Boulder City Council · Special Meeting, November 12, 2026
Transcript
Auto-generated captions, 28k words. No speaker names. Names are often misspelled. Timestamps are the video clock; click one to open the video there.
0:05:1126 special meeting. >> Welcome everyone to the Thursday, November 12th, 2026 special meeting of the Boulder City Council. And Elisha, I should confirm that we're ready to go from a technical perspective. >> Yes, sir. Channel 8 is ready to go. >> Fantastic. Okay, I will go ahead and call this meeting to order. And Elicia, can we have a roll call, please? >> Yes, sir. Thank you, and welcome back, everyone. We will start the night's roll call as usual with Council Member Adams, >> present. >> Benjamin, >> present. >> Mayor Brockett, >> present. >> Council member Kaplan, >> present. >> Marquis, >> present. Shuar >> here, >> Spear >> present >> and Mayor Pro Tim Wer >> present. >> Mayor, we have our quorum. >> Fantastic. Um, if I could start please by getting a motion to amend the agenda to add item 2F, which is introduction and consideration of a motion to publish by title only and adopt by emergency measure emergency ordinance 8791 amending section 3142 imposition and rate of tax BRC1981 increasing the 3.5% sales and use tax to 5.5% and setting forth related details.
1 Call to Order and Roll Call
0:06:29>> So moved. >> Second. We have a motion and a second. Um, everyone in favor, please raise your hand. Okay. Can I get a confirmation that that's everybody? I don't have my view set up quite right. >> That is everybody. >> Okay, great. So, that passes unanimously. So, the uh agenda has been amended. So, Alish, if we can go to our consent agenda, please. >> Yes, sir. Our consent agenda is item number two on tonight's agenda and it consists of items 2 A through 2F. >> Very good. Any uh questions or comments on the consent agenda? >> I just have a quick question if that's okay, >> please. >> Okay. So, the sister cities, I know that we weren't quite done with it. Do you do you have an update for when that's going to be uh done or >> uh Yeah. No, I appreciate it. I think we had incorporated some of the direction that you all provided um as we move forward and I don't see Pam here so we can get you some specific data and I can circle back but we did lean into the uh direction um and I I have to pull it up and right now I am unable to pull my outlook up to let you know >> and N if I may add there is the
2A Consideration of a motion to approve the July 23, 2026 Special City Council Meeting Minutes
0:07:52resolution and with proposed changes and the draft charter will be presented to council at the next meeting uh next week on the 19th. >> Excellent. E I don't know why I was looking for Pam with you right there. Thank you. >> That's okay. Teamwork to make the dream work. >> Uh Ryan, you have a something. >> Thanks. Uh yeah, question on F the um emergency ordinance. Um could staff just speak to why it's an emergency? Um you know, just something along the lines of why is it a rush? Um what's going on? And and while you answer that question, if you can just be clear about what sales tax is being increased to because that's helpful for folks to know. >> Sure. I see Christa coming up. I know it's a timing issue because we are limited in when we can bring this forward next year. Christa, if there's some additional detail that you can provide, that'd be great.
0:08:44>> Absolutely. Well, good evening, Mayor Bracka, members of city council. Christa Morrison, chief financial officer. Um so just for a little background um this item was actually brought forward in the 2027 budget and it proposed an increase in additional recreational marijuana sales tax from 3.5 to 5.5%. Uh this was presented during the 2027 uh budget discussions with city council over three sessions and this was passed with the budget. So the proposed ordinance will amend the section of the code to reflect this change in the adopted budget. Why this is being brought forward as an emergency ordinance is that the uh city is required for any sales or use tax cha tax changes to notify the Colorado Department of Revenue uh 45 days in advance of an effective date. And there are two opportunities in the year with that change. either January 1st or July 1st. So, we're bringing it forward as an emergency uh to meet that 45day window with a January 1st effective date.
0:10:06>> Thanks. >> Thanks for that answer, Christ. I appreciate it. Um any further questions or possibly a motion on the consent agenda? >> I move the consent agenda. >> Second. We've got a motion and a second. Elicia, can we have a roll call, please? >> Yes, sir. We'll start the roll call for the consent agenda items 2A through 2F with Council Member Spear. >> Yes. >> Mayor Pro Tim Wire. >> Yes. >> Council member Adams. >> Sorry. Yes. >> Benjamin. >> Yes. >> Mayor Brackett. >> Yes. Council member Kaplan, >> yes. >> Marquis, >> yes. >> And Shuhar, >> yes. >> The consent agenda is hereby approved unanimously. >> Good. Thanks so much. All right. Now, if I could request a motion to suspend council rules or procedures 4A 6 to allow for three public hearings this evening.
0:11:13>> So moved. >> Second. A motion to second. All in favor, please raise your physical hand. Okay, that passes unanimously. Got my viewing viewing gallery set up now. So, I saw that. Thanks everyone. So, uh the rules and procedures have been suspended for that purpose. So, Elicia, can we go to our public hearing item 3A, please? >> Yes, sir. Thank you. Item 3A on tonight's agenda is the consideration of following items related to a petition to annex approximately 5.43 43 acres of land located at 1275 Cherryville Road and 5995 Maxori Lane. Our first item for consideration is the consideration of a motion to change the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan land use map designation of the properties from rural lands to neighborhood one. Our second item is the motion to adopt resolution 1384 setting forth findings of facts and conclusions regarding the annexation of approximately 5.43 acres of land. And our last item is the second reading and motion to adopt ordinance 8764 amending the city of Boulder approximately I mean annexing to the city of Boulder approximately 5.43 43 acres of land with an initial zoning designation of residential R2 as described in chapter 9-5 modular zone systems BRC1981 amending the zoning district map forming a part of said chapter to include said land in the above mentioned zoning
3A Consideration of the following items related to a petition to annex approximately 5.43 acres of land located at 1275 Cherryvale Rd. and 5995 McSorley Ln: Consideration of a motion to change the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan (BVCP) land use map designation of the properties from Rural Lands to Neighborhood 1. AND Motion to adopt Resolution 1384 setting Forth Findings of Fact and Conclusions regarding the annexation of approximately 5.43 acres of land. AND Second reading and motion to adopt Ordinance 8764, annexing to the City of Boulder approximately 5.43 acres of land with an initial zoning designation of Residential – Rural 2 (RR-2) as described in Chapter 9-5, “Modular Zone System,” B.R.C. 1981; amending the Zoning District Map forming a part of said Chapter to include said land in the above-mentioned zoning district; and setting forth related details. (LUR2025-000149). Staff Time: 15 Min Council Time: 45 Min
0:12:53district and setting forth those related details. This is reviewed under LUR2025-0000149. >> Thank you so much, E. Oh, thanks, Mayor. I was going to say this is a night of uh planning and development uh services glory as we have three public hearings before us. And for this first one, Allison, coming to you, I believe. >> Thank you. I'm just requesting permission to share my screen. It's just granite, Alison. Thank you. >> Thank you, Alicia. >> Great. Uh, good evening everyone. My name is Allison Blaine and I will be presenting this next item. In tonight's presentation, I will briefly cover the information in staff's memo, including a description of the process, summary of the project, and key issues for discussion. Staff first presented the annexation application before planning board on July 28th, 2026, where the board unanimously recommended approval of the proposed annexation and initial zoning.
0:14:11In August 2026, after the initial planning board hearing, the city and county approved a major update to the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan, which included designating all area 2 properties as rural lands. The annexation then went before city council on October 1st for first reading. But because the BBCP changed the city's annexation process and now requires a concurrent land use amendment from rural lands to a non-ruural designation, the item had to go back to planning board for a vote on the land use map change only. The planning board unanimously approved the change on October 27th and tonight's hearing is the final step in this process for city council to make a decision on the proposed annexation initial zoning and land use map change. Note that because this application was received and reviewed prior to the major update findings on consistency with the comp plan policies and the area designation referred to the 2020 BBCP.
0:15:05Annexation is the process to incorporate land into city boundaries. Such application is reviewed for cons consistency with state statute and Colorado constitution and all proposed annexations must meet state statutes. An annexation must also meet city ordinances and policies of the BBCP. Specifically, policies related to annexation limits on expansion and growth requirements. Land that has redevelopment potential must provide a special opportunity to the city or community benefit in order to reduce negative impacts that may be associated with new development. When a property is annexed, zoning is established according to the BBCP and must be consistent with the existing development patterns. Due to the recent BBCP major update, a concurrent land use map changes required with annexations in order to stay in compliance with the comp plan. That change is reviewed against the criteria described in appendix B of the comp plan.
0:15:58The project completed the necessary notice requirements per code. Written notice was sent to property owners within 600 feet and public notice uh public signs were past posted on the property as well. Because of the BBCP map change, staff provided notification of the change to the property owner and posted the memorandum on the city's website as required per appendix B. Staff received a few phone in uh inquiries about the project as well as formal formal comment which was included in the packet. The subject site is located along the eastern boundary city limits along Cherryville Road just south of Arapjo Road and is comprised of two parcels addressed at 1275 Cherryville Road and 5995 Mixurland Lane. Due to the proximity of South Boulder Creek along the western edge of the Cherry Veil properties, the annexation is heavily impacted by high functioning wetlands, high hazard conveyance, 100-year and 500year flood planes.
0:16:56At time of initial application, the Cherryville property contained a two-story detached dwelling unit, two mobile homes, garage, and several accessory buildings, including sheds, yurt, and a greenhouse. The Mixolio property contained a detached dwelling unit and several sheds. The Cherry Bell property is already served by city sewer connections through ordinance 4644 recorded in 1982. The property also obtained an out of city agreement and revocable permit for water service signed in 2010. The Mixurly property is served by an existing on-site wastewater treatment system for sewer and a well for domestic water. The site is located in area 2 on the planning areas map of the BBCP. Area 2 is a service area of the city where annexation be can be considered as long as it meets BBCP policies on growth management, growth requirements, and annexation. The property is designated as rural lands which requires a concurrent land use map change to be approved at time of annexation. The proposed designation is neighborhood one which is the lowest density residential land use designation and is consistent with nearby properties that are within city limits.
0:18:01Neighborhood one anticipates community uses such as places of worship. Note that this property also contains a greenways designation along the creek which is not proposed to change as part of this land use map change. That portion will be preserved from future development with the flood control easement. The applicant is requesting RR2 zoning consistent with the surrounding properties within the city and adjacent to the site. The RR2 district is described as primarily detached dwelling units with some duplexes and attached dwelling units at low to very low residential densities. An annexation agreement is required as part of the process and annexation terms are written to anticipate any future development of the property. As part of that agreement, the applicant must provide dedication of a flood control easement to the city for the purpose of drainage conveyance, control flood waters, and installation and maintenance of flood control and conveyance improvements. The applicant will also be required to provide public access easements along Cherryville Road and Mixurly Lane for future rightway improvements.
0:19:03The site does have potential to subdivide in the future due to the size of the lot. Therefore, community benefit is required and will be met with 1.5 times the cash inlue amount for future redevelopment. Additionally, as a condition of annexation, the applicant will be required to close off an access from Chair Veil Road to reduce the amount of conflict points between vehicles and non-vehicle users and enable safety improvements for all travelers. There were four key issues identified by staff in the memo um regarding the project's consistency with state statutes, consistency with the city's annexation policies, the surrounding and proposed zoning and land use map change criteria. Um they will be detailed on the following slides. For key issue one, staff finds the annexation petition complies with the applicable state annexation statutes. The site meets the 16 contiguity requirement to the city and there is a community interest to annex the site as it is capable of being integrated into the city.
0:20:02For key issue two staff finds that the proposal is consistent with the BDCP and city policies. The site is in area 2 and therefore can be considered for annexation. The annexation will allow for the connection of the Mixurly property to city's water systems, thus providing a public health benefit. And the property has some potential to be redeveloped and therefore provides a benefit to the city in form of cash and lies and dedication of flood conveyance and public as access easements meeting policy 1.17D of the BBCP. For key issue three, staff finds that the proposed zoning of RR2 is consistent with the surrounding area and the community's desired future for the area. The proposed land use map change to neighborhood 1 is the lowest density residential designation and therefore the proposed zoning is consistent with the BBCP.
0:20:55For key issue four, the BBCP land use map change is necessary to update the existing future land use map designation from rural lands to neighborhood one as required as part of the 2025 major update. Staff finds the proposal consistent with the criteria for the land use map change. The change is consistent with the policies and intent of the comp plan and is an expected procedural step for all annexations currently designated rural lands. Therefore, staff recommends that city council adopt the following motions. And that concludes my presentation and I will open it up for questions. Thank you. >> Thanks so much, Alison. Appreciate that. Any questions for city staff? All right. Not seeing any questions. I I will note that um to my knowledge, for the only time in modern council history, there's no one signed up for any of our public hearings this evening. So, uh I will open the public hearing and then close that and then look to council members for any um comments on this matter.
0:22:17I'm not seeing any comments. Alicia, I'm going to ask a procedural question. There are three items related to this matter. Do those need to be um separate motions and would they need to be um voted on by roll call for each of them? >> Uh you're muted. >> Turn my camera on but not my mic. Yes, sir. To both questions. >> Okay. Not seeing any comments. Would anyone be interested in getting us started with the motion if you have it in front of you? or Alicia, perhaps we could get that in the the motion language in the chat. >> Yes, sir. I will take care of that now. Give me just a sec. Copying it now. and I will get it in the chat. >> I'm going to go ahead and get us started. So, um I will go ahead and move that we change the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan land use map designation of the properties from rural lands to neighborhood one.
0:23:36>> Second. >> All right. And I will just uh speak to this briefly just saying that um this seems like a very reasonable annexation proposal and looking forward to get getting these folks annexed into the city um going forward. And with that, if we can have a roll call, please. >> All right, sir. We'll start the motion I mean the roll call for the motion to change the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan with Mayor Pro Tim Wer. >> Yes. >> Council member Adams. >> Yes. >> Benjamin, >> yes. >> Mayor Brock, >> yes. >> Council member Kaplan, >> yes. >> Marquis, >> yes. >> Shuhar, >> yes. >> And Spear, >> yes. The motion to change the voter valley comprehensive plan is hereby approved unanimously and the chat now has all the motion language included. >> Well, if no one objects, I'll just keep going. So, I move that we adopt resolution 1384 setting forth findings of facts and conclusions regarding the annexation of approximately 5.43 acres of land.
0:25:02>> Second. Lisha, can we have a roll call on that motion in a second, please? >> Yes, sir. We'll start the motion to adopt resolution 1384 with Council Member Adams. >> Yes. >> Benjamin, >> yes. >> Mayor Mayor Brockett, >> yes. >> Council member Kaplan, >> yes. >> Marquus, >> yes. Shuhard, >> yes. >> Spear, >> yes. >> And Mayor Pro Tim Winer, >> yes. >> Ordinance, I'm sorry. Resolution 1384 is hereby adopted unanimously. >> Go ahead and finish us out with a bunch of words here. So, I will um move to adopt ordinance 87. No, that's the wrong one. I will move to adopt ordinance 8764 annexing to the city of Boulder approximately 5.43 43 acres of land with an initial zoning designation of residential rural 2 RR2 as described in chapter 95 modular zone system BRC1981 amending the zoning district map forming a part of said chapter to include said land in the above mentioned zoning district and setting forth related details under LUR2025-0000149 >> second that motion in a second one final roll call on this item Please show.
