# Boulder County Commissioners: Business Meeting, November 10, 2026 Auto-generated captions. There are no speaker names, and names are often misspelled. Each line starts with the video clock [h:mm:ss]. To watch from a line, open the video at that offset. Meeting: https://politics.boulderhopkins.com/meetings/county/802a9902-badb-4011-9da0-588ea50466c6 Data: https://politics.boulderhopkins.com/api/meetings/county/802a9902-badb-4011-9da0-588ea50466c6.json Video: https://pub-bouldercounty.escribemeetings.com/Players/ISIStandAlonePlayer.aspx?Id=802a9902-badb-4011-9da0-588ea50466c6 [0:00:21] Commissioners, are you ready. Yes, John, thank you. Thank you so much. And we're recording. Good morning. Today is November 10th, 2026. This is a meeting of the Board of County Commissioners of Boulder County, Commissioner Stolzman, as President in the hearing room and commissioners Locumin and Levy are joining remotely. And we are going to start our business meeting this morning with a proclamation and recognition that tomorrow is Veterans Day. We will first have an introduction to the proclamation by Nick Morgan in the County Veteran Services Office. So I would invite Nick to go ahead and provide that introduction. And I'm not sure if he's actually, oh, he's there. I see him coming forward. Great. Welcome Nick. Hi, thank you. Good morning. So I'm Nick Morgan, an army veteran of the Iraq War and a credit Veteran Service Officer, or VSO with Boulder County. One of her major roles is VSOs is assisting veterans with securing their VA benefits, which they've earned through their military service. The VA is a robust entity with much to offer to our nation's veterans. While the Department of Veteran Affairs offers a wide range of valuable programs and benefits, navigating the system can be extremely challenging. The VA has earned its reputation, and this is why I think we exist in the first place. Accordingly, the role of the County VSOs ## 1 Call to Order ## 2 9:30 a.m. Morning Session ## 3 Business Meeting ## 4 Scheduling & Communications ## 4.a Veterans Day Proclamation [0:01:59] expanded greatly over the years. Our office is now fully staffed with three credited VSOs and administrative support specialists, serving the community at full capacity in a way we haven't been able to accomplish in many years. Our office is much more available with greatly reduced turnaround and response times. We've also been able to build bridges across the community through direct engagement with our partner organizations. I'd like to specifically recognize our administrative support specialist who serves as a first point of contact for many veterans and their family seeking assistance. Abraham Cassus, a Marine Corps veteran whose dedication professionalism and commitment to veterans and their families make him an invaluable member of our team. Our office does not work alone. Our successes made possible by the support of many individuals and organizations across Boulder County, one outstanding example is the annual Veterans Stand Down and Resource Fair at the American Legion and Longmont, which demonstrates what can be accomplished when a Community comes together in support of those who served. Last year, we shared some examples of individual victories, and I'd like to continue that tradition and share a couple of incredible victories we've had over the years over the past year. One is a veteran named Joel, that's not his actual name, clearly, but Joel came to her office needing help in a bad way. He was [0:03:21] sleeping on a friend's couch and was asked to leave. He was about to be homeless on the streets, and he had an erroneous discharge from the army, which I believed to be the case of racial discrimination. We supported him in getting a character of discharge upgrade through his branch of service. We then worked diligently to reinstay his benefits from which he had never been from which he should never have been barred. After he was granted 100 percent service connection, we then requested a claims accuracy review from the VA, which resulted in over seven years of back pay totally nearly 400, 000 dollars in full VA benefits moving forward. Joe's now living in his own apartment in the county and is able to support his parents and younger sister who has a developmental disability. The other story I'd like to share is the Veteran will call Mo. Mose 73 - year - old veteran that we met at the Veteran Standown last year, where he was requesting some support and obtaining his benefits. In the past, other VSOs had dismissed him and a situation. He was only receiving a minor VA pension in the past, and that went away when he made too much money from Social Security. We were able to get him service connected to the rate of 60 percent. after he had mentioned [0:04:40] he had stage three kidney failure due to medication provided by the VA over the course of decades. We then filed a unique claim, an 1151, which is basically malpractice or torque claim. He was granted an overall disability rating centers, which is a VA will pay for in their entirety for Veterans receiving 70 percent disability compensation or higher. It had been difficult to convince Mo, that his back pay was his to keep and that this monthly award is permanent. And at this point, he no longer has to worry about saving for nursing care and his medically and financially taken care of for the rest of his life. These stories represent more than successful claims. They represent lives changed, barriers removed, and Veterans receiving the recognition and support they earned through service to our nation. Each member of our team has demonstrated the ability to collectively secure millions of dollars in federal tax - free benefits for veterans and their families throughout through retroactive awards and ongoing monthly compensation. But the true value of this work cannot be measured in dollars alone. We help veterans gain stability, access healthcare, support their families, and find validation through the physical and mental health challenges connected to their military services. [0:06:08] We would like veterans to know that they can trust our office and it's dedicated, competent, and effective staff who pay particular attention and care towards our historically underserved veteran populations. The county's investment in a fully staff veteran service office produces measurable results, helping recover millions of dollars in federal benefits annually directly into the hands of the community. It helps bring federal dollars back into Boulder County through benefits earned, and more importantly improves quality of life for the people who served our nation. Every successful VA claim represents not only financial support, but access to healthcare, housing stability, family security, and long overdue recognition for service - connected disabilities. Finally, I want to extend an invitation every veteran dependent and family member residing in Boulder County. If you have any questions about VA benefits or unsure what you may be eligible for, please reach out to our office. We're here to help. Thank you for your time and commitment to Boulder County Veterans. Thank you, Nick. Um, thank you both for sharing these wonderful stories of what your office has been able to do for Veterans in Boulder County. And thank you also for your service. Uh, Commissioner Stolzman will now read The Commissioner's Proclamation. Thank you all for being here today. I am honored to be able to read a proclamation, recognizing Boulder County's Veterans and [0:07:38] their families. Boulder County's home to more than 14, 000 active duty reservists, Veteran Service members who make significant contributions to our community each day. Within the Boulder County government, we have Veterans and Reservists throughout our organization who remain committed to public service throughout the work of County Government. Our armed forces members and their families have made selfless sacrifices defending freedom, democracy, and security for our country. We're grateful for the commitment and courage of the many people in Boulder County who have served and our serving in the U. S. Armed Forces. The Boulder County Commissioners honor those who served or our serving in the United States armed forces and their families. Boulder County and our Community Partners work to support all that trends as they transitioned to civilian life. Many County Programs provide critical service to Veterans and their families in obtaining benefits and services earned through their service, connecting them with job opportunities and supports as they navigate the Justice System in an effort to improve stability and quality of life. Boulder County also works alongside Community Partners to end Veterans Homelessness in our community. [0:08:45] We honor our community partners who are making a positive impact in the lives of Veterans and their families. We, The Board of Boulder County Commissioners, therefore proclaim November 11th, 2026 as Veterans Day and Boulder County and recognize and honor those who have served for our serving in the armed forces and their families dated November 10th, 2026. Okay, thank you so much, Commissioner Stolzman. Uh, it's now my honor to invite Major General Robert Davis to come to the podium to deliver some remarks. Major General Robert Davis serves as the 45th Aditant General of Colorado. Is the Executive Director of the Department of Military and Veterans Affairs and a member of the Governor's Cabinet. He leads a department comprising the Colorado National Guard, The Division of Veterans Affairs, and the Colorado Wing of the Civil Air Patrol. ## 4.b Remarks by Major General Robert Davis [0:09:39] Uh, Major General Davis, it's an honor to have you here, and we look forward to your remarks. Commissioners, thank you so much for having me here. It's Julian Honor. Um, you know, first of all, if you're a veteran here today, please stand and be recognized. You know. I was, uh, I was really struck by Nick's stories that he just shared with us at two vignettes and he shared with us because it's truly profound in ways that the department takes care of our Veterans across the state. We've got approximately 365, 000 veterans across the entire state of Colorado with about 14, 000 here in Boulder County. Um, you know, 2026 is truly a profound year for us in history. 