applicant is proposing to improve the appearance of the structure and site through repairing the front steps and railing and providing new landscaping in the front yard, and the floor area expansion will stay below the allowed 10 percent maximum expansion of existing floor area. To mitigate some of the concerns raised by neighbors, the applicant proposes to provide long-term bike parking in the existing garage / studio accessory structure which will reduce the capability of using the space as an illegal bedroom. As a recommended condition of approval, the applicant would be required to execute and record with the Boulder County Clerk and Recorder, in a form approved by the City of Boulder, a signed Declaration of Use against the subject property indicating that the attic will not be used as a bedroom or dwelling unit. In response to the public testimony received during the Planning Board hearing, the Planning Board added two additional
conditions of approval included in the recommended conditions of approval, below. The first condition added requires a sign to be posted on the property listing the name and contact information for the property management company, and the second is to provide a separate trash cans for each unit and submit a trash management plan to the city to be approved by the city manager. As such, staff find that the size, design, and operating characteristics of the proposal will be consistent with the current conditions and have minimal negative effects on surrounding properties. Refer to the full staff analysis provided in Attachment A.
Public Comments Public notice was mailed to property owners within 600 feet, and a sign was posted on the property. Staff received several public comments from 13 neighbors which are included in Appendix D. The concerns from neighbors were primarily regarding noise from tenants, unsecured and overflowing trash cans in the alley, illegal use of the neighbors’ trash cans, traffic and parking concerns, over-occupancy of units, and the illegal use of the office accessory structure as a bedroom. Although issues with tenant behavior were raised by neighbors, these concerns are already regulated by the city’s code enforcement program and police department and are not violations of the zoning code criteria for purposes of this review.
Staff Findings and Recommendation Staff and the Planning Board find the application meets the Use Review criteria of Section 9-2-15(e) and (f), B.R.C. 1981, and recommends that the City Council approve the applications in the form of the following motion: Motion to approve Use Review application #LUR2025-00091, adopting the staff memorandum as findings of fact, including the attached analysis of review criteria, subject to the recommended conditions of approval.
Recommended Conditions of Approval 1. The Applicant shall ensure that the development shall be in compliance with all plans prepared by the Applicant on May 15, 2026, and the Applicant’s Written Statement dated January 17, 2026, all on file in the City of Boulder Planning Department, except to the extent that the development may be modified by the conditions of this approval. 2. Prior to building permit issuance, the Applicant shall execute and record with the Boulder County Clerk and Recorder, in a form approved by the City of Boulder, a signed Declaration of Use against the Property indicating that the attic of the
principal building will not be used as a bedroom or dwelling unit and that the detached garage is dedicated to use as bike parking and storage space.
3. Prior to building permit issuance, the Applicant shall submit to the City a trash management plan including separate trash cans for each unit, subject to city manager approval. The Applicant shall ensure that the development is in compliance with the approved trash management plan. 4. The Applicant shall post prominent signage on the Property that is visible from the public right-of-way listing the property manager or management company and their contact information. 5. The Applicant shall not expand or modify the approved use, except pursuant to Subsection 9-2-15(h), B.R.C. 1981.
Fiscal Impacts Review of this project is part of the P&DS team’s standard workplan and its impacts are incorporated into the annual revenue forecasting as part of the Budget office’s annual budget development. Therefore, review of the project will not have a meaningful fiscal impact past what has already been included in the approved budget.
Current Year Estimated Fiscal Impact Fund(s): 2120FD Department(s): Planning & Development Services Program(s): All P&DS programs
Item Beginning Fund Balance Total Forecasted Revenue
FY 2026 Budget
FY 2026 Estimated Impact
FY 2026 Net Change
$18,200,885
$0
$18,200,885
$15,179,491
$0
$15,179,491
Total Estimated Expenses Ending Fund Balance(s) After Reserves FTE
$17,735,173
$0
$17,735,173
$12,646,701
$0
$12,646,701
122.65
0
122.65
Three-Year Estimated Fiscal Impact
Item
FY 2026
FY 2027
FY 2028
Total Forecasted Revenue Total Estimated Expenses Net Estimated Impact
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Accessibility Statement The City of Boulder is committed to digital accessibility. Some content may not be fully accessible due to technical limitations or issues. For alternate formats or accommodations, please visit Accessibility | City of Boulder or contact accessibility@bouldercolorado.gov.
Attachments A: Staff analysis of review criteria B: Planning Board Disposition C: Applicant’s Proposed Plans and Written Statement D: Written Public Comments