0:26:31>> Yes, sir. We'll start the roll call to adopt ordinance 8764 with Council Member Benjamin. >> Yes. >> Mayor Brockett, >> yes. >> Council member Kaplan, >> yes. >> Marquis, >> yes. >> Shuhart, >> yes. >> Spear, >> yes. >> Mayor Pro Tim Winer, >> yes. and council member Adams. >> Yes. >> Ordinance 8764 is hereby adopted unanimously. >> Fantastic. Thanks so much. We can go right on ahead to our next public hearing item 3B, please. >> Mayor, I just had a quick question. >> Yes. >> Uh just procedural. Um the memo had the resolution, the second one we did as uh 1383. The the agenda had it as 1384. Just wanted to make sure 84 was the right was was the one. >> If I may, um, there was an addendum that was circulated through the hotline and also attached as your last attachment in your packet which made that correction.
0:27:41>> Okay. Thank you. >> Thanks for checking in on that, Nicole. All right. So, let's go to item 3B, please. >> Yes, sir. 3B. Our second public hearing is the second reading and consideration of a motion to adopt ordinance 8782 reszoning 14.84 84 acres of land located at 3550 and 3850 Frontier Avenue and adjacent right away from the industrial service one, industrial service 2 and industrial general zoning districts to the mixeduse 4 zoning district as described in chapter 9-5 modular zone system BRC191 and amending the standards of title 9 land use code BRC C1 1981 to establish a maximum floor area ratio of 3.5 and a maximum permitted building height of 55 ft for parcels in the resoning area and setting forth related details. This is reviewed under application LUR 2026-2024-000024. Thanks so much E and uh mayor and members of council for this item our director of planning and development services has a few remarks. Brad.
3B Second reading and consideration of a motion to adopt Ordinance 8782 rezoning 14.84 acres of land located at 3550 and 3850 Frontier Ave. and adjacent right-of-way, from the Industrial – Service 1 (IS-1), Industrial – Service 2 (IS-2), and Industrial – General (IG) zoning districts to the Mixed-Use 4 (MU-4) zoning district as described in Chapter 9-5, “Modular Zone System,” B.R.C., 1981, and amending the standards of Title 9, “Land Use Code,” B.R.C. 1981, to establish a Maximum Floor Area Ratio of 3.5 and a Maximum Permitted Building Height of 55 feet for parcels in the rezoning area; and setting forth related details. Reviewed under application LUR2026-00024. Staff Time: 15 Min Council Time: 30 Min Applicant Time: 15 Min
0:29:04>> Yeah thank you Nuria Brad Mueller director of planning and development services. Uh we are bringing forward to you this evening a resoning and just uh broader context uh you're certainly going to get some of the context geographically and in terms of plans and related plans uh as Shannon does her presentation but just stepping back and thinking uh a little bit more broadly especially in the uh recent adoption of the comprehens update to the Boulder Valley comprehensive plan uh the recognition that we do see changes is in land use over time that resonings are one of the places where we see uh changing conditions. Uh we have known for decades that Boulder Junction for example was an opportunity area between the rail and um and other transit and uh other connectivity as well. Um this has a long history as first the um transit transit village and now Boulder Junction. And this is just uh one of the types of an uh applications that we would anticipate um being in service of some of those different planning processes uh throughout the city. So with that, I'll um introduce uh Shannon Mhler as the case planner. She planning manager for the department. So take it away, Shannon.
0:30:33All right, good evening everybody. I will just get my screen shared. Okay, I think it should be showing now. Okay, so good evening everyone. Um, I'm Shannon Mohler with the City of Boulder Planning Department and I'll take you through the staff presentation tonight for the resoning request at 3550 3850 Frontier. So the purpose of the request is to reszone the property to be consistent with the BBCP land use map and city goals and policies. Um so the reasonzoning proposal is reviewed under the criteria in 9219 resoning ENF and this is a quasi judicial decision and there's also um proposed amendments to the land use code as part of this resoning ordinance and these are reviewed against city policies and that part is a legislative decision. On September 22nd of this year, the planning board held a public hearing and voted unanimously to recommend a city council approval of this application.
0:31:53The planning board also recommended amendments to the ordinance language, which we'll talk about in the later slides. The ordinance was introduced on first reading in October and tonight's public hearing is second reading where city council will hold a public hearing and make a decision on the ordinance. In terms of public notice, the site was posted and public notification provided per code. The city received several emails in support of the proposal. At the planning board hearing, three members uh of the community spoke in support of the proposal and one member spoke against the item. Moving to the project location here, you can see this site is located south of Pearl Parkway, west of Foothills Parkway and north of the BNSF Railway. It includes um the two properties uh shown here in the purple um along Frontier Avenue which currently have two large warehouse style buildings that were constructed in the late 1960s.
0:32:54The site's located at the intersection of several major thoroughares including Pearl Parkway, a principal arterial and Foothills Parkway which is a raised expressway with an on-ramp next to this property. And again, the property is just north of the BNSF railway. To the west along Pearl Parkway are some redeveloped properties in the TVAP phase 1 area, including a mix of apartments, office, and retail. And caddy corner to the northwest is the Boulder Junction Transit Depot. Um further east along Foothills uh across Foothills Parkway is um business park areas uh primarily with office uses. To the south across the railway, there's a mix of office and industrial buildings. Um, and further north, there's a mix of office and industrial type uses. The BBCP land use designation on the property is regional hub, a new land use designation in the newly adopted BBCP.
0:33:53It's described as major destinations for community members and visitors. It's a busy high energy place where people come to work, visit, shop, dine, and live. Um, it has activity throughout the day and night and includes a mix of stores, restaurants, entertainment venues, cultural attractions, offices, and housing. In terms of the existing zoning, the properties are currently zoned IS-1, IS-2, and IG, which are for industrial service and industrial general areas. The property is located in the boundary of TBAT phase 2 that was adopted in 2023. Um, TVAP describes the city's vision for the 160 acre transit village area and guides redevelopment. It was first adopted in 2007 due to expected change in the area, including development of the bus facility at Pearl Parkway and 30th, the future rail stop, redevelopment on city-owned land, and redevelopment of the former Crossroads Mall. And for the TVAP phase 2 amendment, which is the area east of the railway, there were several key recommendations that included ensuring proposed land use designations enable a mix of housing types, retaining and encouraging uh local businesses, encouraging maker spaces, workshops, breweries, and creative spaces, and introducing flexibility and land use to transform the area into a mixeduse transit oriented neighborhood rich with amenities and services. Here you can see that TVAP designates the properties mixeduse transitoriented development
0:35:32which calls for transforming the area into a mixeduse transit oriented neighborhood rich with amenities and services. TVAP also assigns the regional TOD place type to these properties. Place types were included in TVAP 2 to provide greater refinement of the land use designation and describe the design intent and performance expectations. Um, the regional TOD place type intends to integrate retail and housing options into traditional light industrial areas and prioritize creativity in development. It includes um a detailed description of anticipated characteristics um as shown on this slide. TAP phase 2 also includes an urban design framework. The framework describes an overall pattern of activity nodes which are shown in the red dots. outdoor spaces shown with the green dots and po and greenway spaces. Um as shown on this map, the subject property is identified to incorporate one of these activity nodes, one of three major outdoor spaces and several poos um within the site. The activity nodes are intended to provide focused retail, dining, personal service, and other related activities that capitalize on high pedestrian traffic, public spaces, and planned transit improvements.
0:36:54Outdoor spaces are for publicly accessible gathering spaces. And the space identified on these uh properties is intended to serve as a southern anchor for this entire phase 2 area and provide space for activities like festivals and events. In terms of transportation connections, the site um is impacted by several significant thoroughares and transportation corridors, including the BNSF rideway just to the south and the raised condition of Foothills Parkway just to the east. The site is included in the TVAP connections plan. As part of TVAP 2, the community identified a desire to improve transportation connections to ensure redevelopment is walkable, pedestrian friendly, more connected to phase 1, and offers better connections to surrounding bike and trail networks. Um, tonight's resoning application follows review of a concept plan that was discussed by the planning board back in February. The concept plan included a mixeduse redevelopment proposal including an arts venue or events venue and rehearsal space, a hotel, apartments, commercial uses like restaurants, coffee shops, and retail and structured parking. At that hearing, staff noted the concept plan proposal would not meet all form intensity and use standards in existing zoning districts in Title 9 and the city hadn't yet comp per performed a comprehensive analysis to determine whether the creation of a new zone district or a code amendment or an other tool might be
0:38:25required to implement TVAP phase 2. Implementation of TVAT phase 2 was anticipated to involve significant projects requiring cross department staff time such as regulatory updates which might mean drafting new zoning districts or form-based code standards and this hasn't yet taken place. At the concept plan hearing, staff requested planning board's feedback on the redevelopment proposal and on a preferred approach to reszoning the property from the current industrial zoning to a nude zoning district. Board members generally agreed the overall redevelopment proposal was consistent with the BBCP and with TVAT phase 2 and board members feedback on a preferred approach to the resoning was mixed. Options discussed included using an existing zoning or modifying an existing zoning district or creating a new district via an ordinance. The proposed resoning tonight follows that discussion by proposing a resoning to the MU4 zoning district with some specific amendments.
0:39:33So for tonight, staff has identified two key issues which we'll talk through. The first is consistency of the resoning request with the criteria in 9219E and F. And the second is consistency of the proposed ordinance, including the specific amendments to the MU4 zoning, which would allow for a 3.5 F and a 55- ft permitted building height. Um, looking at those against the BBCP land use map, goals, policies, and objectives and looking at those with the TVAP phase 2 plan. So for key issue one, we'll talk about the resoning request to MU4 and the applicable resoning criteria. So as we talked about earlier the current zoning is IS-1, IS-2 and IG and these are industrial zoning districts and the applicant has proposed reszoning to mixeduse 4. The MU4 zoning district is described as a mixeduse residential area with neighborhood serving retail office and other complimentary uses with development occurring in a pedestrianoriented pattern. MU4 was created in 2009 to implement the TVAP phase 1 mixeduse 2 land use prototype which called for a maximum F of 2.0 consistent with that TVAP prototype and it was intended to allow for flexible mixeduse buildings. The MU4 zoning district has been applied or recommended in several areas of the city with sub community or area plans like TVAP phase 1, Alpine Balsom and the East Boulder
0:41:08sub community plan area. As noted earlier, TVAP phase 2 included place types which are similar to the TVAP phase 1 prototypes and these provide greater refinement of the LAN use designation and describe the design intent. As noted in the slide above or here, the MU4 zoning district is consistent with many of the characteristics called for on the subject property by this regional TOD place type. However, the MU4 zoning district doesn't accommodate up to the 3.5 F maximum called for by the place type and it limits building heights to 38 ft, which would not accommodate the maximum 3.5 F while also meeting open space requirements. We'll touch on the proposed amendments to the MU4 zoning for this site in key issue two. So, looking specifically at the resoning criteria, the city will grant a resoning request only if the proposed resoning is consistent with the policies and goals of the BBCP and if it meets one of six specific criteria. staff found the proposal met criteria number one shown here which is the reasonzoning is necessary to come into compliance with the BBCP land use map. The land use map designates the property regional hub which is a busy higher energy place. The proposed MU4 zoning would bring the property into consistency with this land use designation. The current zoning um
0:42:39of IS-1, IS-2, and IG was applied in the past when the underlying BBCP land use on the property was under the designation community industrial. The land use designation on the site has since changed and the current industrial zoning is now inconsistent with the updated land use designation. So there's clear and convincing evidence the proposed resoning is necessary to come into compliance with the BBCP map. Additionally, staff found the proposal uh is consistent with many policies and goals of the BBCP, including those listed here, which support the intended urban form and redevelopment of the site, support for retail and businesses and the economy, providing for additional housing, supporting the arts, and in particular the proposed performing arts venue. um on the site. Staff also found the proposed resoning was consistent with the additional criteria specific to the MU4, RH3, RH6, and RH7 zoning districts related to transportation and infrastructure requirements. In regards to transportation, the property is subject to the TVAP connections plan, which is capable of being implemented to the extent necessary to serve the property and the public infrastructure can be paid for by way of redevelopment without contribution of funds from the city. In regards to water, wastewater, storm water management, and flood control, staff also found there were adequate facilities considering the infrastructure requirements in the DCS
0:44:11and adopted plans. The property has adequate public facilities that are in place and the property owner will pay its fair share of the infrastructure needs of the surrounding area. As noted in the staff memo, the site is expected to be redeveloped and public improvements would be reviewed concurrent with that proposed redevelopment. So, moving to key issue two. This key issue pertains to the proposed amendments to the MU4 zoning district in the proposed ordinance. The city has approved ordinances from time to time to amend city standards in limited circumstances, such as to support a special public benefit. This proposed ordinance would grant the approving authority of a future site review the ability to approve a development on the subject property which exceeds certain standards in the MU4 zoning district, including allowing a maximum floor area ratio of up to 3.5 and a maximum permitted building height of 55 ft.
0:45:13The ordinance allowing for additional intensity and height for the future redevelopment is specific to the unique value of the proposal um to the community and the unique characteristics of the subject property. In regard to the unique characteristics of the property is shown here. The property is again located in TVAP's phase 2 regional TOD place type where regulatory changes to enable development consistent with the vision established by this area plan have not yet been completed. The property is further distinguished within TVAP phase 2 as a unique opportunity site for redevelopment which must implement the activity node and the southern anchor anchor festival and event community gathering space shown on the TV phase 2 urban design framework. The property is also uniquely situated adjacent to the BNSF railway to the south and the foothills Parkway raised overpass to the east, limiting potential uh visual and physical access to the site. Whereas the activity node called for on the property notes that high levels of activity, high visibility, and pedestrian foot traffic are critical to the success of a mixeduse neighborhood here.
0:46:27In regards to the unique proposal on the property, the resoning ordinance supports the plans for a future site review to redevelop the property as a new mixeduse neighborhood catalyzed by initial development of a performing arts and events center. Attention to developing additional performing arts venues in the city has been highlighted by the city's selection as the new host of the Sundance Film Festival and in the recently completed Boulder Arts Blueprint. The blueprint just adopted this year noted that affordability, availability, and suitability of space emerge as persistent challenges that impact the ability of artists and organizations to sustain their work in the city. The blueprint provides seven goals, including goals one and five that support the creation of new arts venues. And similarly, the development of the performing arts venue on the property supports many BBCP policies and will serve as a catalyst and anchor for the redevelopment of the property, including support for the high level activity necessary for active ground flooror uses such as restaurants and retail to thrive and will help provide for creation and activation of the southern outdoor anchor space called for in the TVAP plan.
0:47:44The intent and structure of the ordinance are described in the memo and on this slide. Generally, the ordinance is specific to this specific proposal and requires certain elements at full buildout of the site, including the southern anchor outdoor space and the arts and rehearsal space. The ordinance would allow for phase three development of the overall site and would require the initial phase to include a performing arts and event center of at least 20,000 square ft. The approving authority would have the ability to approve a future site review consistent with this ordinance. And the approving authority would be the planning board or city council if the site review was called up. The ordinance grants the approving authority of the future site review. Um the ability to approve up to a F of 3.5 where a maximum of 2.0 is otherwise allowed in the zoning district. and it specifies that floor area used for parking areas within a structure do not count to that F limitation. The ordinance also grants the approving authority um the ability to approve a site review with buildings up to 55 ft where 38 ft is otherwise permitted in the zoning district. with a 55- foot permitted building height. The future site review would not be subject to the height modification criteria in 9214H4 or 9214H6.