250th year, uh, celebration as a nation, 150th as a state, and the 25th anniversary of 9 - 11. That's a lot of big anniversaries for us. And it's giving me a lot of time to reflect about a particularly meaningful period in my career in our nation. Today we recognize those who have served Veterans Day goes back to the armistice that ended the fighting on the Western front in 1918, November 11th. [0:10:56] In 1938, Congress made November 11th, a formal national holiday. And then in 1954, Armistic Day was changed to Veterans Day. We reflect on 250 years of service that many Americans have delivered, have dedicated themselves to protect our freedom by winning our nation's wars. Colorado's had an incredibly important role in all that. In 1862, in the Battle of Glorieta Past, before Colorado was a state, the first Colorado Infantry from Denver mustard and then went to deter attacks by the Confederacy, better known as the Gettysburg of the West. That decisive battle went on to preserve our union and ultimately abolished slavery. Today our Colorado National Guard is invested heavily in our state and nation. Just over the last couple of weeks in Southwestern Colorado, we responded to flood saving over 65 people. This was no less catastrophic event than our floods here in Boulder in 2013, which your national guard helped save lives and help communities recover. [0:12:00] Every weekend we're providing support to our state, rescuing people who get stranded in the high mountains. Last week we provided election support cybersecurity support under the Authority of the Governor to preserve our elections. Globally around the world, your Colorado National Guard is forward deployed in the Middle East, in the Pacific, Europe and here at home in the United States. Honoring Veterans is a necessity to inspire future generations to serve. Our Veterans serve all of our country in our communities by making positive contributions, building stronger futures and inspiring future generations. Our nation's veterans throughout history have kept us free. Returned home and continue to serve in society. A special thanks to Boulder, my home for over 31 years. Your military depends on you, our community, to support our Veterans and our families. Thank you. Okay, thank you so much for those remarks. Uh, we will now take a 30 minute recess so that, um, those who are fortunate enough to be present can talk with one another. Um, share some, some refreshments, and then we'll reconvene. ## 4.c 30 minute recess for Veterans Day Reception [0:13:12] I see that Commissioner Le Chimian would like to say a few words. Yes, if I made her, thanks so much. I just want to appreciate and want to apologize. I'm not able to be the person I came up with a significant fever on Sunday and I've been ill. So that's why it shows not to share that with you all today. Um, in person, but I just really want it from, from a personal standpoint, just appreciate the veterans who are in the room. It's we're not able to join us. Our staff, but also residents throughout Boulder County and people who work in Boulder County who have given of their lives to keep the freedoms that were shared in the different conversations. Nick, those were really important stories that you shared today. And so I'm just grateful. [0:13:58] And thank you to Boulder County for recognizing and giving us as a Board of County Commissioners an opportunity to make an important proclamation. So thank you all. Yeah, thank you for that. And other than the fever, I, um, echo all of Commissioner Lo Chimine's remarks. So at the time now is we'll just call it 11 or I'm sorry. I'm on the East Coast 945. We will reconvene at 1015 for the balance of our business agenda. And I hope everybody enjoyed. We are back from research. I hope everybody enjoyed the opportunity to talk and thank all of the Veterans joining us for their service. We will now move on to item five on our agenda. And this is a note for the record. We had a resignation from the NIWAT Local Improvement District Advisory Committee. So that's just a note for the record. We will now sit as the gun barrel public improvement district Board of Directors, and we have one item on our consent agenda that is item 6A. Move approval. Thank you. Okay, all in favor. Aye. Aye. Aye. And we have approved our consent agenda. We will now resume sitting as the Board of County Commissioners of Boulder County. And we have four items on our consent agenda. That's 7A through D. ## 5 Items to Note for the Record ## 5.a Commissioners' Office - Niwot Local Improvement District Advisory Committee resignation ## 6 Gunbarrel Public Improvement District Consent Items (Sitting as the Gunbarrel Public Improvement District Board of Directors) ## 7 Commissioners' Consent Items [0:15:50] May have a motion. Move approval. Okay. On favorite, say aye. Aye. Aye. And we have approved our consent agenda. We will now take up discussion items. And the first is from the County Administrators Office Atalanta Reitana is here to do her amazing job presenting the 2026 policy updates. Good morning. So this year, for the record, my name is Atilana Retana for the Office of County. County Administrator. Uh, this year we are requesting the adoption and approval of the proposed policy changes that were reviewed in the department head meeting on September 23rd. The effective date for these policy changes will be January 1st. The total of requests that we received were 66 - 24 of the requests were made by employees. 42 of them were from the Office of Primary Responsibility and or collaborating department. From there, uh, we have 20 policy changes that need your approval and adoption today. Each policy change was carefully reviewed by multiple parties. The Office of Racial Equity identified policies requiring our additional discussions for unintended consequences, as well as the completion of a racial equity impact assessment tool. The County Attorney's Office collaborated with the respective OPRs. And it says potential impacts related to union negotiations out of the 66, 39 of them were not moved forward. Pause for consideration due to potential union negotiations or further discussions if ## 8 Commissioners' Discussion Items ## 8.a County Administrator's Office - 2026 Policy Updates [0:17:41] needed. The process included a more intentional collaboration across departments to ensure policy changes were developed and introduced thoughtfully with a clear communication among impacted parties. This approach helps minimize unexpected impacts and supports effective implementation. As previously mentioned, these changes will come into effect January 1st, 2027, and will be presented at a supervisor's meeting in December if they are moved forward. Thank you. Were you going to go through any of the changes that are in the packet or you just hear it takes questions and comments? I can do either way. Would you like me to state each change for the record or take any questions needed per policy. Why don't we just move to questions? I think we've had a chance to review them. I just didn't know if you were done. That's why. Um, so commissioners, any questions about, uh, any of the policy changes in our packet. Thanks Atilana. I appreciate the presentation. And of course, have an opportunity to see the information ahead of time and then the presentation that was done previously as well, uh, Executive Leadership. I think one of the questions that just as you were presenting kind of came up for me and an understanding of, of two different pieces because we have the union, um, here at union here at the County for any, because a lot of [0:19:14] this is employee driven from a policy manual changes and asks. So just, if you know kind of what that next step will be for next year's process, it was just curious. And there might not be something formulated quite yet. That's one question. And then the, the other question, well, maybe let's start with that one. Okay. So starting with that one next year, I definitely know the process will change given our current process in itself. This year the request that had potential union negotiation content were pulled per the county attorney's office labor relations. Um, they did an amazing job at identifying them very quickly. Next year, we're looking at a different process in general for policy submissions to make it a little bit more, uh, of a clean, a clean method for employees to submit. But as well as for OPRs to follow and come through. [0:20:09] Currently it's a form. So with that being said in the new method, we're also working together with the county attorney's office to see if a workflow can be implemented if the policies are, uh, union negotiation content. They would be pulled in and then processed further by the county attorney's office at this time. We don't know if next year, you know, pending the contract and the effectiveness and what the terms and conditions are. Um, I had my information is limited on what that looks like. Yeah. Thank you. I appreciate that. The other question I had is there was, um, at least one of these that I know has been in the works for a while in regards to art exhibits at the County. And so it just prompted this question for me about how would the public see this information versus what internally staff would see. [0:21:03] Internally, currently the policy and procedure manuals are posted for all employees to see externally it would have to be requested. So the external items for the policy itself as it stands, it needs to be requested part of the process improvements that we are looking for 2027 is the option of actually having a page posted for external viewing, um, policies where they don't need to be requested to anybody. And it would be an access for all Community members to see. Okay. And I think the, the peace in there is all these changes are important. And do all staff understanding and acknowledging that not all stuff is, you know, in the room or listening to the business meeting and or even on a computer, um, all day books are out in the field doing different jobs and different work at all times of the year. So just, just thinking about if someone asks a staff person really may not know about the policy changes. And so it was just a thought too in regards to the way that we communicate this out. And I apologize. I don't know who all is sitting in the room. So there might be a group of folks in there that have already contemplated how they're going to share out some of these really unthinking about the external ones where folks in [0:22:18] the county, um, might have, like you said, kind of a drug line of access to, but they may not know that there's changes for the external partners. And I might have access to it initially. I can connect with communications to see what type of postings or information where we can, uh, email what emails we can reach out to for because of that reason they might not have access to the changes that will be in effect in January. Thank you. I don't have additional questions. Thank you. Commissioner Stormsman. I don't have any questions. Thank you. Uh, great. I had, um, one question and I'll have to scroll down to find it. It has to do with designated certain County Properties as public forums. Oh, is this it. Yeah. It's, um, number 5. 03. And the way I read this and I just didn't know if I was reading this correctly. It looks like the fairgrounds is the only county property that is a designated public forum. [0:23:40] Am I reading that correctly? I would need to, um, I can get back to you on that with the OPR just to make sure that I am interpreting the policy they submitted accurately. Okay. Um, I was surprised that that was the only place that was designated as a public designated public forum being a place that is available for purposes, assembly. And, you know, and making speech with the least restrictive, uh, First Amendment, uh, limitations, um, because I, I would have thought that the county courthouse being a place where people do traditionally assemble and have demonstration and such. Um, it's designated as a limited public forum. And so I just, uh, wanted to understand a little bit more about why it was not in the former category. And I apologize for not raising this early or I didn't have a chance to review them in detail until just before the hearing. Um, and Atilana, if I may, Commissioner Levy, this is Natalie Spring at Commissioners Deputy for the Record. Thank you for the opportunity to clarify this policy update on the record. I believe the addition of 5. 03 is to add the fairgrounds to that category. Whereas previously it was not designated as a specific public forum. Um, and it went through a different review process or a parks in open space team. And so [0:25:16] this is just the addition. It's not removing the downtown courthouse from the policy or that definition of a public forum. Um, well, thank you for that clarification. I'm not sure that's consistent with how this is written because. Identifies the Boulder County Courthouse as, oh, so maybe, okay, and I don't have the full, uh, policy in front of me. So you, so you're saying the courthouse plaza or lawn is included there in that category one of designated public forums and the courthouse itself being the hearing room is, um, so there's a distinction there. Is that what's going on. Um, yes. So it's an, it's not changing the limited public forum designation of the courthouse. Okay. But the, but the plaza or, or lawn is considered a designated public forum. Um, we believe the definition is eliminated public forum in the policy. Yes. The lawn. Okay. I thought you said that the plaza courtyard, it's not a courtyard lawn in front of the courthouse. I thought you said initially that it is in category one being the place with the fewest restrictions on speech. And I'm happy to defer to Trina Rulin who's in the realm, um, because we're combining our answers at this moment. Okay. Thank you, Karina. Sorry. And again, I apologize for not raising this earlier. Yeah. Good morning commissioners, Trina Ruland Interim County [0:27:17] Attorney. Um, I believe, but I can verify that, uh, the Courthouse is a limited public forum. The policy is not a change to that. There's no change to what it has been. Um, but I can pull that up and get back to the commissioners in like two minutes if you want to give me some time. I'll just say on the public forum issue, we did previously discussed that as a board and go through it and I'm supportive of the way it's written. Okay, thank you. All right, so I'm not gonna slow us down to get clarity on the plaza issue. I think we can go ahead and move forward and adopt these. I guess I would request that we do modify the document as presented just to strike that sentence. Commissioner Archimian. Thank you. I was, let's see here. I was actually interested in the response to the question that you brought up. [0:30:37] On. Oh no, I can't see it. The 5. 5. 03. Thank you. Thanks, Atilana. 5. 03 the use of County Grounds and our buildings. I heard two different questions in regards to the first space and then the second space. The responses that I heard made it sound like we think that this is just an addition to something. And so just to clarify that for me to make sure that what the intent was and what was accomplished in this change is the same. So I'm still waiting to hear that response. I think I would be more comfortable having legal advice and executive session if we want to continue talking about public forums. I think for me, my question doesn't feel like illegal question. I'm just trying to get clarification of what I heard in the conversation this morning. If there's more there, of course I tend to support asks for. Exec session that I just, the question I had didn't sound like that to me. Yeah, I think similarly that was what I was asking for our deputy had indicated that this was an addition of the fairgrounds to the first category, a designated public forum. [0:32:00] And I think it is important to get the answer to that question. As we move forward here, but I didn't want to hold up the adoption while our staff goes in pages through all of this. But if this is something you're able to answer now, let's go ahead and hear that. There's an indication in the room that we need a few minutes. So why don't we take an eight minute recess, it's 1032, and we can come back at 1040. Okay. Then we will be in recess until 1040. Thank you for reading the room for me. No problem. Okay, I just received the thumbs up. Commissioners, are you ready. Yes. Thank you. I will resume the recording. Okay. We are back from our recess. I see Trina Ruland at the podium. What do you have to tell us? [0:33:03] Thank you, Commissioners, for your patients. As I go look into this, the sidewalk is a traditional public forum. So we do not designate that specifically in this policy, but the courthouse lawn is subject to permit requirements, and that's in Section 5. 02G. So it's named separately in a part of the policy that we are not revising, but it is specifically addressed. Okay, well, thank you for taking the time to get that. And just to be a little bit more specific, the sidewall. Where's that. The sidewalks of the courthouse lawn. So sidewalks are traditional public forums, as it says in the preamble to 5. 