0:49:13The amendments to the height and intensity standards are specific to this property and proposal and the future site review would need to be found consistent with the terms of the ordinance and with the site review criteria. At the public hearing in September, the planning board held a public hearing to review the proposed resoning application that we just talked through. From following the public hearing, the board voted unanimously to recommend approval of the requested resoning application. The planning board also amended that motion on a vote of 4 to three to recommend amending the ordinance to require any building with a fourth or fifth story that's partially or fully above the 38 ft limit to meet the requirements of the additional criteria for a height bonus which requires increased community benefit for that bonus floor area. except that the requirement would not apply to the floor area used for the performing arts and event center or arts and rehearsal space. The intent behind the motion was to still apply the extra community benefit requirements for tall buildings, but exclude the requirement for the arts spaces, which some members of the board felt supported different goals of the BBCP. Other board members felt that the original ordinance language met the city's goals regarding supporting more housing overall and providing new art spaces and were not supportive of the
0:50:41amended language. Um, additionally, the planning board voted 4 to three to provide an additional recommendation for consideration by city council to amend section five of the proposed ordinance to require at least 50% of the floor area in excess of the 2.0 no F at the time of full buildout to be used for dwelling units and a requirement for a phasing schedule, but would not require the performing arts and event center and arts and rehearsal spaces to meet this requirement unless dwelling units are approved in the same or an earlier phase. This additional recommendation was provided to address concerns among some board members that additional F granted by the amendment to the MBU4 zoning district on the property doesn't guarantee development of residential dwelling units. Staff have advanced the original drafted ordinance 8782 for council's consideration. without the additional recommendations by the planning board at tonight's public hearing, council could choose to amend the ordinance language.
0:51:45So overall, staff found the proposed reszoning and proposed um amendments to the zoning in the ordinance are consistent with the relevant criteria and city policies and staff recommends the motion listed here to approve the proposed resoning ordinance. And happy to take any questions. All right, Shannon, thanks so much for that. Appreciate the presentation. Questions for city staff? And Shannon, if you can just take that presentation down, please. Right. I'm not seeing any hands raised for questions. So, there we go. Rob, go ahead. >> Um, thanks. I'm just curious about the piece of the formbbased code. Is this a stop gap until the formbbased code um is created or new zoning is done for phase 2 or the permanent approach? Because the memo says, if I remember correctly, I'm trying to see it here. um work has not yet taken place while the applicant says the city decided against it. Can you just give some clarity on that?
0:53:06>> Yeah, I can speak to that. Uh again, Brad Miller, planning and development services director. Um the TVAT plan definitely points to um formbbased code as a way to implement the plan. uh as I think uh this council can appreciate quite fully having gone through the comprehensive plan update and and lots of discussion about what it looks like after it's adopted. There there are lots of different ways to implement it. And so for a variety of reasons, uh we've neither advanced a formbbased code in TVAP 2 or or Boulder Junction 2. Um and and frankly there may be a a a a a point where that is really not even an appropriate implementation. You know things change as I mentioned in my introductory statement with land use and uh one of those for example is knowing that we've got a train station coming imminently. So, there are lots of different ways to approach different things um in terms of reaching land use um policy goals and and that was not one that we've advanced at this point. I I would I would be hesitant to call it stop gap uh stop gap, excuse me. Um I would uh characterize it as just uh consistent with the unique uh circumstances that Shannon went to into detail to explain unique circumstances
0:54:31of the site. the site specific characteristics. >> Okay. So if other owners see a similar ordinance, it would be the same standard for council to grant them. >> Land use is a very sightsp specific uh exercise councilman and everything is going to be uh considered on its own merits in its own unique space and time and proposal. So I'm always very careful to point out that nothing sets precedence in land use. Every every case is uh considered on its own merits. And >> thank you. Appreciate it. >> Thanks for that. And before we go any further, I should ask if anyone has any exparte communications to share regarding this application. I'm not seeing any other hands raised. So, I'll go ahead and disclose that I did speak with um council member or not council member, planning board member uh Mark McIntyre about this proposal, but our conversation was confined to the legislative items about the land use code changes rather than the quasi judicial reasoning. Uh Matt, I see you've got your hands up hand up.
0:55:46>> Uh yeah, I I've I've spoken to the applicant, but that was just a little bit past the concept plan. um more just understanding the process and um how this would sort of play out and and where ambiguity was, but um nothing of great substance. >> Very good. Rob, >> um I also spoke to Mark McIntyre and uh Max Lord, but stayed within the realm of legislative >> Tina. >> Yeah. I also Can you hear me? >> Yes. I also spoke to Mark McIntyre um in the same vein very briefly and um and I spoke to the applicant a long time ago I think before concept plan but an extremely long time ago. >> Thanks for that. And I will additionally disclose that I uh spoke briefly to the applicant but again uh subject specifically to the legislative items not the quasi judicial items.
0:56:48Uh, Terra, >> I spoke to the applicant an extremely long time ago. I can't even remember when it was before a concept plan. Okay. >> And and I I will affirm that the conversation that I had u as I mentioned was legislative in nature and did not impact my ability to um be impartial in this matter. Um, I will just ask every the other folks who spoke up to just u nod your head if you also feel like you can be impartial in this matter. >> Okay, great. Teresa, does that uh comply with our um requirements on exparte communications? >> Close enough, Mayor. >> Okay, I'll take close enough. All right. Um, not seeing any other hands raised for questions, then I'll open up the floor for a discussion of the resoning proposal in front of us.
0:57:45>> Don't we have a public hearing? >> Oh, thanks. We have no one signed up for the public hearing. Uh, so I'll open the public hearing and close it. Thanks, Matt, for keeping me honest. >> Excuse me. I I do believe we have an applicant presentation. >> Ah, I didn't see that in my notes. Pardon me. I see uh Daniel Eisman coming online. Daniel, if you'd like to um >> Yes, >> present. >> And just to make sure uh you're on board as well. >> I'm here. Can you see me? >> Yes, I can. >> Hi. >> And uh yeah, let me just share my screen briefly. Actually, here second. Please let me know when you are looking at my screen. >> We're looking at it, but it's not. There we go. Yep, >> that's good.
0:58:39>> Excellent. Uh we'll try to be very brief. Uh my name is Daniel Eisenman. I'm the applicant and developer for the Pearl Arts District. I'm with Conscience Bay Company and we're a local uh property owner and developer, a member of the community and uh we uh specialize in investing in properties that support the changing needs of our community. And our goal is to improve people's lives through our share shared vision for the built environment and we take uh the long vision uh you know and how we make decisions. So it pays dividends for our community. So I want to pass this on to Danica who's going to talk to us a little bit about the timing and uh walk us through some specifics on the on the project. >> Great. Thank you Daniel. Um yes, this is a great night to be here. We've been working on this for I've personally been working on this um since about 2012 and so or sorry about 2015 when this property got mapped into a flood plane that didn't exist before. So, as a as a very important pro side project to this resoning and entitlement process, we're working on a um improvement to the trestle bridge at um the railroad tracks, which would not only take this property, but probably over 35 other
0:59:52properties out of the 100red-year and high hazard flood plane. So, significant investment being made to not only remove this property out of that flood plane, but all of the properties around us, which will also make the train safer for the people that will be coming into our community in 2029. Um, and so we started entitlements. We were very involved in TVAP um phase 2 and the the engagement around that. And so following that, we were um did submit the concept plan that Shannon went over. And now this resoning is very important for us to be able to continue to move this pro project forward. Next slide. Um as Shannon went over in great detail, um we are proposing a pretty simple ordinance to match the um goals of TVAT phase 2 and other community goals for the area which is resoning to the closest zone district that we have that matches the regional to place type and the land use of regional hub. So very simply, it would um reszone to MU4, which is the zone district that was created for implementation of phase one of TVAP with two modifications that very closely align with the formbbased code um strategy that had that been implemented, it would have allowed the the F of 3.5 and as well as the height of 55 ft. Um
1:01:16this um next. Oh, sorry. Did we just skip ahead? I'm sorry. Yeah, next slide. Um what most importantly, this really commits this project and this through this ordinance, it commits the project to a set of community benefit standards that wouldn't be required if we had just a straight MU4 zoning or an MU5 zoning or a formbbased code. Um, it requires that this performing arts and event center be built in phase one of the project of at least 20,000 square feet. The um it requires that the rehearsal space for the community is provided at at least 4,000 square ft of full buildout. It it commits to that southern ankor community gathering space that was identified in TVAP phase 2 on the plan and it creates publicly accessible open space and connections. And I think really importantly too, this doesn't circumvent any future requirements related to site review. There will be at least one or more site reviews that will be subject to planning board and city council traditional review. And so these are commitments that are out of the ordinary for a traditional resoning if we were just to resone to MU4.
1:02:38And so as we we talked about, you know, in 2023 when the TVAP was adopted, we thought there was a path forward towards a formbbased code. Understandably, that hasn't been on the work plan. So this is the best way to move forward. And as I described, there's no existing zone district that pretends permits the intensity envisioned by the regional TOD place type. Uh Shannon did a great job of explaining how it aligns with the Boulder Valley comp plan, the Boulder Arts Blueprint, and the resoning criteria in order to get to this regional hub destination and um land use that we have long envisioned for the community. Next slide. A lot of engagement has taken place to date. I think the phase 2 amendment had an incredible amount of engagement with working groups, advocates, rest um residents, community connectors. The arts blueprint had a significant amount of community engagement as well as significant engagement on the Boulder Valley comp plan that brought this property also further in alignment with the regional hub destination and um significant engagement. So this we've heard time and time again from Boulder stakeholders that this is where density belongs near transit to support the transit and to support arts and culture in our community.
1:03:54I'm going to pass it off to Daniel to wrap up our presentation. >> U thank you. So I will talk a little bit about uh community benefits and a little bit about the program and reminder uh this is about creating this 2500% capacity venue and performance space that is will probably be occupied about 180 events a year. 120 of those most likely will be ticketed. 60 of them will be local events for the local arts community. Uh the part that excites me the most is this 8,500 square foot rehearsal space for the arts community. Something that we heard loud and clear was needed uh by the arts blueprint and by listening to uh the arts communities. And then certainly the growth of Sundance uh in our town and uh the lack of infrastructure for Sundance to to to have that growth that they're expecting to have here. uh this project truly supports that. Uh but more important, the things that are also part of the everyday life is uh 30,000 square feet of uh food and beverage and retail and services uh creating this 15-minute city. Uh the 500 plus uh transit oriented development homes in a 150 room hotel. Uh all of these are key components of creating this uh this uh consolidated environment. So I want to
1:05:07talk a little bit about the BBCP alignment. Uh I think Shannon listed 11 or 12. I think we counted 16 uh listed here, but uh uh you know, you'd be hardressed to find a a project that uh really checks a lot of boxes as this project is doing. So uh you know, talking about a little bit about regional hubs that are envisioned as vibrant, walkable destinations that bring together housing, jobs, arts, entertainment, and community life, right? Uh this the Pearl Arts District will bring that vision to life. uh delivering generational investments in music, arts, culture, all are carried by this performing arts venue in the fa in the first phase. Uh so this is an investment in Boulder's cultural identity for generations to come. Uh which I believe it's a pure community benefit. Uh and at the heart of the Pearl Arts District is a commitment to supporting the local arts community, not just uh during performances or special events uh but 24 hours a day, seven days a week with this uh rehearsal space uh where we are committed to delivering much needed uh environment. So beyond the arts, this project will become a new civic gathering place for Boulder, a vibrant uh welcoming destination that connects us all together and experience the creative energy of our community. Uh
1:06:22this is not just building a venue, it's about creating a a lasting home uh for Boulder Arts and uh and cultural community. So uh the Pearl Arts District will also deliver more than 500 transit oriented development homes uh helping address one of our most pressing issues. uh you know it's more housing next to transit uh within walking distance of the new train station and the existing train uh bus station but also connected by bicycle and connected by all the things that uh exist in this part of town. So, we are committed to provide this diverse mix of uses and diverse mix of types of housing from studios, one-bedroom apartments, um town homes that are inline, uh basically a full range of housing sizes that uh that belong in this project. So, uh it's an opportunity to create a one-of-a-kind uh environment that prioritizes the growth that we're looking for that it's walkable, connected, and close to transit, and close to the jobs. So, you know, this is about creating a 15-minute neighborhood, bringing together all the things that we've been talking about.
1:07:27Uh, but also very important to mention that over 30 years, the project is projected to generate uh $2.8 billion in economic activity for the city and Boulder County and $1.6 billion for the state of Colorado. So, those are big numbers that uh that uh could provide a lot of jobs and a lot of good uh good economic development in a much needed time. And this is a truly uh lasting investment in our in our Boulder community. Uh the thing that's very exciting right now is that we got this train approved. We are at the entrance of uh of Boulder. Cocoa will be passing by by our site and by our gathering space in the southern anchor. Uh so really this is where density belongs in our city and truly uh the opportunity to finally uh materialize the vision that was set for the transit village area plan uh with all the all the mix of uses that uh we currently don't have necessarily in the in the area plan. And then lastly is major imp infrastructure improvements that will exist on the project including undergrounding utilities, expanding sewer capacity, new streets, uh new multi-use paths, enhance enhanced bicycle paths, uh significant flood mitigation through the Boulder Slooh, and as Danica said, we're expected to remove 34 35 neighboring properties from the 100red-year flood
1:08:44plane. So together with these investments, we'll catalyze redevelopment through uh TBAP. And this project is the catalytic uh project. So I think it's time uh I think it's time to let us realize TVAP 2 and the VBCP vision and turn these two metal warehouses into dense fourb block uh TOD project. So I want to say that today's potential resoning is a very very important milestone but to be very very clear uh there are many steps before this project can be delivered. So, we look forward to continuing the work with city council, the planning board, the city staff, which been incredible to work with uh throughout this ordinance uh process and working with our community to realize uh the the opportunity here. So, as you can see from this uh chart over here, you know, uh the time fra the first three trips, the flood mitigation project, which is the thing that's actually stopping us from developing the project right now to and today is probably not going to be able to be completed till 2030 until we until we achieve the letter of map revision from FEMA. So really uh we'll be hitting uh opening this project sometime in 2032 along with uh the 10 trips uh service of Koko. So, I just want to close uh with uh a few uh thoughts. Uh you know, three
1:10:05years ago, the city adopted this bold vision for uh Boulder Junction phase 2. And we're ready to bring this vision to life uh with housing, arts, cultural facilities, restaurants, hotel, public open spaces, flood mitigation, etc. So, we are committed to delivering this community benefits uh including the affordable housing that uh comes with doing such a large project. Uh the question before you council is not whether these benefits should be delivered. Uh we agree that they should. The question is whether additional restrictions uh that were uh implemented or uh presented by planning board uh you know will make them happen or they will put the this project at risk which is our concern. Uh we believe that staff's uh recommended ordinance strikes the right balance. It establishes meaningful commit commitments and maintains site review public oversight and provides the flexibility needed to finance and deliver the project on time. So we respectfully ask to approve the reasonzoning and adopt staff's recommended ordinance including the 3.5 FI and the 55 ft by height allowance without the two planning board amendments. So, uh, I just want to thank, uh, all of you and staff is specifically for, uh, for a great process. Uh, and we hope we can continue working on this. As I said, uh, this is a long-term project and we're just, uh,
1:11:31in one of the first steps, so we're here. Thank you very much. >> Thanks, Samuel and Danica. Appreciate that presentation. Do we have any questions for the applicant? >> Yeah. No, I'm really excited about this proposal. Um, and um, just how it checks so many boxes. Um, I would be remiss, how if I, however, if I didn't bring up the energy resilience and power concerns and just curious how you all are considering navigating that. I didn't see anything around, you know, solar or generation or on-site, but just how you all are kind of thinking. Um, I think that it's time for us to think differently about how developments consider energy. I saw water is deeply considered, which is always appreciated, but if anyone uh any group can uh kind of set a new model uh for that energy and power resilience and liability, I feel like it's you and your team. So, just curious your thoughts on that.