03C. And so the sidewalk of the courthouse area, the public sidewalks, our traditional public forums. Okay, so along 13th Street and 14th Street. The public sidewalks. Okay. Okay, well, thank you for getting it additional information. And so the lawn, which I assume includes the plaza, it requires a permit. Correct. [0:34:21] Okay. In certain situations. Okay. Okay. I think I'm satisfied with that Commissioner Lochimin. Does that address your questions. The only other question that I heard brought at, thanks, Train - Epper, um, for doing some research. The only other question that came up for me in the conversation was about, and I'm looking at the first criteria there on designated forms. Just to understand if that was an addition, it talks about in there, they are properties. So it makes me think the other list, and I'm just looking at a redline version that adds one item. Is that true. The other section of the policy has not changed, so the other list remains intact. And so everything referenced outside of the red line is not to be changed in any way. Okay, and I think it's just the version that I'm looking at, which is totally fine, but just because that came up in the conversation, I wanted that clarification. I appreciate that. I did on that, thank you. I don't have additional questions. Okay, let me ask my fellow commissioners, do either of you object to deleting that last sentence regarding our golems, zero waste, or darn near by 2025. I don't have any objection for me. [0:35:48] I was thinking it probably just was in there from years previous, and so on an update. That makes sense that we're doing an update. Commissioner Stolzman. I don't have a strong objection. There were a number of proposals that were declined this round just because of the update we're going through, and some of them in the zero - way section. So I think fine, and I don't think would create any issue for the reasons the other proposals were declined, but many of them were just told to wait and we'll come back at a future date. So just acknowledging that, but I don't have a strong objection. Okay, well, if you don't object and it would be the one to make the motion, if you wouldn't mind, including that deletion, I would appreciate it. Great. So, uh, with that, I will move that we adopt the policy updates, but in the zero wastection at an additional policy update so that we delete strike the language 2025 for darn near. I didn't understand that the motion, I apologize. [0:36:59] Can you say that again? I moved to accept the policy changes in this agenda item, and to add an additional policy change in number 1. 080 waste in the last sentence of the 2nd paragraph, we will strike the parentheses and then or darn near parentheses by 2025. I just didn't hear it as a policy change. I think maybe that's what I was thinking maybe. That's what we're doing today. I don't know what else to say. For me, it's just a text amendment. I just, I just don't want someone to pick up this writing and think they're supposed to be an actual polyphenement. So this is literally the policy manual. Like we are literally changing the County policy. I understand the assignment of the policy amendment. I'm just trying to understand it. All right, I'll wish through, I'm happy to have you make the motion. Okay, thank you. I'm looking at item 8A in regards to 2026 policy updates. It would move that we approve and the only change would be a text amendment on the item. And I'm just scrolling here. In Section 1 General Under No. 1. 080 waste to do, to delete the last sentence of what's looks like the second paragraph where it reads Boulder County Government - Chief Sarah Waste Generation. [0:38:32] Or down near by 2025. I think that motion captures my intention. Thank you, Commissioner Lo Chimin. So Commissioner Levie, you're intending to eliminate the goal of the Boulder County government achieving zero waste generation altogether, not just taking out the or darn nearby 2025. I did want to delete that sentence because the balance of the paragraph reflects our goal of reducing and minimizing to the extent possible. Um, I don't, we don't have the tools to achieve zero waste at this time. Okay. I really. Didn't think this was going to be a significant issue. Um, and so that we can move forward on all of the valuable work that, uh, Atilana has done, and all the other County employees who have provided input into this, uh, I will withdraw my request that we delete that sentence, uh, we can continue to have a sentence that, um, that in my view is unachievable, um, it doesn't do any harm, um, because we still are saying we should model best practices for responsible purchasing waste reduction reuse resource conservation minimize landfill disposal, et cetera. And we still have all of the policies that help us achieve that goal, uh, however, for purposes of moving forward with this, with a nice clean record, I will withdraw that and ask that we simply, um, approve [0:40:41] item 8A. I'm happy to second that new motion. Okay, we have a motion and a second, uh, all those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed. Okay, so we have approved 8A. We are now ready for 8B. And thank you very much, Atilana. My agenda shows that we will be hearing from Whitney Wilcox with humans. On the Community Partnership grant, um, finding out approval. Good morning, Commissioners Whitney Wilcox Community Initiatives Manager with Human Services. Good morning, Commissioners. Georgina Basaril, Division Director with Partnerships Contracts and Services Division with Human Services. We're here this morning to request approval of the 2027 Comity Partnership grant Program Funding Recommendations. The Community Partnership Grant Program supports the County's Safety Net through funding to nonprofits, providing services in at least one of the program's three priority areas, including Housing and Homelessness Prevention, Health and Wellbeing and Individual and Family Supports. In 2027, the Program will be funded through a combination of the Human Services Safety Net Mill Levy and the Health and Human Services and General Use Property Tax Funds. The Program's Competitive RFA opened on July 14th and closed on August 21st. We received 71 applications requesting funding totaling 15 million, 227, 555 dollars. All applications were screened against the eligibility criteria and 65 applications method eligibility requirements and moved forward to the evaluation process. Applications were ## 8.b Housing and Human Services - 2027 CPG Primary RFA Funding Approval Memo ($8,521,729) [0:42:46] reviewed by an 11 member committee who were selected based on their expertise around the program's priorities. Their understanding of Community needs historically underserved populations and existing services and systems. Reviewers independently evaluated applications using a standardized evaluation matrix based on the criteria established in the RFA and in alignment with the program's priorities and the human services safety net mill levy. The committee met twice to discuss applications and develop and finalize funding recommendations. The committee is recommending funding for 35 applications totaling 8 million, 521, 729 dollars. We're requesting the board's approval of these recommendations and to delegate authority to the County Administrator to sign the funding agreements. Georgina and I, along with some other members of our team, are available to answer questions that you might have. Hey, thank you Whitney. Thank you, Georgina. Any questions. I don't have any questions for the team. I just want to appreciate all the work I heard. There was a couple of questions I had you included that information. And so I'm just grateful for the work and appreciate y'all being available for questions. Thank you, Commissioner. Commissioner Stolzman since I can't see whether you're starting to speak. Do you have any questions? Thank you for the presentation and I appreciate the approach with the memo and how you've laid everything out. Thanks. Thank you, Commissioner. Okay, I don't have [0:44:20] any questions either. Um, it's always, uh, wonderful to be able to push these funds out into all the great safety net and other nonprofit providers that really do so much to further the ordre address the social determinants of health and voulder County. So I think we, uh, are ready for a motion. Move approval. We have a motion in a second, all in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. I almost forgot to say I myself. Uh, okay. Now we come to eight C and this is, uh, the Sheriff's 2026, 27 eramark Correctional Services Contract. I had asked that this B pulled for discussion because I had some questions about it. And I can't see whether we have Weinheimer or, uh, the Sheriff with us. On HC. Okay. Carry. There you are. Good morning, Commissioners Carry Weimer under Sheriff. Also with me is Jeff Getz, our jail division chief. If you have some more specific questions like can't answer. ## 8.c Sheriff's Office - 2026-2027 304442 Aramark Correctional Services [0:47:16] Yes, so to answer your first question, our commissary provider is Keefe Commissary, a separate and independent business from Airmark. So airmark does not provide our commissariats done by separate company under contract. That's good to know. Thank you. And then to try to answer your questions about Oversight and caloric content, Eramark assigns a dietician to every facility they work with. That dietician works closely with our support services commander in the jail, who makes with them on a regular basis to make sure that we're providing the right nutrition, not just in general, but also for specific diets, like special dietary needs, diabetic diets, and religious diets. We also have on staff a chaplain who assists that commander and overseeing any needs or request for religious diets, and vets those to make sure that their compliant with all federal and state laws. Okay. And I guess maybe just follow up question on that. Thank you, that's very reassuring. [0:48:22] Do you receive complaints from offenders around whether there is an uphold to keep them from being hungry and having to supplement with the commissary? So the two most common complaints in jails are healthcare and medical and food service. We receive very few grievances about our food service. And we provide two hot meals and one cold meal per day. I don't know if Jeff can answer the exact number, but we receive very few grievances about our food. Okay, well, thank you. I did share my concerns with Sheriff Johnson, so you all wouldn't be surprised this morning. And it sounds like you came ready to answer the questions, and I appreciate that. So that addresses my concerns about item 8C. Commissioners, any, do either of you have any questions. Thank you. Thanks, Sander, for being available. Just a quick question, if you can, sometimes on these documents, they'll be consistent where you see the numbers that we're talking about. It shows on here an amendment. And so I just want to wonder if you could speak to what the actual number is that you're asking. And just to clarify, you're asking for the specific dollar amount. That's the way I'm interpreting that. Yeah, so this is a, we have a five year contract with airmark. This is the first year, first annual renewal of that contract. And [0:49:53] the request is for not to exceed 2. 3 million dollars for 2027. And I can tell you, as of October 13th of this year, we spent about a million in 43, 000 dollars. So we, even though we're asking for 2. 3, we're not quite sure that that's going to all be necessary. But that is the amount not to exceed 2. 3 million for 2027. Actually, from, let me correct that from November 1st of 2026 until October 31st of 2027. That's the 12 month period for this contract. Okay. So I'm looking at the, in the memo in the packet, has a 2. 3 million dollar number and a 4. 6 million dollar five year term. Uh, 4. 6 would probably be the cumulative. Your first year and then second year. We typically increase to show that over the life of the contract what the entire cost is. And I believe this, I believe 2026 was also 2. 3. So that's why we show 4. 6 for 26 and 27. Okay. I'm sorry. I missed her. I was thinking you said a five year, but it's actually a two year for that point. It's a five year contract in total. We renew it every year. We extend the contract every year. It's a five year agreement, but we come before the board every year for renewal. In [0:51:17] case there are questions every year and then we've increased the budget. So we didn't have to do an amendment. And the factors and the numbers, I understand that change that. And it's food service. So we have to pay something that's already been complete. I was just trying to understand what number we're really looking at, the contract. And if it's an, if the term is potentially five years at 4. 6 million and we know that's not actually like, that's not really at this point a real number than just for awareness as we continue budgeting. So thank you so much. My only comment is I just, I think we should provide the same level of scrutiny for our own contract that's on the consent agenda with airmark. I appreciate this coming forward and the conversation and our, um, our County Commissioner Department that has an airmark contract also has an amendment today. And we didn't ask the same questions. And we didn't provide the same scrutiny. But I think that would be great. And I think, um, I think combining, as we've said in the past when we're new in five years, the opportunity to figure out if we can combine. So that would be three years from now, um, with JPC and the jail. Thanks. Okay. [0:52:30] So I think we've had our questions answered. Thank you very much, Carrie and Joe, even though I can't see you for, for being here this morning. We're ready for a motion on eight search. It's approval. Thank you. All in favor. Aye. All right. So we are now ready to move into our work session of Staff. Do you need some time here to get set up for the presentation on the AAA or can we head right into it? Good? Yep. Commissioner Levy Community Services has indicated that they're ready to jump right into the work session. That's wonderful. Then continue on. And for any members of the public that might be watching our work sessions are opportunities to get information, review proposals, discuss topics, sometimes direct, uh, test to have to take action on, uh, on, on the things that we as county commissioners, um, have jurisdiction over. And today we are getting a presentation from our area agency on Aging regarding the update. I'm trying to find the name of the topic or the name of the area plan for the Boulder County area, uh, Agency on Aging. And so, um, Carol, I assume you're going to be the primary presenter. Is that correct? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Great. Then go ahead and take it away. ## 10 Work Session [0:54:09] Thank you so much. My name is Carol Cross. I'm the Division Manager at the Boulder County Area Agency on Aging. And good morning. Today I'll provide an overview of the draft 2027 to 2031 area plan for the Boulder County Area Agency on Aging. I'll briefly cover the planning and funding context. What we learned from the community and how those findings shaped the proposed priorities and goals. The area plan is required for your framework that guides Aging Service Priorities for the AAA. For state fiscal year 2027, we anticipate administering approximately 2. 5 million and combined older Americans Act and State funds for senior services. This plan establishes the direction that will guide how those resources are invested over the next four years. Before turning to the Community Findings, I want to briefly explain how we put these resources to work. The AAA supports older adults and caregivers through a combination of contracted services, Community Partnerships, Direct County Programs, and client directed options, such as vouchers. The area plan does not determine specific funding awards. It establishes the framework that will guide decisions based on community need, service gaps, provider capacity, geographic access, and the ability to reach people with the greatest economic and social need. Competitive procurement for grant funded services is scheduled for spring 2027. [0:55:33] Boulder County has a strong network of organizations serving older adults and caregivers. What we heard throughout the planning process was that the need is often less about creating new programs and more about helping people access, navigate, and connect the resources that already exist, including federal programs that serve people of all ages. The area plan is intended to strengthen that network and focus resources where gaps remain. To better understand those gaps and emerging needs, we conducted an extensive community engagement process with older adults caregivers and service providers throughout Boulder County. Community engagement was central to the development of the area plan as it has been for all of our eight previous plans. We conducted 32 Community Conversations with 349 participants. 218 people completed the State Unit on Aging Survey and 55 service professionals responded to our key informant survey. Targeted outreach included Spanish speaking older adults, caregivers, LGBTQ plus older adults, residents of affordable housing communities, rural and mountain residents, and residents in long - term care like assisted living and skilled nursing. What we heard through this process directly shaped the priorities and goals in the draft plan. That Community Input was considered alongside demographic trends and priorities established by the broader aging network that will influence demand for services. Boulder County's older adult population continues to grow, both in number and as a share [0:57:06] of the overall population. Between 2027 and 2031, the population aged 60 and older is projected to increase by roughly 7, 000 people. From approximately 82, 000 to nearly 89, 000. The most significant long - term growth is expected amongst the oldest residents who are more likely to need additional support to remain independent. These trends point to an increasing demand for aging services. Both during this planning period, ambext, we'll talk about what the community shared with us. It helps us understand what the changing demand looks like in people's daily lives. Several themes emerge consistently across the engagement process. Across different communities, people describe working to remain independent while facing rising costs, increased support needs, and uncertainty about where to turn for help. Survey responded to help illustrate the extent of these concerns. And available services and supports. [0:58:21] Service providers describe many of the same challenges from their perspective. Their feedback suggests that the challenge is not a single service gap, but growing pressure across the aging services network, as more residents seek assistance and needs become increasingly complex. Together, these findings suggest that demand for Aging Services is growing faster than the system's designed to support it. The older Americans Act requires area agencies on Aging to prioritize people experiencing the greatest economic need. Poverty is one measure, but it doesn't tell the whole story in a high cost community. We also consider it housing costs, food security, transportation access, health and care expenses, and a person's ability to meet basic needs. Approximately 5800 older adults in Boulder County are estimated to live below the federal