1:12:35Thank you. I really appreciate the question and uh in fact uh a couple of thoughts. Number one, I want to emphasize that our energy code is the uh the city's Boulders's energy code is the stringest in the country. So our energy uh standards are really high already. Uh but on top of that, uh we applied for a grant from the state of Colorado to research uh geothermal energy on the site. as a result of some letters of recommendation from uh from our mayor Brockett and a few other members in the community, we did receive that grant and that study was just completed uh gosh about a month ago uh identifying exactly how geothermal energy could provide uh the savings in energy and avoid the use of more electricity. So uh granted I can't make any promises that we will apply that uh the geothermal energy we're serious about it and uh we spent enough time and money and engineers uh the the grant essentially covered some portion of it. We invested a lot more to uh to see if this was a reality. So we are taking that pretty serious and uh certainly the use of solar panels and uh efficient windows and uh water conservation strategies and uh you know gardens and uh pollinators and all those things that matter uh to creating these
1:13:51environments is is critical for us. We we take that pretty seriously. >> Awesome. Thank you so much. >> Thanks Tisha. Um, not seeing any other hands raised. So, I'll go back to where we were a minute before and uh bring it back to council for discussion. Who'd like to get us started? >> Brian, and Matt, >> thanks. Um, first, uh, the exparte thing moved too quickly. I I did talk to the my brain didn't move quickly enough, I should say. Um, the I did speak with the applicant. It must have been more than a year ago. Um I I don't it won't affect my ability to be impartial. Sorry to be slow on that. Um >> I think this is great. Um I appreciate the uh applicants vision and their tenacity over the years. Um I'm really happy to move it forward. Um I did read planning board's comments um and gave it some thought and I I do greatly appreciate their diligence. Um, and I think at this point it's just the the the best the best optimization is is to is to move it forward. Um, eliminate the risk as much as we can and um get the client um moving on developing this thing. So I think it's great >> thanks Ryan. Um yeah, I mean Taiishious
1:15:18I think said this early on right it checks all the boxes and you know it's seldom we have a project that checks them so thoroughly and you know I go back to TVAP and I go to our comp plan they all more or less set a path for a project like this to come to fruition. The only thing that didn't happen was councils are the ones I've been a part of included, never acted on actually getting those areas caught up with their actual zoning. That that's not an applicant's fault. That's not the fault of a vision. That's not the fault of having um a concept that meets every box that we've put out there to check. That's just we didn't we we didn't step up to get the zoning done. So that doesn't mean that we can't come in here and be adjustable and adapt to the current situation where we have a greatl looking project. We have an urgency with trying to get things established by the time Coco arrives. And so all of those things mean that we're incumbent to just, you know, make things happen as quickly as we can. And so I think the staff recommendation on the ordinance does exactly that. And you can tell that there's been a lot of work between staff
1:16:24and the applicant to try to find the right ways to get this balanced with what our zoning is the area plan and how to get a special ordinance in place. You know, with regards to the two outstanding issues of two and a half or three and a half F and 55 ft, right? Those were all envisioned in TVAP and the comp plan. And I can't imagine any other site where we would where else would we want to do this? So, if we say we want to see height and density and three and a half F, where else would we do it if not here? Um, so I think this is a great chance for us to put our money where our mouth is and let these visions come to reality because I think at the end of the day, that's what we're here to do is set the stage for that.
1:16:59The community said this is the vision they want and uh we just got to pass uh the stuff and make it for make it happen. So, um I think this is this is a good opportunity to go forward. >> Thanks, man. I got Tara, Rob, and then Tina. First of all, we haven't seen anything this exciting for the arts community, right, in quite a while. So, I'm really excited for the arts community and the rehearsal space. Also, I did watch, it's true, a few days ago, the uh planning board meeting quite long. Um, and I would say that I think we should just go along with the staff proposal that seems to be perfect. So, I appreciate the planning board's um weighing in, but I think we should go with what staff wants. Thanks for Robert and Tina.
1:17:48>> Yeah, I'm just going to echo a lot of the things that have been said. The project looks so well thought out and as Taiisha said, it does check all the boxes, the performance space, the rehearsal space, 15 minutes city regional hub. and I I can't imagine throwing more barriers in front of a project that's going to have such a huge benefit for the community. So, I'll be voting for um the staff's recommendation. >> Thanks, Tina. >> Hey. Yeah, thank you. Um thanks for all the information and the presentations and I'll also be supporting staff's recommendation. Um I think when we first saw the concept plan, one of my concerns was ingress eress and ingress um outside of the entertainment space because we'll be having a lot of people coming out. Um and I think that was adequately addressed. We don't have a site plan yet, but um given this the new Coco development, it's actually really exciting. And what's very unique about this area, which makes me think about it differently than I would would another development, is that it's um proximity to both the the depot in um junction in the junction and that's important because those buses go to a lot of different places and the addition of the train. So, it has a unique access that I
1:19:06just don't think you could describe any other site in the city of Boulder. So, um so I think it's a great way to also get this cultural facility into our community. So, thanks for bringing it. Thanks, Tina. I'll go ahead and call on myself and say that this is an incredibly exciting proposal. I think it'll be transformative uh for this transit oriented part of town and also transformative for the Boulder community. Uh really looking forward to seeing the next steps on this, seeing the performing arts center get up and running as well as the rehearsal space and all the other housing and other community benefits that'll be bringing right there in that transit oriented uh section of town. So, I wanted to uh commend um the applicant for moving this complex uh project forward and also uh for city staff for sitting down and working carefully with them on the details of this uh resoning ordinance.
1:19:57Um I don't think we've seen one exactly like this before. So, I appreciate the collaboration and the creativity and finding this solution uh to moving this project forward. That's what I've got. Um I don't see any other hands raised, but perhaps someone might put a motion on the table. There is language in the chat. >> I'll go ahead and make a motion if you don't mind, >> please. >> Um, I make a motion to adopt ordinance 8782 reszoning 14.84 84 acres of land located at 3550 and 3850 Frontier Avenue and adjacent ride ofway from the Industrial Service 1 IS1 Industrial Service 2 IS-2 and Industrial General IG zoning districts to mixeduse MU4 zoning district as described in chapter 9-5 modular zone system BRC1981 and amending standards of title 9 land use code BRC1981 to establish a maximum floor area of 3.5 and a maximum permanent building height of 55 ft for parcels in the reszoning area and setting forth related details.
1:20:59>> Second. >> So, we've got a motion, a second. I think people have spoken to this already. So, Elicia, can we have a roll call, please? >> Yes, sir. Thank you. We'll start the roll call for the adoption of ordinance 8782 with council member Kaplan. >> Yes. >> Marquis, >> yes. >> Shuhart, >> yes. Spear, >> yes. >> Mayor Pro Tim Winer, >> yes. >> Council member, Council Member Adams, >> yes. >> Benjamin, >> yes. >> And Mayor Brock, >> yes. >> Ordinance 8782 is hereby adopted unanimously. >> Fantastic. Well, um, congratulations to the applicant. Um, and we look forward to the next steps for the project and reviewing this. >> Thank you very much. I appreciate everybody's support here and uh this will be great for the city of Boulder. Thank you all. >> Thank you.
1:21:58>> Take care and have a good night. >> With that, Elicia, can we go to our public hearing item 3C, please? >> Yes, sir. Thank you. Item 3 C is the consideration of a non-conforming use review for the property located at 969 10th Street. The application proposes expansion of an existing duplex by converting interior attic space to habitat floor area and the addition of one new bedroom to each unit through interior renovations. No exterior expansion or addition to the building is proposed. This is reviewed under case number LUR2025-000091. >> Thanks so much. and council members making his first appearance before you uh and presenting. Uh we will turn it over to Alex for uh a presentation on our last quasi judicial item. Welcome, Alex. They don't bite really. They're they're okay. >> No worries. Thank you. Um let me just pull my screen up here.
3C Consideration of a Nonconforming Use Review for the property located at 969 10th Street. The application proposes expansion of an existing duplex by converting interior attic space to habitable floor area and the addition of one new bedroom to each unit through interior renovations. No exterior expansion or addition to the building is proposed. Reviewed under case number LUR2025-00091. Applicant: K Works Studio; Owner: Monticello Ventures – Hardees, LLC Staff Time: 15 Min Council Time: 45 Min
1:23:18All right, everybody see that? Cool. Um, yeah. Good evening. I'm Alex Pachz, a senior city planner here to present the application for non-conforming use review at 96910th Street. So, as a formality, this is a quasi judicial review. So, I'll take a moment to go through the process. First, council members must note any exparte contact. Staff and the applicant will each give a presentation with the opportunity for council to ask questions after each presentation followed by a public hearing. The public hearing is then closed and council can discuss the decision. A motion requires an affirmative vote of at least five members to pass and motions must state findings, conclusions, and a recommendation. And at this time, I'll pause for a moment so council members can acknowledge any exparte contact if needed. Somebody can speak up if necessary because I can't see all the hands with the presentation up.
1:24:21Not hearing any. Alex, go ahead. Great. So, in this presentation, I will provide a project summary followed by the background and project proposal. Then I'll discuss the review criteria and key issues along with a recommended motion of approval. The duplex at 96910th Street is non-conforming because the property exceeds the density requirement of one dwelling unit per 7,000 square ft of lot area. The property is 6,250 ft and the duplex was legally established at a time when it was allowed by the zoning code. The applicant proposes to expand the duplex by converting interior attic space to habitable floor area and add one new bedroom to each unit through interior renovations. The existing floor area will be expanded by 3.6%. There's no exterior expansion or addition to the building as the work proposed is only through interior renovations. The expansion of the floor area in addition and addition of bedrooms to a non-conforming use is what requires this review process.
1:25:23The application was approved with conditions by the planning board after a public hearing on August 18th. The planning board decision was called up to a public hearing by the city council at the meeting on September 17th. At tonight's hearing, council can approve the application finding it meets the review criteria with recommended conditions of approval. Council may approve the application with amended or additional conditions of approval. Or if council finds the application does not meet the review criteria, even with conditions of approval, council must deny the application. Standard public notice procedures were followed and staff received several written public comments included in the meeting packet and additional public testimony was provided at the planning board hearing. 96910th Street is located in the University Hill neighborhood between Uklid and Aurora Avenues. The neighborhood contains a mix of housing types and densities, and the property is a 10-minute walk from the CU campus.
1:26:17The site is currently zoned RL1. The minimum lot size in the zone is 7,000 square feet, and the density requirements allow for one dwelling unit per 7,000 square ft of lot area. In response to state laws that were passed in 2024, the city eliminated minimum parking requirements and occupancy limit limitations through an ordinance in 2025. Additionally, the family-friendly vibrant neighborhood project was also passed by ordinance in 2025, which encourages housing affordability by providing missing middle housing such as duplexes and triplexes. Through that ordinance, the density requirements for properties in the RL1 zone within 350 ft of highfrequency transit corridors were reduced to allow duplexes or two detached dwelling units on lots as small as 3,500 square ft. 96910th Street is 750 ft from College Avenue. If it were located one block north, this proposal would be allowed by right through a building permit process.
1:27:16Here's a street view image of the duplex for reference. The existing building was constructed in 1917 and has operated as a duplex since at least 1953, as indicated by a utility inspection note on a 1971 zoning inspection record for the property. Additional building permit records show the detached garage in the rear yard of the property was converted to an office space in 1993 through a building permit process. There's no land use review associated with that conversion. There have been no other significant building permits such as additions or expansions to the principal building or accessory structure. Around 2018, a small accessory shed and an elevated deck were added by the previous owner without permits. The proposed project will remove the small shed and reduce the size of the deck through a building permit process. There are 50 lots within 300 ft of the subject site with most buildings constructed in the early 1900s. Out of the 50 surrounding lots, only eight lots meet or exceed the required 7,000 square foot minimum lot size. 32 out of 50 properties have rental licenses for at least one unit, and 20 properties contain non-conforming uses because they have residential densities exceeding the standards of the zone. On the east side of the block across the street from 969 10th Street, eight out of 11 properties
1:28:38contain two or more dwelling units. The proposed expansion of the duplex will occur through internal renovations and the exterior appearance of the duplex will not be modified. Floor area will be expanded by creating a new staircase on the main level that provides access to a new living room in what is currently an attic space that's accessed through a drop- down panel. You can see the main level before and after plans on the left and the before and after conditions of the attic space on the right. Other renovations include converting the existing living room into a new bedroom and adding a new bathroom off the kitchen and dining room area. The applicant chose to relocate the living room upstairs as an attempt to separate social gatherings in the living room from spilling out onto the front porch and into the front yard. As a condition of approval, the property owner will be required to sign a declaration of use that prohibits the upstairs living space from being converted into a bedroom. And it will also require that the accessory structure in the rear yard can only be used for bike parking and storage.
1:29:43The lower level renovations will create a new bedroom by reducing the size of the utility room and reconfiguring the existing storage area and closet. Staff received several comments from neighbors reflecting their lived experiences on the hill which help inform broader discussions about how the neighborhood is evolving. Many of the concerns are related to nuisance issues, neighborhood safety, the potential for over occupancy, the trend of investorowned properties used for student housing, and broader policy questions for the city regarding the balance of increased housing within existing neighborhoods. These concerns matter and were taken into consideration during the review process. The use review process relies on specific land use criteria and is staff is required to evaluate the proposal based the excuse me staff is required to evaluate the proposed expansion through a criteria based analysis. The land use process does not regulate tenant behavior. Instead the city relies on code enforcement and the police department to deal with nuisance concerns.
1:30:46The review process can only require mitigation directly tied to land use. As mentioned previously, a condition of approval would require the property owner to sign a declaration of use so code enforcement has more clear guidelines to enforce upon potential future zoning and building code violations. The key issues for discussion are whether the proposal meets the applicable use criteria and the additional criteria for an expansion of a non-conforming use. The full staff criteria analysis is included in the meeting packet. I've separated the criteria into two parts and we'll go through each one in the following slides. These criteria are broadly written with the intent to apply to any type of land use in any zoning district and they aren't tailored specifically to residential uses. The criteria provide the framework for an impact analysis that seeks to review the potential impacts of the proposed use both to and from the surrounding neighborhood considering the nature of the use and the proposed mitigation.
1:31:43These same review criteria are also used to review the impacts proposed and proposed mitigation for industrial or commercial uses and could apply to a wide variety of possible non-conforming uses like a drive-thru, a hotel, auto repair shops, or residential uses in industrial zones. For the first key issue, I'll elaborate further on criteria two and four on another slide. Briefly, running through the other criteria here. The applicant, excuse me, the application meets criterion one because the duplex is an existing legal non-conforming use. Criterion three is met because there are no new utility infrastructure needs. And criterion five is not applicable since proposal does not include the conversion to a non-residential use. Likewise for key issue 2, I'll focus on criteria 1, 2, and four in more detail shortly. For criterion three, the proposal was reviewed for compliance with title 9 to ensure consistency with the applicable zoning standards.
1:32:46The application meets criterion five because the proposed floor area increase of 95 square ft is a 3.6% of the total floor area. There's no zoning variance requested. So criterion six is not applicable. So getting back to key issue one, the use review criteria. For criterion two, compatibility staff finds that the existing duplex will remain reasonably compatible with nearby properties. The nonconformity is due to the number of dwelling units rather than the occupancy or number of bedrooms. Legally, staff cannot make findings based on occupancy or the character of potential tenants other than what's regulated through the building code to ensure fire and life safety regulations are met. The key issue in this criterion is that the operating characteristics of the use will have minimal negative impact on the use of nearby properties. In this case, the addition of one bedroom to each unit does not automatically imply a direct negative impact to surrounding properties, and it's consistent with the other duplexes and residential units that have multiple bedrooms in the neighborhood.
1:33:54For criterion 4, the predominant character of the area consists primarily of individually owned properties and rental properties with a mix of detached style dwellings operating in single unit, duplex, triplex, and quadplex configurations. The proposed project would maintain the existing duplex function and appearance and the interior renovations to each unit would not change the predominant character of the surrounding area. Key issue two is the additional criteria for non-conforming uses for criterion one reasonable measures required. The additional floor area and interior renovations within the duplex will not create any additional effects upon the surrounding properties since there are no exterior improvements proposed to the duplex. The structure will maintain its existing appearance and function and will not create any new objectionable conditions or adverse visual impacts. Vehicle trip generation and traffic impacts for residential land uses are based on the number of dwelling units.
1:34:54Since the proposal will maintain two existing dwelling units, a traffic study and trip generation analysis is not required by the city's design and construction standards as it would be if the use were being expanded or changed to something different that would significantly increase the volume of vehicular traffic. On street parking on 10th Street is within the University Hill parking district and managed through the neighborhood parking permit program. Any resident with a driver's license in the parking district is eligible for a parking permit and can park anywhere throughout the district. The proposal will include long-term bike parking and the in the detached garage that otherwise doesn't exist, which encourages the use of alternative modes of transportation to help alleviate potential traffic impacts. For criterion two, reduction in non-conformity or improvement of appearance, the key phrase is the degree of non-conformity.
1:35:49In this case, the site is only non-conforming because of the number of dwelling units on the property and the proposal is not considered non-conforming because of the number of residents or the proposed number of bedrooms. In order to reduce the degree of non-conformity, an existing dwelling unit would need to be removed. The lower level unit is too large to qualify as an accessory dwelling unit. So, there's no reasonable process to reduce the degree of non-conformity of the legal non-conforming use. To meet the requirement to improve the physical appearance of the structure or the site, the applicant proposes to install new landscaping in the front yard, repair the front stairs and railing, and repair the fence along the alleyway. Given the existing conditions of the brick and wood building, staff finds these measures reasonable to meet this criterion.
1:36:41For criterion four, the property is only non-conforming to the density requirements of chapter 8 of the zoning code because it contains two dwelling units where only one is allowed under the current zoning standards. A duplex is an allowed use in the RL1 zone if it meets the minimum lot size requirements of 7,000 square ft per dwelling unit. As mentioned previously, the duplex cannot be made to conform to the requirements of the code unless a dwelling unit is eliminated. As such, the legal non-conforming use cannot reasonably be made conforming since this would un it would be unreasonable to require the removal of a dwelling unit that has been legally recognized by the city since 1953. Here are the key conditions of approval that were recommended by staff and amended by the planning board in response to the public testimony from the hearing in August.
1:37:33And here's a suggested motion of approval. With that, I'm happy to take any questions. >> Thanks, Alex. I'll certainly give your first council presentation an A+. Appreciate all that. >> Thank you. >> Questions for city staff? I see we got Tara. >> Yep. I I know this doesn't have anything to do with anything, but I'm just curious. They're adding one bedroom per. Do you happen to know the size of the bedroom for the life and safety? How many people are allowed in that one bedroom per >> um I believe it it would just be one person per bedroom. The zoning code doesn't really get into that. It's more of a building code standard that is a time of building permit. >> Okay. Thanks. >> Wait, can we take down the uh presentation, please? >> Yeah. Sorry, I thought I did that. My bad.
1:38:30>> No worries. >> It's my first time. Um, stop share there. >> There we go. >> Okay. Sorry about that. >> No worries, Alex. I got Matt and Tina. >> Thanks, Aaron. So, I have a question about how what the process is for council and how we evaluate this criteria because certainly I can see how staff looks at well adding two bedrooms doesn't significantly modify a number of criteria but how do we evaluate the sum of the parts if a number of units start to grow at at at an extraordinarily high rate and you start to have really high occupancy duplexes grow uh precipitously. How then do you measure the compatibility when we're doing it project by project? So maybe this is a Teresa question, but h if you do it one by one, you never see the forest for the trees. And so I'm kind of curious h what's the process for that?
1:39:29And and how do we go about doing that and balance the sight specific nature of things versus the larger continuity of things? >> Thanks for the question. So this is actually evaluated on a siteby-sight basis and you may not take the aggregate into the picture. Um that is more for policym and decision-m and at this point the policym and decision- making does not create an avenue to look at the aggregate. I appreciate that. So the so it is on a sight by sight case by case basis and the aggregate could be part of the discussion we might have later under matters and whatever that leads to could eventually maybe bring forth that again that forest for the trees way to evaluate things. Okay, appreciate it. I see the nod. I assume that's a yes. Thank you.
1:40:23>> Yeah, >> thanks for that Tina. Yeah, I do have a question. Um, just about when we spoke or you brought up how the traffic management study wouldn't come into play for an increase of bedrooms, only an increase in dwelling units. Um, when you think about like a single family home being converted into 12 bedroomedroom units, would that also not kick off a traffic study or a traffic management uh conversation? Correct. Yeah, I believe the way that the traffic studies are required, it would be um if there was an increase in dwelling units. So, if they added another dwelling unit to that single family home, if they made it from a single family home to a duplex, we could require a trip generation report. And then depending on the amount of trips, it could trigger a full traffic study.
1:41:21And so in this case, if they were adding another dwelling unit, they would be required to meet the requirements for drip generation and traffic study. But the way that the code is written and the DCS is written because it's maintaining the same duplex status, it's not increasing the number of units and not tripping those requirements for traffic studies. >> Can you remind me what the DCS is? uh the design and construction standards >> and those are set by the city, right? >> Yeah. So, they're like the city's engineering and uh civil engineering and traffic standards. >> Okay. And were those set before we were thinking about higher occupancy with individual leases sort of I mean sort of back in the day when that was perhaps a different use was contemplated. >> Yeah. I mean I would say they predate the familyfriendly vibrant neighborhoods and that discussion.
1:42:19Okay, great. >> Maybe I can add a little bit too. So Brad Miller again, planning and development services directors. So traffic studies just in general um speak to averages and and that's out of necessity because they're based at a a land use type and those land use types are based on national standards and natural uh and again averages of things. So, um, like a lot of instruments in, uh, land use and and frankly many laws, I mean, it's based on a it's kind of a blunt instrument. It's not meant to be a case-bycase study. Over time, if um, household occupancy, you know, across the country or in a region or whatever changes, then those standards may change, but those are based on on averages. >> Thank you. Thanks. Uh Ryan, >> thanks. I have a question. Um and it's pretty in the weeds. Um a community member, Trip Hyde, by the name of Trip Hyde, sent an email yesterday. I'm now realizing I think he sent it just to council, so I don't know if staff would have seen this, but I'll just try it. Um he raised the question that um that he was involved in the planning board proceeding or observed it and I believe spoken it and had raised a question about the calculation of the of the FAR
1:43:49F and he said his calculations indicated it it is actually an expansion of 116 square feet not 95 square feet. Um I'm just c if you're hearing this for the first time, this will be hard to uh hard to deal with. But I'm just wondering if that if that rings a bell and if you could if so if you could speak to that in any way. >> Yeah, sure. So um I believe the way our floor area calculations are, it talks about um areas used for egress that are elevated like above 30 in. So like um the rear deck was included in the project area calculations where it's not something that we would typically look at. So I did did take a look at that in the review process and um that area is not necessarily um increasing the the floor area that they have calculated. Um, I haven't I I looked at that comment from uh Mr. Hyde and looked into it, but it's been a little bit since I had that analysis pulled up, but I did consider that and look into it, and the floor area is still consistent with what's allowed.
1:45:08>> Okay. Thank you. >> Very good. Uh, Tara, did you have another question? >> Sorry to double dip as they say. Um, so I do wanted to bring up, thanks Ryan for bringing up that letter. I want to bring up another one where uh Steven Spings are diff the findings of staff are difficult to reconcile with this proposal. There's nearly a 29% increase in bedroom capacity while the record already includes neighborhood concerns regarding noise, refuge, parking, and occupancy. Yet the principal mitigation identified as additional bicycle parking. That's true. Uh whether or not the city, this is the important part, whether or not the city regulates the number of occupants, increasing the property from 7 to nine bedrooms plainly increases its capacity for residential occupancy and is directly relevant to the operating characteristics the board is required to consider. In my view, the record does not demonstrate either that this uh either that this increase intensity will have minimal negative impact or on nearby properties or that it is or that all reasonable measures have been undertaken to alleviate those impacts. And I tend to agree with that because the use criteria requires these findings for approval.
1:46:28The board has a specific basis to deny the requested um expansion. Now, I tend to agree with that and I'm wondering what is your uh retort? What's the correct word? What is your opinion on that? >> Response. >> Response. Awesome, >> Teresa. >> Uh yes. So, we are not allowed to regulate occupancy limits. Um that is a state law that this city supported, this council supported. And so occupancy is not one of the considerations. It's not one of the criteria. You've got to make your decision based on the relevant criteria in front of you. Applying the facts to that criteria, >> right? But I'm not talking about the occupancy limits. I'm talking about there was a slide that talked about trash and transportation, you know, cars. Remember that slide? the the effects of this change it I think would affect these things.
1:47:47>> Yes. And so I think that's a a valid opinion that you may have. >> Okay. Great. Thanks. >> Put on the record. >> Great. And Teresa, just I believe to set the record, um I believe the city council was neutral on the state legislation about occupancy limits. >> Thank you for that for that uh correction. I appreciate it. >> Absolutely, Rob. Another question. >> Yeah, thank you. Um, I don't know if this is a question or a comment, but um, I can turn it. >> If it's a question, ask it now. Otherwise, hold for discussion. >> I'm going to hold. >> Okay. All right. I think that's it. Teresa, you might want to bring your hand down. All right. Let's turn to the applicant now for presentation. And I know our clerk is going to be running there. Thank you so much, John.
1:48:59Uh, yes. Hello. My name is Katina V. I'm part of the architecture team and um we actually have two presentations and I think I I am here to answer any questions about design and can walk through some of the design decisions that we have but there should also be a second presentation um that I think it might be more beneficial to start with which is from the management team and Bridget I believe she should be on um would be able to handle that presentation. Thank you. A moment >> and I think uh Bridget needs to be um promoted to panelist. >> Took care of that. Now she should be coming in. >> Thank you. >> Now we only have just for everyone's awareness, we only have one presentation in our possession. So excuse me. So, I don't know if Bridget has her a separate presentation that she's going to ship.
1:50:01>> Uh um maybe that presentation was combined. >> Yeah, the slides should be good. >> Okay. Okay. Pardon me. In that case, then pardon if you want to pull that one up again. Um I will briefly talk about the first couple slides in case Bridget's slides are at the end. Um so if you would kindly go to the next slide please. Um this is just thank you very much first of all Alex for the presentation and uh the help and support throughout uh for this project. Um I just want to address again in these three plans we're adding one more bedroom on the lower level and on the uh on the ground floor level. Um all bedrooms are a minimum of um 80 square feet. So they meet building code and they're um at least 7 feet wide. Um and we have moved the social space, the living space to the attict floor in order to have kind of a separation between like uh kind of more the public use and the louder uses which is on the upper floor versus the bedrooms on the uh lower level and on the ground floor.
1:51:11Um and we have tried to have a minimum impact in regards to construction, moving plumbing and items like that. Um if you could kindly go to the next slide please. Uh which shows the site plan. Uh and we just want to have um improvements in the front yard. Um so we have approved more planting in the front yard. We have improved in um uh adjustments and improvements to the front stair that goes up to the porch um as well as uh improvements to the backyard and making sure that uh it meets um all the aesthetic uh requirements for this project. So, if you could go to the next slide now, please. And Bridget, if you want to take it away from here. >> Yeah, I got it. Um, so I'm Bridget Rolls. I'm with Core Properties in Boulder. Uh, we're a new property management company that just started in January. Um, I'm the owner with my partners Peter and Lorna. Uh, we've both been doing property, we've all been doing property management in Boulder for I mean I've been in it for 15 years and they've all been in it for at least 15 years, too. So, um, combined we have a lot of experience when it comes to these student properties, um, in the Hill area, which typically rent to students,
1:52:41right? Um, which I think is a lot of the neighbors concerns and, um, rightfully so. You know, one bad apple can really spoil it. Um, I live in Boulder. Uh, I'm a local Boulder, City of Boulder person. I send my three kids to school in Boulder. Um, we started this property management company because there was an issue in Boulder with companies and the ability to communicate with them and the ability to for tenants to have, you know, also like the needs that they have, which I think goes handinhand with what the community has responded with. um things can get a little more out of control when there's not someone holding hands for these for these students. Um if you could go to the next slide. Um I just want to go a little bit about the owner of the property and kind of what the property has always been. So this owner bought the property in 2022.
1:53:45Public record. Um she bought it as her retirement plan. Um when she retired, this is where she put her retirement money. So, it's not like some private equity firm who's buying up Boulder houses that haven't always been student rentals or just rentals in general. This was um a rental before she bought it as a rental and she bought it for her retirement plan and really came to Boulder one time, fell in love, and thought, "Wow, I'm going to look at some houses here." She did. She thought that they were in pretty deplorable condition. Um, this one is not comparatively speaking to some of the houses that uh I've seen, but she wanted to reinvest and you know invest not only for herself but also for renters. Next slide. Um, one of the things that came up in the city meeting, what when it was called up, um, when I watched it was about the trash plan and kind of what what's the solution and what are we going to do for trash here? Um, there's a pretty easy solution for a lot of trash on the hill and Western Disposal. You pay them a little extra money, but they will go inside of your fence and pick it up and therefore it makes it harder for bears to get in and
1:55:11the trash if a bear does get in that goes everywhere is in their yard and maybe makes them want to pick it up more. um it gets it out of the alley. But that's our plan is we're going to store the trash behind the fence, which is right off the alley. Western will go inside the fence, pick it up, and then they'll place it back behind the fence um after they've picked it up. I've kind of looked at the history of this property and I would say the the trash uh tickets doesn't seem to be as big of an issue as I've seen on some other properties, but really all properties on the hill could be cleaned up. Next slide. Um I saw one of the requirements was a sign on the building. This isn't something we normally do, but um we just started managing it 11 days ago. We've got the sign. will apply for a permit.