poverty line. And nearly 10, 000 live below 150 percent of that level. At the same time, many older adults above those thresholds continued to experience significant financial strain because of Boulder County's cost of living. Income is not the only factor that can limit access to services or the ability to remain independent. We are also required to prioritize people with the greatest social need. Social need reflects the barriers that can make it harder to access services and remain connected to the community. Through the planning process, we identified several populations in Boulder County that are more likely to [0:59:46] experience those barriers and may require targeted outreach and support. When we considered economic need, social need, community feedback, and provider input together, a clear set of service priorities emerged. These categories show represent the areas where needs were most consistently identified and where Strategic investments may have the greatest impact. They will guide future planning, analysis, and resource decisions during the area plan period. They do not establish funding specific funding allocations or procurement outcomes. Those decisions will occur through the appropriate funding and procurement process. The goals are intended to move beyond individual services and focus on the outcomes we're trying to achieve. While programs and funding may change over the next four years, the objective remains the same, helping older adults remain independent connected to their communities and supported in the setting of their choice. The goals provide a framework and strategies for future planning and investment decisions for both the AAA and the broader Aging Network in Boulder County. With the goals established, we're entering the final review phase. The draft plan will be available for public comment from November 16th to December 18th. During that time, we will also complete an equity impact review. Staff will then incorporate feedback, bring the plan to the aging advisory Council for a public review in January and submit the draft plan to the State Unit on Aging by [1:01:18] February 1st. Today we're seeking feedback on two questions. First, are they emerging needs or policy considerations that you feel are missing? Second, does the proposed direction align with BOCC priorities and expectations? Thank you, and I'll take any questions. Okay, thank you very much, Carol. Really informative presentation. Commissioners, um, we have two questions were asked to answer, but I think we can ask any other questions that we might want to ask as well. So, uh, the floor is open. Great, thanks. Yeah. Thank you, Carolyn team for the information, the presentation. I had a couple, maybe curiosities. One is you presented the timing. So it sounds like it'll be, um, maybe beginning of the year when we hear some of the feedback. So just curious about how that feedback will come back to the board for us to have some more conversation or an additional work session with you all. Cause I would assume there'd be some recommendations that are coming. So that's my first question. That's a great question. Thank you for it. Um, there's a couple pieces. The area plan is required to present that public information and what we did with that information. So it will be a part of the ultimate final area plan. Um, and we are happy to come back and present on that. I know that we presented at the [1:02:49] consortium of cities earlier this year and they were interested in hearing about the area plan. So that's another venue, um, that, that we would be interested in presenting this too as well. Um, so we're open to your feedback on that. Okay. Well, and will there be recommendations from that plan or will it just, is it kind of a study or is there a study with recommendations and a prioritization of. Whatever comes out of it plant. So we have listed the, the goals and objectives, implementation framework. Um, I believe the link in your, um, memo, um, that contains more specific strategies. Um, that fall into three categories. We have our internal programs that we run directly that provide services. We have, um, the funding that we put out into the community through the procurement process. And then we, we also created strategies for the more general aging network. Um, so maybe that's communities or individual, um, organizations. But recommendations for how they could implement those as well. Um, in terms of recommendations, there aren't any explicit recommendations other than identifying goals and objectives. Okay. [1:04:12] I saw the other document that had all the list of the objectives and strategies and things like that. I guess what I'm trying to understand is. It sounds like there's. A project being worked on. That may get some different feedback. And you've got already got all the strategies determined is the way I just heard that. Sure. Okay. We would take that feedback. So thank you for the opportunity to clarify. We will be taking the feedback that I think December 18th is the last day. And we will be working on incorporate, like identifying what that feedback was and incorporating it in whatever ways that we can. So to your point, those strategies could, um, be modified based on that input. And we're happy to come, um, present on any of those changes, um, once we've done that first draft. Okay. That's great. I appreciate that. Um, the other question I had is it's just, maybe. Wondering about. How to do inner departmental work in different ways. [1:05:22] Like so we're looking at County Wide, all of the different projects and programs and partnerships that are, you know, happening at the county. And there was a piece in the memo. I think it was in the OneNote specific because that document was up in the OneNote as well. In regards to, let's see here. It's the section. About what the data and community told us. And the section of bullet points, community important available data points going demand in several recurring themes. And one of those is around unmet needed for in home and caregiver support. Earlier the different section around issue of housing costs, um, affordability. There's a piece around just housing and home that, you know, has some other in the other document has some other, um, objectives, et cetera. The question I had, just kind of brought to my mind of some of the work that the housing department has been doing through the regional working group. On homelessness with an elected officials from around Boulder County region. That created an ADU toolkit. And it just made me wonder, is there an opportunity? Are you all thinking kind of County wide too? What else might be out there. In that example? Is there an opportunity for the ADU toolkit to be used. As a pilot project to try and bring some of these multiple issues [1:07:00] together. And just so it's just kind of a curiosity about what other interdeparmental team conversations may have maybe being considered as well. Outside of just general survey and feedback from residents around Boulder County. Thank you for the question. Um, I think there haven't been any purposeful outside of transportation at this time. Um, in terms of what our strategies might be interpartmentally, um, housing is one of those areas I will just admit that we have heard about housing and aging services since we were created. And it's an area that we haven't really tackled in terms of trying to move the needle in any direction. So for us, it was more of a challenge of how, what are the levers that we can pull in our space? And I think to your point, the example of leveraging things that are already available in the county and sort of pulling those resources together. Um, another aspect that is almost like the idea of a road show to sort of make sure that the other county entities know who we are and to refer to us. Um, so I think exactly what you pointed out of the things that we'll be looking to actualize, to achieve our objectives. Great. [1:08:20] Thank you. Commissioner Stolzman. Thank you. Um, it was really interesting this morning that in CPR, um, there was an article up out the hidden caregivers of Colorado's agent population. I just thought that was interesting to read after having prepared for this meeting and this topic. And it talks about how children are the primary caregivers of so many older Americans. And it was a remarkable number I forget with Article said, but a very, very high percent of middle schoolers who are these caregivers, um, for our older adults in our communities. And at Toes talks about the burden that that place is on children in the community. So when I looked at goal two again, after reading that article, I thought maybe you really underscoring some of that, um, caregiver support and understanding what that means for children who are in that role and put into that role in an increasing manner. So that just came up for me this morning thinking through that in the meeting today, but it's already in here. I just, it sort of underscored that there are caregivers look different in different families and in different parts of the county and that that would be something to think about for children that are put into that position and what we can do for caregiver support and that or relief and find other, [1:09:32] um, community responses for caregiving so that the children aren't burdened in that way. Um, the other thing that came up for me recently in, in preparing for this