1:56:04And um it's pretty easy to reach us. We miss an average of three calls a month. So if you need to call us, it's pretty easy to reach us. Uh I think that's the end. Um I did just want to say one thing about um you know, kind of the size of the bedroom that someone brought up. But I think it would, if you were looking at code um kind of enforcement, only allow one occupant. I believe it's 100 square feet to allow two occupants. And that's all I have. >> Okay. Thanks so much to the applicant for that. Any questions for the applicant? Matt? Um, yeah. I got a a couple questions. Um, can you can you answer why if why why add two more bedrooms? It's already a three and fourbedroom, respectively. I know this area of the hill. I used to live in this area when I was a student.
1:57:14It's already pretty pretty tight and pretty dense. Why was the need to add two more bedrooms to this already pretty full property? >> Um, I mean, the owner did buy it in 2022. it was, you know, at the height of the market. Uh, it is an investment and for a return. Uh, but also I've seen that with the allowance at the state level that it's allowed a lot of Colorado kids to be able to live on the hill, which previously people who are instate students couldn't live on the hill. They didn't have the same experience because it's so expensive. now they can share bedrooms or the smaller bedroom in the basement that you know is 80 square feet or I don't know the exact that Cat said. Um, but you know, it does come at a lower cost for them. And I think like what we've really been trying to achieve as a city is like also being achieved in that in that way for the missing middle for our college students who are instate students and it's really hard to go to school here.
1:58:24>> And and what do you charge per bedroom on that property? >> Um, it just I'm not sure what it's currently rented at. I mean, currently, I think the renters are paying somewhere around like 1,500 >> per bedroom. >> Yeah. So, it's already not >> as a seven bed. >> It's already unaffordable. So, yeah. Okay. >> Yeah. Teresa Teresa's got I'm gonna interrupt here. Teresa's got her hand up. I'd like to call on her. >> Yeah. I would I would like to remind council to keep questions um to the criteria criteria based items. I mean, we're just learning about the property a little bit, so I thought there could be a little opportunity to learn more about the why, but I appreciate that. Teresa, >> did you have anything else? >> Uh, no. I was just wanting to learn more. That That's it. Um, so so appreciate that.
1:59:15Okay. Um, Tara, Teresa, >> I don't know if this is allowed, but since the applicant brought it up, T >> Terry, you're you're very quiet. Can you move your microphone up, please? Can you hear me now? >> That's better. Thanks. >> Teresa, I don't know if this is allowed, but since the applicant brought it up, are you saying that you're that the rents are decreasing on the hill because you're adding bedrooms? Do you have facts for that or >> No, not because we're adding bedrooms. I mean >> because of because of the allowance of occupancy like >> yeah the prices are not going down on the hill by the way so you know just FYI you're muted Well, I'm muted. >> No, I am. That was me. Thanks. Thanks, Nia. So, um, not seeing any other questions. So, I will, uh, go ahead and open the public hearing and then close it because there's no one signed up. And so, I will now look to council for discussion on the matter in front of us.
2:00:38Oh. Um, and I will just say let's as we deliberate here and make a decision, let's just make sure that our decision is based on the criteria u for the quasi judicial consideration. >> Sorry, mayor. This is Taiisha. Um, I missed the window on questions. >> Go ahead. Taisha has a question. >> Thank you. Um, so I understand that this criteria was developed before the updated WOOI map. And so I'm just kind of curious. Um, like I noticed one of the criteria was, hold on, let me just get that up again. Um, the impacts to the surrounding area and the neighborhood. And since the WOOI map has a is a significant kind of impact in general, how that how that renewed or that updated map impact impacts some of these some of the criteria? I mean, I know that's kind of like feels like the tail wagging the dog, but will there be a place or space where there are considerations around, for example, evacuation and um just some of the um specific concerns um that were identified in our numerous conversations around wildfires?
2:02:05>> Uh thanks for the question. and I'll I'll try to take a stab at it since our wildfire experts aren't here, but I would say that as that work progresses, if there is a code change that we need to make and bring that forward to you, we would. Right now, that would not necessarily come into play. um I don't believe unless staff tells me otherwise but certainly we will always look at integrating um sort of our uh CWPP and will we risk criteria as we're moving forward and if we need to come back to council to have different conversations about um other related uh code interpretations we certainly will team if I've gotten anything wrong. >> And again, this is more so triggered by the applicant's comment of, "Oh, they could double up in bedrooms." I was like, "Wait a minute, that's then double it's double the amount of people, potentially even triple the amount of people." So I just again I'm just not you know I understand that we have to use the criteria that we have but recognizing that since the criteria was developed there's additional um policy um considerations that um would impact um this property and and future properties as well.
2:03:30>> I think this is a legal question. Teresa, would would you like to answer that? >> Sure. Uh, thanks for the the question, council member. I and I think it's a good one. Um, so the WOOI largely um implicates new development rather than existing development. Um, I I do think that considerations uh about the impact to the neighborhood are are appropriate. Um I don't know that I would frame those in terms of WOOI, but um things like evacuation capacity seem seem um like appropriate uh considerations. I mean that's my largest concern and the additional information around the WOOI and I understand the uh implications that we talked about are for new developments and sorry mayor for this extended exchange um for new new developments. However, um it was my understanding we were when we were talking about that that there were considerations beyond just new developments but also um again the evacuation considerations. That's that's my largest concern right now.
2:04:52>> So there is a criteria that um the use will not adversely affect the infrastructure of the surrounding area including streets. And so um I I think that that's where your consideration comes in. >> Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mayor. >> No problem. Taisha Tara, did you uh want to jump in and speak and address this? >> I'm ready. >> Go for it. >> So, um yes, I agree with Taiisha and I also agree that we have the ability to say no because it will it does affect the not only the infrastructure but the um the neighborhood in that slide. I don't know if you want to bring that slide up or not or if you need to. So, I feel like we can actually say no to this because Teresa said we could.
2:05:52And there are impacts. Without a doubt, there are impacts. >> That's it. >> Need to say more? >> Well, no. I just saw Teresa shake her head, but I think I think you're you you're allowed to uh make a criteria based decision that we should deny the application. uh based on the criteria fair way of putting it. >> That's great. >> I certainly didn't say you could deny the application though is that would not be my role as I'm not an elected official. >> No, all I meant was that you let's see what Aaron said. How's that? >> You could you could make a finding that the criteria were not met and therefore the application should be denied. >> I do make that finding. Thank you so much. >> Which which is not my I'm not saying that's my opinion. And I'm just saying I think that's the language you're looking for.
2:06:47>> I am looking for it. I appreciate you always helping me with that. >> Thanks, Tara. We got Rob and then Ryan. >> Thanks. Um I'm going to try to stick to the criteria. I I do 100% agree with the impact on evacuation and thank you for bringing it up. But um criterion F1 asks whether the applicant has taken reasonable measure measures to mitigate the effects of the expansion on the surrounding areas. Noise refues on street parking. The measures in the records um are removing a structure built without a permit to meet building coverage limits, repairing existing items, and installing landscaping and bicycle parking uh that the code already requires. staff has added conditions for a trash plan, signage, and bike storage. And my feeling is that complying with code, repairing the property, and these administrative conditions do not mitigate the effects of adding two bedrooms. And I don't see anything in the application or on the conditions that address noise, refuse, capacity, or parking demand.
2:08:05>> Thank you. I got Ryan and then Nicole. So I actually raise my hand because of the question that Taiisha asked maybe some I'm suddenly looking for clarity myself so I don't know if I can do this but we're now talking there was just a discussion about um impacts on wildfire egress and I I don't think staff covered that. Am I wrong? Did did staff could provide a perspective on um whether that is implicated in this you know like a staff perspective on whether wildfire egress is affected. Hi. Uh Brad Miller again, planning director. You know, the the WOOI code and wildfire considerations have not been part of historic criteria uh under the zoning code. And and honestly, there's never been a comprehensive uh review of how that uh could fit into things like uh density and such. Uh obviously, as part of the work that's been done over the last year or two, there's questions about that. Um I think it's been represented to you in previous study sessions about the wildfire um uh policy and policy possibilities that um that there's no definitive science around you know what that tipping point is. So that that would definitely be a future policy issue, but the uh zoning code historically hasn't taken um uh especially at this kind of granular
2:09:30scale uh consideration of uh evacuation routes and some of those types of things. >> Okay, that's what I thought. Thanks >> uh Nicole and then Tina. >> Yeah. Um, thanks so much for the presentation um and analysis. Um, regardless of my personal feelings on this plan, it is a criteria based decision and to me that this um this proposal meets the criteria that we have. Uh, I do appreciate planning board's amendments. Um, if we want to change the criteria, I think we should do that at some point in the future, but right now we're beholden to the criteria we have. Um, and I do see those as being met with this proposal. >> Thanks, Tina. >> Yeah, I just want to I So, now I have a clarifying question. So, one of the comments we made is that if this exact situation were happening one block to the north, it would be happening by right without any council involvement.
2:10:32Is that can is I understanding that comment correctly? I'll let Alex uh correct me, but um I think that was just representing the fact that this body of nonconforming duplexes which have existed for for some time. This is not the only one as as shown in the one exhibit and map um would in fact more recently farther to the north uh duplexes would be allowed. uh that that wasn't meaning to represent um any change in policy because of uh the family-friendly vibrant uh community zoning. And Alex, keep me honest on my comments there. >> Yeah. So to that point, um any property within 350 ft of a high transit corridor, which is College Avenue, would be eligible for a duplex or two detached single family homes on a property that is 3,500 ft. So given that this property is over 6,000 square feet, um they would if it were within the 350 foot buffer, it would be eligible, but they're about 700 ft away instead of from from the from College Avenue. So they're close to the buffer. If they were a block to the north, then this would be under the byite standards that were adopted through family-friendly vibrant neighborhoods.
2:12:04>> That's that's what my understanding was. So that there and there are no criteria that have anything to do with whether it creates more noise, more traffic or whether it's clo it could have been closer to the WOOI and still been by right at this point in time. Right. >> Correct. It's just a building permit process. >> Yeah. So um I I mean I I feel pretty uncomfortable putting a different standard onto this property. Um and agree with Nicole that this is a criteria based decision. Um the one thing I would say a little differently, not differently, not like saying different than Nicole. Um I think we need my personal opinions is that um in aggregate we have an issue on the hill and in some areas and um I hope we can address it really quickly. Uh because I I I don't think this is probably good for the health. Um but I don't see a way around the criteria in this especially as a property closer to the WOOI with more people would be a buy decision.
2:13:03that's just so inconsistent for me. So, I I will be supporting um staff's recommendation. >> Thanks, Matt. this is not what we want to see on the Hill. I'm just going to say it. Um, but with the criteria we have, unfortunately, this is what we're going to keep getting until we change our criteria and we change our policy about what we want to see on the hill about high occupancy uh duplexes or single family homes. Um, we're going to talk a little bit about that later tonight. Um, I don't think it's appropriate that our overall frustration, mine included, of of seeing some of this development go the opposite direction of what familyfriendly vibrant neighborhoods was, right? familyfriendly, not high occupancy student housing uh ordinance. Um going the opposite direction, I don't think we can appropriately take it out on one property, but each one of these projects is showing us that that we have a problem and we've got to deal with it um quite quite urgently because each one of these developments that we allow to continue to grow in this manner means that we will probably forever lose that home, that property, that dwelling for families uh to ever to ever come back.
2:14:17So, um, these are bells we can't unring. Um, but the criteria we have, um, right now means we probably have to go forward. But what if we don't want to see this, then we need to come to the table and fix it quickly. >> Thanks, uh, Rob. >> Um, thank you. So, I guess I'm going to ask staff um or maybe um Katherine or Bridget, what specifically were the reasonable measures in staff's opinion or in um anybody's opinion that were taken to mitigate the expansion in this uh adding the bedrooms and for the surrounding area? Because again, what I see is just things. It's up to code now, but I don't see any um like mitigating efforts. And could you speak to that? >> Yeah, I think we'd probably want to let the applicant speak first to the argument that they've made and we're happy to give our analysis.
2:15:22>> Yeah. So, um I'll jump in here. So we definitely have uh I think one of the requirements that we have addressed was um making sure that the aesthetics of the property is being increased. So we have engaged a landscape design and completely redone the the front yard which is just an aesthetic improvement. to your question about noise which not necessarily is a criteria I think we we we had to meet but I think on a design as aspect it was important for us that we separated the rather noisy areas and hence we we we put them in the attic space obviously the attic space wouldn't have been allowed for bedrooms either um without doing massive modification to the home and we wanted to keep the architectural integrity of the space of the building in regards to the neighborhood intact. So, um, with extra insulation, obviously R60 in the in the roof, um, and kind of like trying to really separate that noisy area of the living space and kind of like the social spaces to not have it on the ground floor and not let it spill out on the front yard to disturb the neighbors of families to really separate that on on a vertical aspect was um, a design decision that I think was very uh,
2:16:40purposefully made. Then Alex, did you want to add the staff's interpretation? >> Yeah, from a staff perspective looking at this application, um, I think there's the the element of looking at what are the impacts and so a lot of the the public comments that came through, the most prevalent ones were noise and trash. and noise is already regulated by the city's noise ordinance and code enforcement will also regulate any loose trash or violations with like trash cans. That's already something that's illegal. Um the proposal wasn't adding any like additional equipment or like HVAC equipment or anything like that that would be creating no noise that could be regulated through land use measures like buffers or screening or something like that. So from our perspective looking at this as an increase in occupancy it's similar to if it were a large single family home or something like that. And so the individual users and the tenant behavior isn't really something that couldn't be mitigated through the land use code.
2:18:01>> Rob, does that answer your question? >> I mean, yeah, it sounds like there is no mitigation that can be done except bringing things up to code. Is that a fair assessment? I I I don't know that they said that no changes could be made, but that the criteria was met according to the analysis. >> Yeah, >> I I don't we could respond to that, but yeah, that's that's our staff analysis. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Get Taiisha and Tara and then I'll call on myself. >> Sure. Thank you so much. Um, you know, again, these come to us and as city council members, and it's up to us to determine um our alignment with the given criteria, and I respect all of my fellow council members and how they the information that they use and bring to the conversation and uh into their analysis. Um, when I look at compatibility, I continue to have concerns around the location given the uh the updated WOOI map and the increased um climate poly crisis that we're we're we're facing right now. Um, and I don't think that it's it's reasonably compatible. So, um, for those reasons, I will be saying no. Thank you.
2:19:26>> Thanks, Ter. I just want to add that there is on that property there were code violations back in March. Illegal dwelling units, housing code violation. So to paint this applicant, sorry, as helping this bothers me and I know it's not I don't care if it's appropriate or not that you would actually say, well, this is going to help the rents go down when actually it's just going to help you make more money. So, my question is is what are you going to do about you're going to put in new um landscaping in the front, but if you walk around the hill, you can see that if the landscaping is never watered, it dies. And a lot of the hill is just flatout disgusting front lawns. I've been there a lot in the past few months.
2:20:23So, what are you gonna do to make sure that the landscaping in the front stays nice or you >> There's an automated sprinkler system um integrated in the front and the back yard actually >> Terra good enough and I think it would be good for us to move to a decision soon and >> that's good enough good enough. >> Okay. and also to continue to focus our statements on the criteria. Ryan, >> yeah, sorry, I just asked a question before and didn't get the comment. I I just wanted to quickly for the record say um I I agree with Tina and Nicole that um policy of the Hill notwithstanding this is a question about criteria. Um I don't I don't I don't see a case that it doesn't meet the criteria, so I'll be I'll be supporting it. Thanks.
2:21:17>> Thanks, Tina. Yeah, I don't know if this is an appropriate question, but um could could Teresa remind us if there's risk that we make decisions that don't look like we followed criteria, what risk is there to council or the city? >> Sure. So, a body that doesn't make a decision guided by the criteria is subject to challenge. Um, if you as a body determine that the criteria are not met, it's important to make a finding on the record of what criteria specifically are not met. Um, and as I said, you know, that's open to challenge and uh a court will decide whether the body uh complied with its duty. >> That works. Thank you. Okay, I'll go ahead and call in myself and say I thought um Nicole put it well that this is a criteria based decision and when I read the criteria and staff's analysis of whether the policy is compliant with criteria, I agree with their analysis that it is in fact compliant with the criteria that we have in front of us. So I will be voting in support of the project on that basis.
2:22:42So with that said, we do need a motion. I think people have generally stated their views. We need a motion to uh move to a decision. So I request that someone make a motion of some kind, please, for our next step. >> I move I think this is the right one that's in the chat. Um, I move to approve use review application number LUR2025-000091 adopting the staff memorandum as findings of fact including the attached analysis of review criteria subject to the recommended conditions of approval. >> Second. >> We have a motion and a second. I think everyone has stated their opinions. So, if no one objects, I'll move to a vote. Um, so Elicia, can we have a roll call, please? >> Yes, sir. We'll start the roll call for the approval of the non-conforming use review for 96910th Street with Council Member Marcus.
2:23:46>> Uh, yes. >> Shuhard, >> yes. >> Spear, >> yes. >> Mayor Pro Tim Winer, >> no. >> Benjamin, >> yes. >> Mayor Brackett, >> yes. >> And Council Member Kaplan, >> no. The motion to approve the non-conforming use review for 969 Tim Street is hereby approved with a vote of 4 to three. >> I'm sorry, 5 to three. >> 5 to three. >> Okay. Well, thank you. That um brings us to a close. Uh thanks to the applicant and I think we're done with that agenda item. So that brings us to the end of our public hearings. We do have two matters items. Um so Elisha, if we can go to the first one of those, please. >> Yes, sir. Our matters from the mayor and city council are number item number four on tonight's agenda. 4 A is the discussion to obtain a N of five to undertake legal research and develop policy alternatives regarding the grant property and broader hill compliance.
2:25:31So, um this was brought forward by remind me >> Tara. >> Tara. Thank you. Terara, please speak to this. >> Tell us what you're thinking. >> Yes. What I'm thinking is is we all made it clear uh even today that we're concerned about um the way things are going on the hill and specifically in terms of the legal issues of what we can and cannot do. I would love for us to ahead of our um Aaron, what are we doing in April? >> Retreat. Council retreat. >> Look what's happened to me. I go overseas. I can't even think. Um, and I would like us to know ahead of our retreat. So, that gives plenty of time to the um attorney's office to find out what we can and cannot do. Um, I don't know that we need to do Grand Avenue specifically, but um I think besides that it was said correctly. But I think also Matt I would like Matt to actually speak into this as well. can and cannot do with respect to what?
4A Discussion to obtain a “nod of five” to undertake legal research and develop and policy alternatives regarding the Grant property & broader Hill compliance
2:26:37>> Hold on. I would say that there are some things that are when it comes to what we can for for instance like any overlays um because we have that occupancy law and so that's law and so what can and can't we do to alleviate some of the issues from a planning and development perspective legally? I think Matt would explain it better. I'm gonna since I'm overseas and in partial vacation mode, I would like Matt to speak into it. >> Do my best to thanks >> be your surrogate on this one, Tara. Since we spoke of it, >> I'll do my best to do that. Um, so I think where Tara was going >> is thinking about getting some legal advice perhaps through an executive session where we can all riff together and hear it all in one space. What are the perhaps policy or legal options and guard rails regarding um family-friendly vibrant neighborhoods and its unintended consequences? Um things looking at perhaps our uh the authority of the city manager in using rental licenses and those allowances or restrictions.
2:27:48Perhaps looking at overlays or ratios of ownership to rental in a given neighborhood or area. So I think that there's an array and these are just some. I'm sure many of you have other ideas, but I think looking at what those legal guard rails are um around that, trying to stay in scope, not talking about or um noise abatements or chronic nuisance, specifically the housing uh situation. And I think one way was described as sort of the the western expansion of high occupancy student housing moving on the other side of 9inth and those impacts and how are we preserving andor how are we thinking about maintaining a stable environment for families and not losing that housing to high occupancy student rentals. Um, and so I think those are some of the concerns that are that I know Tara has and just looking at where those guard rails are so we can have a narrowed focused conversation perhaps if the next council decides to take this up at the retreat. Tara, did I did I do that the way you hoped?
2:28:45>> Okay, this a one two from Tara and Matt. I've got Tina and then Nicole. >> Yeah, I just had a couple other things that um I've been thinking about on this same topic. And the first is also understanding how um how some changes on the hill or first I just want to state that from what I can tell the status quo in the hill isn't working. Um and then the other piece is can we keep up with the nuisance piece and are there um policy around development that could help us meet some of the nuisance costs we're having? We're not able to respond. I don't know if we'll be able to enforce the, you know, bear trash ordinance or a requirement that we just put on this last property. Um, so thinking also about sort of our um enforcement infrastructure and whether it's meeting this new demand and how can we plan for that more adequately. Um, and the the other piece is um trying to understand outcomes in the community. I know that the applicant stated that it might be a goal that we want more students living on the hill. I I'm not convinced that that's a shared goal and would like to have the opportunity to talk about that.
2:29:52Um and the last thing is is I if if at all possible I have a huge sense of urgency about this because of of what we're seeing and um just you know I if there's anything we can do to slow things down um that would just be great. So any creativity there would be appreciated. >> Nicole then Brian then Rob. >> Yeah. Um I think my question is is how is this um proposal different from a council priority? Um typically, you know, over the next month or two, we'd be having some conversations with staff to flesh out some ideas and then propose exploring things like ordinance changes at the retreat. Um I I guess just a question for you, uh Tara, what um how is this different from a council priority or is it like a council priority that we're just deciding to do now? Um, and and I guess you know, Teresa and Nuria for you, if we were to decide to kind of scope something, figure out what it is that we're interested in looking at now, um, does that then take away from the options that we have um, for for next year? I know it's a a particularly busy time for you. Um, I think there's been an abundance of Kora requests and things that are just taking an inordinate
2:31:09amount of time right now, too. and and and I guess I just wondering how does this fit in um without you all working 20our days for the next 3 months. Appreciate that and I certainly have some thoughts. I see Teresa and maybe Brad have um some additional thoughts. I mean the reality is um it it depends on scope. If there is a narrow scope uh and Teresa can correct me if I'm wrong. there is a narrow scope to do some preliminary research which actually needs a notified because it goes beyond just a few hours. We're talking a little bit more um of a broader research project in preparation for your council retreat to determine what council priority you want to move forward or not. then I think that there is some legitimacy pending um the city attorney's capacity to be able to perform that and if there is a capacity issue then certainly Teresa can say this is what will be delayed or pause if we do this first as we start adding and um appreciate um Tina's thoughts and frankly um without commenting specifically on the last conversation but we certainly hear that there is a desire to look at policy solutions um beyond some of the criteria that you just discussed. If there's a desire to talk more about that, do staffing
2:32:34analysis, do some data because this is all focused on data and what we can move forward, then we really are talking about a larger time frame. You are correct that staff is pretty busy at the moment. We are hitting over 800 core requests and that doesn't count PD or those that go to PNDS or MUN court. It is an extraordinary um amount of increase and we'll be perhaps talking about that at a different time. Um and we have a small little festival coming our way in January that staff is very um involved in. But that does not mean um that we don't consider and and we don't take into account your um desires for some research or work. It just means that there is a time issue to it. Um, and we will have to um think about what needs to stop and and really knowing what you all really want to move forward and whether or not that is a council priority per se or if there is some other desire to do right now. Brad and Teresa, what have I missed out and have a gap on?
2:33:37>> And and as you follow up on that, I'll just note that we have 15 minutes scheduled for this, so um succinct answers would be appreciated. >> Yeah, I have a really succinct answer. So respectfully, uh, we are not elected officials in the city attorney's office and what I am hearing is that you want us to come up with solutions of what can be done on the hill and that's a policy question. So if you have specific policy ideas you'd like us to research the legality of, we're very happy to do that. Um there may be tradeoffs for that, but um I I I feel frankly uncomfortable stepping into the role of an elected official and coming up with solutions for this body. >> I might use that as springboard for my comments, which is um number one, we certainly acknowledge that there's been interest by the community and by council on activity in the hill. That's a long-standing interest that person could trace back to decades. Um, but also recognizing things have changed in the last year. I think uh what's a little difficult is for us uh and and I don't know if this can be resolved tonight is is defining what has changed. Uh that certainly is something we could try to analyze at a at a short capacity leading
2:35:03up to the council. But um depending on whether you talk to a beat officer, police officer or a neighbor or um a variety of things, I would say that the that there's not a universal agreement on what has changed or how much it's changed. Um so to Teresa's point, um you know, we recognize that we get asked to bring policy options forward, but um but defining the problem will be part of that challenge. Just to to that point, Brad, as long as you're there, just a um quick followup that do we even know sort of how many plans like like what we saw tonight are in the queue? Um like if we you know wait till we have our council retreat and talk then and maybe have some policy ideas fleshed out a little bit more to explore. Is that you know a couple of months? Um do you have a sense of like are we talking a hundred applications?
2:36:00Are we talking maybe like two? Just curious. >> Yeah, I appreciate that question because it really gets to the database decision making that I know is part of the value of of the community as well. And the the answer is no, we really don't. Uh obviously we have building permits coming in and uh anecdotally maybe one or two have been pulled out that that seem to lead to kind of a densification if you will. Um but but that is research we haven't done uh because that's I I know of three. Um but I you know we get dozens and dozens of building permits on a regular basis >> for the whole city. You mean >> for the whole city and the hill? I mean we've got dozens in >> I'm sorry just I want to clarify dozens and dozens. You're talking about the whole city or you saying you're getting dozens and dozens of permits on the hill right now?
2:36:52>> On the hill? Yeah. Yeah. on a regular basis for for a variety of things, right? That would be a water heater and >> to be clear, it's not just for added density. Brad, >> yeah, Brad, I'm going to ask you to be more clear because you said three and then you said dozens and dozens. So, I said um three that I know of that speak to this density question, but in general, we're getting uh building permits in dozens and dozens of building permits that, you know, we haven't pulled out to say, "Oh, look, this one is appears to be adding density." So, I'm sorry I wasn't clear about that, >> but it might be for like a hot water heater or a deck or something like that. >> Yeah. Yeah. I I was I was just illustrating that uh building permits are just part of daily operations unless we were to undertake a research project to go look at all of them and see if any of them imply density uh additions. We just don't know that yet. I just anecdotally know of the three that in in response to >> that clarified. Thank you.
2:37:53>> Thanks. >> All right, I got Brian and then Rob and then maybe we can move to a conclusion here. >> Great. This is a question. This might be a question for uh the retreat com committee which is that Nicole and Tara but um on this one I mean I'm with I'm with uh Tina in feeling a sense of urgency to really address this issue and also just looking forward to a work plan setting session and and talking about this and scoping it out. But I guess my question is, you know, this is one of of multiple work plan items we're going to have to wrestle with and then we've got new council members coming on very shortly. Um, so I guess I'm just wondering procedurally there's there's other items that I, you know, want to bring forward and and some of these will have not just this one and I guess the next one tonight, but others will have questions about feasibility like what do we know about what it would take to move this forward? So I'm just wondering um has anyone given thought and it's funny if the answer is no but has anyone given thought to as we start to think about the the retreat and the work plan setting session um is it would there
2:38:59would be a step built in to um raising topics that council members believe have a like a feasibility question you know like a legal research or other type of research question built in so that we understand that that we'll have time for that or or rather is this the way to do it and then we'll just kind going to do this case by case each week. >> No, >> I'm sorry. This is a pointed question and nobody's prepared for I didn't prepare anybody for this question. So feel free to defer. >> Mary, do you want to talk about the process for heading? >> Sure. Yeah, I I I appreciate it. What we have done and what we're getting ready to do right this Saturday there will be a conversation with community and you members of our boards and commissions about strategic plan. We are uh finalizing and work plans are iterative living living documents. We are finalizing that like um your previous not this last one-year retreat but the previous one. We will be sharing with you what um what is uh currently on staff's uh work plan and as that aligns to the strategic plan and we'll have that discussion there. In the past, we have asked you uh ahead of time, please share with your colleagues, not just
2:40:09with us, but share with us if you're thinking about a priority, let us help. Let us at least uh share with you our thoughts about what that could mean for scoping, what that might look like. So, there is an invitation to come talk to staff beforehand. Then, we ask you to share that out with your colleagues so that everyone has a chance to know what you're thinking of. And that all happens pre- retreat. um so that then you have a joint conversation about the retreat, but the invitation will be there to continue to talk to staff as you're formulating your council priorities. Um hopefully we can provide some of our own insight as um as you're forming that, but there will be opportunity. >> Okay. So, just to get I got this right. If if the if tonight council were to say, "Well, this seems like a work plan thing," would it work to say, "Okay, well, you know, that's in a couple months. We'll we'll we'll defer that to the process." But it's it's also asking a research question that's that that that requires to be answered before knowing for how to go forward. Right. So >> I think those two are slightly different issues. One is it depends on how you scope it. But as Teresa mentioned, if
2:41:15you have a specific um question for research um then that is something that can be looked at. If perhaps the question is broader on can you research yourself and give us the universe of possible things that we can do on the hill that is entirely too broad um as we do but if there is something specific that you want us to look at and I've heard some uh specific suggestions and that is something that Teresa can consider um and figure out how much time she and her team uh will need or have capacity to do so without needing to do trade-offs. >> Good enough. Thank you. Appreciate that. Tara, do you have a a follow-up thought as you've heard the discussion here? >> Am I off mute? I do. I do. I just want to bring to the attention of everybody that I already talked to staff about this ahead of time. So, I came up with this with Brad discussion to obtain a modified to undertake legal research and develop alternatives regarding development and compliance policy for University Hill. That was from Brad and I. However, Matt did mention if you want exactly a certain amount of things, like three things, we can certainly bring that to you either today or if you want to give us like till next week, we could
2:42:29just use what Matt said. But I also want to remind Brad that you said that uh providing an update on general compliance related to quality of life activities on the hill does not need a notifi. Do you remember that, Brad? I'm sorry. Can you say say that again? I didn't >> You could just look in the team's discussion by the way, but um we um we've talked about there's two different issues here. What we can do legally, which Matt mentioned a few things and I don't know if those three things are good enough or if you need more, if you need less or and also you said providing an update on general compliance related to quality of life activities on the hill needs no out of five. What I'm specifically thinking about is >> Yeah, I'm I I I'm tracking with you.