meeting, um, I met with the coroner around a number of his mortality statistics and just trying to understand what we see there. Um, the focus on the youth in terms of suicide, but in our county, that's actually not, um, where we see the vast majority of suicides. And I learned it's an older adult in our community and in tourist suicide, which I don't have a better term than that, but people who come into the county to go into the forest to take their life. And so just trying to understand how we can actually intervene in those tragic situations. It's really different than just providing the conventional supports. But one thing I learned is that, um, older adults who pursue medical aid and dying don't get counted toward our suicide statistics. The legislation for that excludes that. [1:10:28] But many older adults can't afford, um, that solution or don't have access to health care. And so as an older adult essentially, uh, pursues medical aid in dying on their own terms because they don't have access to healthcare. They do get counted. So in my opinion, we're currently not, um, quantifying what's happening in our community equally across different, um, economic demographics. So we can't really know what's going on. So I just wonder in the mental health section that you have a goal on, if the way to try to understand better what is happening, um, in mental health situations, or is there chronic pain? Are there other factors? Like there are a lot of different reasons. Right. And so it's not just a blanket. Like if we just do this one thing, it'll work. And I think we need to dig a little deeper in that section. But other than those comments, those are those generally, you know, what I would add to the conversation and look forward to the next steps in the conversation. Thank you. Hey, thank you for those observations. I guess my takeaway from, from this work is just how generally starve for resources we are, uh, here in addressing the needs of older adults. And that's, you know, we have the older Americans Act and we have the state unit on [1:11:59] Aging and, you know, we have this network, but it receives so much less public attention than the other things, um, that are very much important as well. But I, I wish there were more attention paid to the needs of, of, um, older adults who are trying to stay healthy and age in place that don't have the means to move into an assisted living and have all their needs met. I did just quickly look up, uh, the federal poverty level in 2026 for one person. You mentioned I think there were about 5, 800, um, people in Boulder County, uh, older adults in Boulder County that were at or below the federal poverty level. That is, it is 15, 960 dollars. And then you, you said 10, 000 people, I think, um, that were below 150 percent of FPL, which, you know, it's, it's like, uh, what is that 24, 000 dollars that I think any of us know that, um, that that is simply inadequate to be able to support yourself. And I appreciate the focus in the document on addressing, you know, just some of these, uh, income needs, uh, older, um, members of our community have that lead to so many of the other, uh, it shows that they face, um, you know, the ones that, um, can't really just be addressed with income [1:13:40] supports or the social isolation that you call out is one of the themes, um, the need for in - home and caregiver support. And this brings me to my, um, you know, my response to your first question about emerging needs or policy considerations. You know, we, our population in Boulder County is aging. It is, we are a very high cost county. We all know that. And one of the things that's causing is real difficulty in finding care providers for people, especially if they're of modest means. And I just wonder whether, whether we often, um, have some, um, you know, a section here on, um, on the labor shortage, the difficulty in finding people who can even provide the services, uh, if a person were able to afford it. And that was a question. Oh, applaud. Yeah. So the workforce question is that. No. Yeah. Is that does that even belong in here? It's a really good question. And it's something that I initially did include. And when we went to our staff and Community Partners to discuss sort of the trends we were hearing about and seeing in the Community Conversations, the feedback that I got is that while during COVID, that was a really big issue, specifically in Boulder County, um, we had a hard time getting providers, um, for the needs that we had, even funding [1:15:25] wise. We had the money, but we couldn't get enough providers to provide services. It seems as though it's course corrected specifically in Boulder County a little bit. Um, as compared with the rest of the state. I know that it is a problem at the state level. If we're looking at all those numbers. However, it seems to have improved a bit in Boulder County specifically. We will continue to keep our eye on it. Well, that's, that's good. That's good news. Uh, I wasn't aware that I guess my information is maybe a little bit more anecdotal than, than, uh, quantitative. So because I mean, I do know, uh, you know, in care providers that, uh, they often don't live in Boulder County, uh, they live in neighboring counties and that puts a strain on them and their family lives to have to travel long distance to go to work for, you know, what is often, um, not very good pay, but I'm glad you did look into that. That's, that's reassuring. Um, otherwise I, I think, you know, you've hit on so many of the really important issues. Uh, I didn't have a chance to go through the attachment F in detail because I was only granted access this morning, but I did skim through it. And, uh, and, you know, it looks very comprehensive and very [1:16:45] good. So I think it sounds like you're on the right track and we all, um, we'll just continue to follow this as you move through all the process that you laid out. Hey, thank you. And I think if we need to work and getting another work session so we can come back and speak to you about the public input and what we've incorporated, we're happy to schedule that. If that is what we need to do, then we'll make that happen. So, um, so that commissioners anything else before we close out this work session. I think the only other piece I would just, um, after the benefit of, of others comments, it made me curious about what other resources you're going to be adding into that public report and you don't have to share them right now. Or it sounds like there's some more input and then you're going to put pieces in there. Just thinking about the. Analyzing who is the caregiver in Boulder County, um, I know the reports and work done that might be able to be pulled from to add in their part of kind of understanding what, what is happening with Boulder County, but I'm guessing in that survey, you'll get a little bit more up - to - date, more recent. Information of who that is so that we can [1:18:17] think about. What, you know, maybe the policy idea from that information. So I'll just be the anxious to hear a little bit more when you have that information and put. Absolutely happy to provide that. I will mention that in years past, we have, um, worked with, um, Polco, which is the parent company of national research center to do the Community Assessment Survey of older adults. Um, we, the state was unable to secure funding for that this year. And so unfortunately we weren't able to collect the information that we have with prior plans on that more comprehensive survey, but it did allow us to be a bit more intentional about the specific questions we were asking on the ground in Boulder County. Um, I will also say that we'll be looking at, um, how to roll the area plan out and, um, communicate with our providers about that. And follow up with more data. So our, our cycle is typically to do the area plan. And then a couple more years later, we'll do a data report. And so I think to your question about specific rates of caregivers in Boulder County, that will definitely be a section of that report. Um, and we will continue to be monitoring that and working with our partners. And that space. Thank you. Okay. If we have no other [1:19:39] questions or comments or direction to provide. Thank you very much Carol for being here. And I thought I saw Robin sitting behind you. Thank you Robin for being here as well with us this morning. Uh, we do have a 1 p. m. docket coming to us from Community Planning and Permitting. So we will be in recess until one o'clock. Commissioner, are you ready? Yes, thank you. Thank you so much. And we're recording. All right, good afternoon. We are back from our recess and we have two Landy stockets on our agenda this afternoon. The first is DC26 - 003, and there are text amendments to the Landys Code related to data centers. I see Ethan Abner all ready to go at the staff desk. And just as a overview of what we'll be doing here, our landU staff, CPMP staff will explain the proposed text amendments, the commissioners will spend some time perhaps asking questions after we are finished. We will take public testimony concerning these changes. We provide up to three minutes for each person. And after that, if Ethan has anything else to add, or if we have additional questions, we will do that at that time. We will close the public hearing, The Commissioners will deliberate, and hopefully we will be making a decision this afternoon. So