2:43:20Yeah. >> Yeah. >> What I was referring to is we've we've already got um plans to give council what I think we're still calling an information packet kind of memo. >> Okay. >> Just a general update on uh code compliance. This is in uh fulfillment of a commitment that we made when those laws were being passed. Both the noise ordinance and the >> So my Okay. So my thought is that Tina and Ryan is right there. It is urgent and so if we could do some initial time allowing legal uh legal um study about what can and can't be done. And Teresa, you tell me three things, four things. I mean I didn't know this ahead of time that I would need to have things. So, just to be clear, um, and that way we'll be set for our our, um, retreat because it takes a long time for a retreat item to be done. Sometimes the entire year and so I would like to get a little bit of a handle on this ahead of time. What to to get a little bit of a um, head start is the way I would put it. But I think Rob also has something else to say because he's been a part of this as well. So, >> Rob, do you have a quick comment before
2:44:36I go back to Teresa? >> Yeah, I have a quick one. Um, I'm just curious. Are we do we need to lay out the three or four things tonight for a not of five? Like, for example, what Matt said and I mean, we even spoke of a comprehensive review of the concerns of evacuation. Is that within the scope or >> So, I think I think Thanks for that, Rob. I think Terra was just asking a very similar question. So Teresa, perhaps she could speak to what a next step might look like if we were to take a next step. Sure. I'm happy to research specific questions. I don't understand what the universe of research is that I'm being asked to re to do. what can be done on the hill is is simply too broad for for me to know what you all are looking for. Um, so >> so you need specific >> that you can narrow this that would be really helpful.
2:45:41>> So I'm going to make a suggestion here. So Tara, I appreciate you making this request and bring this forward. Uh it looks like uh there would need to be a level of specificity that I don't think we have tonight. So what I'm going to suggest is um doing a little bit of work offline and coming back um at a meeting in the near future to reask the nod of five with some specifics. So Terry, would that work for as a next step for your request? >> Yep. >> Okay. And I'm seeing nods from some other folks. So, so Terry, I guess I'll make a formal real. Is it okay for us to withdraw this for tonight and then have you do some offline work and then come back um in the near future? >> Absolutely.
2:46:26>> Okay, I think that'll be our next step then. Thanks for the discussion everybody. Look forward to talking about this in an upcoming meeting soon. And Terry, I do appreciate you bringing this uh forward because I'm interested in in exploring some options myself. Okay. Well, we got one more. So, if we can go to our last matters item, please. Alicia. >> Yes, sir. Our last item on tonight's agenda is also under the matters from the mayor and city council and it is 4B. It is the discussion on whether voters should establish an independent performance audit function. And Rob, I know this one came from you. So, do you want to speak to this? Once I learned how to unmute myself. Yes. Um I wrote a little something down so I apologize for reading. Um council sets policy and adopts budgets but we depend almost entirely on information that comes from the organization we oversee. Staff work hard in good faith. Even so that arrangement has a structural limit. No one outside the organization is regularly asking whether programs deliver what we funded them to deliver at what cost and with what result. An independent audit function fills that gap. Uh it gives council and the community an objective answer to a simple question. Are we getting the outcomes we're paying for?
4B Discussion on whether Boulder should establish an independent performance audit function
2:47:55Independence is the point. An auditor who reports to council or a body outside the management chain can examine any department without worrying about the next budget cycle or the next review. That protects staff as much as it informs us. The good program good programs get documented as good problems surface early and when they're cheap to fix. I'm not proposing a specific model tonight. Cities handle this in different ways, including an elected auditor, a council appointed auditor, a contracted function or a shared arrangement with another jurisdiction. And each has different costs, different charter implications, and different degrees of independence. And I'm just asking uh council could see those options before choosing. So my request is narrow. Um, I'm asking for a not of five from my colleagues to direct staff to research options for an independent performance audit function and return to the new council after the new council is seated uh with a memo covering the possible models, their costs, and any charter implications. Uh, returning in the first quarter of 2027 would let the incoming council decide whether and how to proceed.
2:49:15>> Thanks for that, Rob. And so I'll turn to Nuri and Teresa. Is that focused enough that that's uh would be direction that you could work with? >> I understand the question. >> Yeah, I I believe so too. And um certainly staff has been I will say staff has already been working on this. We have been thinking about this for a while. I I want to make clear to you and to those in community who have accused staff or me myself frankly of being resistant to this idea that nothing could be further from the truth. We believe that auditing is an essential component of good governance and thank council for continuing to lift it up. I guess the devil is in the details as that uh moves forward. We have internal capacity to perform performance audits already. I know I myself have worked with performance auditors who report to city managers as well as worked with those that work directly to council will likely say that the experience yielded similar results because the goal of independent audit is in fact that independence. Um just like our independent police monitor, I do not look into their case management or their casework or get involved. I or council, depending on how the rubric is created, should similarly um provide that auditing function with the independence
2:50:33it needs. But certainly happy to continue to work with council um and talk through it. There are questions that we would want to know about um how to leverage the audit committee um how to um how and when to publish audit reports, creating annual work plans, but happy to work with you. >> Thanks for that, Maria. So it sounds like we have a a focused request that is um implementable if that's the will of council and nur I appreciate the the flexibility and Teresa as well. So I don't know that we need to appine on this at length. We would not be making a final decision but simply giving a notify to come back with options in Q1. So I'll let people throw in an opinion if they're interested but um I'd love to just get to the will council pretty quickly here. Nicole.
2:51:20>> Well, I just have some questions um for Rob uh bringing this forward. I think they're more for you, Rob, than for staff. Um and and I guess my question is why not propose this as a council priority at the upcoming retreat. That's sort of my my first question. I mean, it kind of gets into what we just had with um the Hill and it could be um I don't feel that this is as impending as the Hill. So, I mean, I wouldn't be opposed to that. >> And I guess just another kind of question is what what problem are you hoping or intending that um an auditor could solve? In my opinion, I I think it would take take some of the burden off of staff because they're doing an independent review of things. It would create transparency. I mean, we just went through an election and I know, you know, it wasn't the majority, but, you know, we'd had some things come up where um there were a lot, you know, to Nuria and Teresa's point, a lot of corora requests. And I would love to see this as something that gets in front of those cors because it's putting out information and data.
2:52:43And do do you have information that an auditor is an effective and proven way to um improve transparency and reduce core requests? Is that like have have you done that that work to bring back the evidence that that an auditor is an effective way to do that? >> No, I haven't done that work. Okay. >> That's what I would ask of of staff. >> Yeah. I mean, I I guess that that's it feels like we're we're a few steps ahead here that I would really love like I would I'm happy to consider this um as like a council priority when we get there, but um I think for for me uh I I really need to know what what the problem is that we're trying to solve. If it's transparency, great. If it's reducing core requests, great. Um and then is an auditor something that we know can help with those things? And then do we know that um is there some evidence that an auditor is the the most coste effective uh given we're in a constrained financial environment and also um the the the sort of most most generally effective right does it sort of give the biggest increase in transparency over other um cost-effective options. I think those are the things that I would love to have
2:53:59before sort of asking staff to look into this um a little bit more is just what's the problem we're trying to solve? What's the evidence that an auditor can solve that problem? And then um what is the the sort of is it the best way to do that? Um and that to me because these are policy type things that feels like work that like I would love for you to do and bring back and you know talk to us about at the retreat. um versus asking staff to spend time on that just given the um I think especially with over 800 core requests. I mean, the amount of time this is taking, especially from the uh clerk's office, from the city attorney's office, it's just this is really really tying a lot of hands right now. Um and and I'm just sensitive to how much work we still have to do. Thank you.
2:54:42>> Yeah. And I I mean I'm I would be happy to um do re Yeah. >> Oh, did you say something? Yeah, just Nicole stated her opinion and then I've got Ryan queued up in the >> Oh, sorry. I thought she it was a question to me. Okay. Sorry about that. >> We We can get you in the queue. Uh Ryan, go ahead. >> Thanks. Thanks, Rob, for for raising this. So, um, since you since you brought it up, um, yeah, I mean, I just went through a campaign, this discussion came up a lot and, you know, forum to forum and, uh, I mean, but but also like there's a lot there's a lot that this this is potentially part of around our financial uh, approach and our improvements to budgeting. And um I you know I when I thought as I've thought and evolved my thinking on what this could be um I think I might have some ideas that that are different than others here and I'd like to negotiate and talk about what you know if we're going to go forward with performance auditing like what it should do and you know for example uh it might focus on the city's financial position like our balance sheet um you know how our revenues are working and
2:55:49liabilities and that sort of a thing. Um, it might also focus more specifically on, you know, things like services, but those are just examples. The point is, um, I feel like this is a this is a really important, you're raising a really important topic that's that's part of a big like a big set of ideas. And again, we've got a couple more council members coming on soon with the work plan sessions, um, setting session. Um, and my instinct would be to um, I guess wait until probably we have them on and we're able to kind of scope out what we what we mean a little bit more. Um, or at least I would like to advocate that if research goes forward that it include the things that I that I think are important. Um, so I I feel like we need a little more time for that. Um, but I you know in general very open to this and I you know appreciate your leadership in raising it.
2:56:40Thanks, Ryan. Matt, I've got a thought as well. >> Appreciate it. Uh, Rob, thanks for bringing this up. I mean, you and I were fortunate enough not to have to run this year, but from from the um and same with Nicole, but from the uh viewing side of the election, it seemed like this was a hot topic. Um, but that being said, I think that there's issues in the community has has declared, at least some for groups in community have declared that there's some trust issues. there's concerns about what we're doing with our money. Um, and maybe programmatic questions, but what I think is important is that by unfortunately these have now been merged together. And I think that's actually a mistake. And I think that that's maybe setting community up for expectations that aren't really there. Um, and so I just want to make sure that we do this for if if we do this and embark on it, we do it for purely the operational benefits for our community, not as a witch hunt to go chase alpine balsom ghosts or to go find, you know, some some some pot of money underneath Lake for South Boulder Rec Center. U, you know, I I I just want to make sure that we're doing it for the right reasons and not using this as a
2:57:45vehicle for a community to chase whatever thing they feel is in vogue in the moment. Um and so so but but but it's tied together unfortunately because these things got brought together by similar people on similar subjects. So I just want to make sure we're sensitive to that going forward and we're not doing this as a knee-jerk to scratch the itch of where everyone thinks that there's, you know, Jimmy Hoffa's body, but more or less where we're at with our finances or programmatically. So we got to disagregate that and maybe we need time to do that. But I' I appreciate you bringing that up. Um and if we want to do it, that's fine. Okay, now I'm looking forward to the pot of gold under Vely Lake. That sounds like a good thing to find. Um, so I'll just call in myself and then I'll go back to Rob. The um, Rob, I appreciate you bringing this idea forward. I I am interested in going ahead and and getting this going forward so that we can investigate options and then Ryan, to your point, I think those options could include a lot of different things and then we could have a discussion in Q1 about what direction we might be interested in moving forward with with the new council. So I see this as uh
2:58:49commencing some research that would be valuable um uh for the next council to then make a decision. Not that this would be a decision itself, but I um I would be interested in moving forward sooner rather than later um is my thought on it. I'm going to call um I know Tina hasn't had a chance to say anything and then Rob will come back to you. Yeah, I would um like to start this now and I would be okay with something pretty simple, but I would appreciate it just giving us an idea of how auditors work, what kind of the formats would be. Um, but I would like staff to offer that to us because they'll be so deeply involved. So, I'd like to have their voice when we're starting this whole process of deciding whether or not we want to go in this direction. That would just be um helpful to me.
2:59:37And uh Rob, I hate to keep deferring on you, but I want to give everybody one chance to speak before I come back to you. So Taiisha, >> speaking briefly, I I know I will be transitioning off. Um however, I think there's some additional considerations. one being that one just in general I am in agreement of I will be giving my nod of to get to the five to to initiate some of this initial research because I think it'll inform not only um what considerations would be for the um the council retreats and council priorities but I would argue that there's a real need to reimagine even council priorities I've found in the three years in my short tenure that that is not necessarily the best way. Um there are so many urgent and important issues that our council are responsible for and um I have found the council priorities to be a very constraining um and doesn't always identify the most urgent and important issues that the community is facing. Um the other thing is we're moving into a strategic planning cycle that we've never had before as a city with the staff, the council and community coming together.
3:00:51And again, having this information will be incredibly helpful. Um I also have concerns about just the timing of when a staff when the priorities are identified, the research is done. Um based on the three years that I've served, that that timeline is is is rather um challenging. And so I will I will be nodding in in support of of getting some of those initial research done. And I and although um I appreciate my fellow council member, you know, indicating that we should be doing our own research, I I don't think I don't agree. Um I don't think that Rob should be doing his own research and coming back. I do think that having our legal counsel and um and staff um doing that initial research is the appropriate mechanism. Um, and they work at the pleasure of council, not vice versa.
3:01:42Thank you. >> Thanks, Tisha. All right, Rob, we'll come back to you. >> Yeah, just real quick, I just want to say in no way is this a witch hunt. Is no way is this pointing fingers. This is purely efficiency moving forward. Um, I think it will build public trust. Um, and I I think it will be eventually a load off of staff. I that's that's my goal, not a witch hunt. I mean, if they use a project to go back and look at it, you know, just for a uh a case study within their own realm, whatever. But this is moving forward with like the public safety building, the rec centers, things like that. Any any big capital projects and to be defined? >> Yeah. Yeah. I think to be defined, I think the the point was to ask staff to do research.
3:02:34>> Yeah. >> What the options were. >> Okay. So, thanks for that, Rob. So, I think Rob's initial statement made a clear ask that I think Nuri and Teresa said was specific enough to be actionable. So, I'm now going to look for the will of council. If I could ask everybody to have their cameras on so we can do a record of nod or five um as expressed by a show of hands. So, all interested in um nodding in favor of Rob's proposal for research, please raise your hand. I got 56. Uh those not in favor. Okay. So that uh there is a n of uh five as expressed by uh 6 to2 uh opining on that. So uh we've got direction to move forward with that. So again, Nur and Teresa appreciate your flexibility on that and look forward to that discussion coming forward. Anything else that you need from us on that request?
3:03:31>> I don't believe and and Teresa let me know if I'm wrong. I don't believe we we need anything more, but I will um state that we go back to the original asks. Uh there were a lot of other things kind of glombmed in there. We will likely not be looking at whether or not this will reduce core request. My gut is telling me that it will not be the case. Um but there's some research there that we will not be doing. Um but certainly I think the ask for what models are available and what could be considered I I heard loud and clear and we're happy to bring some of that forward. appreciate that very much. Okay, well that brings us to the end of our agenda, I believe, Elicia. Okay, well, thanks everyone for a good meeting and I will bring this to a close here at uh 8:59 p.m.