Ethan, you have the floor. Thank you, Commissioner. ## 11 1:00 p.m. Afternoon Session ## 11.a Public Hearing on Text Amendments to the Land Use Code related to Data Centers [1:21:53] Good afternoon, Commissioners, members of the public. My name is Ethan Abner. I am a senior planner with Boulder County Community Planning and Permitting. And today I will be presenting on docket DC - 26 - 003 text amendments to the land use code related to data centers. And just as a reminder for everyone proposed text amendments only apply to the unincorporated areas of Boulder County, not to the cities and towns like Longmont or Boulder. So just to provide a bit of background, data centers have been a controversial topic in recent months across the country, and the Board of County Commissioners expressed concerns about recent trends and potential land use impacts related to data centers and authorized staff to pursue text amendments. We had a working session on this back in May earlier this year, and the commissioners expressed concerns because the Boulder County Land Use Code does not currently define data centers as a use. It does not identify an appropriate scale of use, and it does not identify zoning districts where the use can or cannot occur. So the Board of County Commissioners and members of the public expressed interest in prohibiting these uses and preventing related land use impacts. Just to go through the timeline real quick, like I said, back in May 2026, the Board of County Commissioners held a work session that [1:23:12] was public regarding both data centers and detention centers. And then in June of 2026, text amendments were authorized by the Board of County Commissioners, as well as a moratorium on applications as they relate to data centers and detention centers, while staff worked to update the code. We had a hearing on that six - month moratorium in July of 2026, which can be extended or ended earlier, appending the outcome of today's hearing. And then in September, 2026, staff finalized drafts and sent them out on referral posted them on the web, sent them out to folks who are subscribers of the Boulder County Land Use Code News Lists serve and other folks. And then in October 21st, last month, we had a planning commission hearing, and today we are here at the Board of County Commissioners hearing and the moratorium just as a reminder is currently set to expire on December 2nd, 2026. So just to review some General Land Use Concerns related to data centers, data Centers can impact the community, and they have land use impacts. These impacts often increase as the size of data centers increase. Generally, some of the land use impacts that are associated with data centers include utilizing large amounts of energy or water, noise related usually to generators or other equipment emissions from backup generators, depending on the generator type. [1:24:34] Prominent design features that aren't typical and residential neighborhoods, and often reduced traffic impacts compared to the size of the structure. So just to summarize what we are presenting as the proposed changes to the land use code today, these text amendments would define a data center use. And that would be a facility designed or primarily used for the centralized storage management processing or transmission of digital data often characterized by high density computing equipment specialized electrical and cooling systems dedicated uninterruptible power supply, or some other form of backup power and an information technology, energy load less than or equal to 75 kilowatts. This use does not include data centers larger than 75 kilowatts, which are not permitted under this code. It would also limit data centers to the light industrial and general industrial zoning districts. It would require a limited impact special review, and it allows for incidental server rooms or technology infrastructure that support and allowed principal use in the code. So just to show you what that draft text looks like, it was included as attachment A and the staff packet, but we'll just give folks a minute to look at this. [1:25:55] And we can come back to that if we need to during the question or discussion period. So just to kind of review why staffer recommending a 75 kilowatt limitation, um, 75 kilowatts is a small amount of power when considering Dana Centers, which is in line with the express desire to limit these uses and potential impacts. Uh, 75 kilowatts of IT energy consumed over one day is going to equal about the same amount of energy consumed by 50 or 60 average homes in the same time period. Um, in doing research into this, different communities are defining data centers in different ways. And a lot of times they are including power measurements and they range from megawatts to gigawatts. And it really just depends on the community. But there is no well - defined power level at which a server room becomes a data center. Um, or a server is become a data center. Um, but staff did consider, uh, energy stars definition of a data center, which suggested that server rooms or other IT infrastructure start to resemble a data center when they're drawing 75 kilowatts or more of constant power. Um, and then just due to a rapid changes in technology, limitations on power offer a decent proxy for potential impacts, um, potential land use impacts that might be associated with data centers. So, um, [1:27:06] just to provide an example of sometimes what you might see with the size, uh, you can purchase a prefabricated, um, data center hall that has 97 racks that are pulling 5. 1 kilowatts of power per rack. And that'll fit in a 2, 700 square foot structure. Um, traditionally server racks were pulling about five to 15 kilowatts, but now with AI data centers, RACs are sometimes pulling over 50 kilowatts to 100 kilowatts. And so we are seeing an immense amount of power being pulled in an area. So structure size just isn't a really good proxy for this particular use. And, um, the water use associated with this use will also change its power increases, things like that. So we sent this out on referral, like I said, back in, uh, September. And we got feedback from the city of Boulder, which highlighted the relevant Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan Policies related to planning areas and urban development, industrial land and economic vitality and recommended consideration of additional standards related to potential impacts. And then we received responses of no conflict from little Thompson water district town of Erie Longmont Fire United Power Boulder County Conservation Eastment Program in Excel. We had a Planning Commission hearing, like I noted back in October. Um, Planning Commission voted 60 to recommend that the BOCC deny the docket, uh, they also [1:28:22] recommended a joint working session of the planning commission and the Board of County Commissioners to explore best practices related to the regulation of data centers and discuss further detailed amendments to the code with the intention of establishing a sustainable and growth sensitive definition of data centers and data storage. Um, Planning Commissions discussion and the link to this is in the staff pack if anyone wants to go back and view it. But planning commissions discussion mostly focused on whether the 75 kilowatt limitation on IT energy proposed by staff was appropriate. Whether it would be better for the county to draft more comprehensive regulations that might allow for a greater intensity of use while mitigating impacts that still may affect the community, even though the use does not occur here. So generally climate change impacts associated with data center use and expressing interest in additional detailed information about potential land use impacts, how other communities are addressing this issue and comparative information related to data centers and other permitted or existing industrial industrial uses. We also, um, received public comment, uh, we had 13 public comments expressing support for prohibiting these uses to express support for adopting the planning commissioners recommendation to express support for prohibiting or limiting these uses unless they meet certain requirements. Five supported establishing a use for data centers with standards to mitigate [1:29:41] impacts and three express support for the proposed amendments. And I've done my best to summarize the comments, but they are also available on the staff packet and those that came in after the staff packet was sent and posted. We'll also be posted online. If folks would like to take a look at those. And just as a reminder at the moratorium, I'm hearing that we had back in July. We had almost a hundred comments that were mostly in favor of prohibiting this use. So in order to amend the land use code, uh, the code, the text amendment needs to meet certain review criteria. So Article 16 of the code requires that text amendments meet the following criteria. Uh, the existing text is in need of amendment. The code doesn't currently define the data center use in appropriate intensity for that use or locations in which this use may or may not occur. The proposed text defines data centers identifies an appropriate scale of use and identifies where the use may occur. The second criteria, the amendment is not contrary to the purpose and intent of this code. The proposed amendment is not contrary to the purpose and intent of this code, which guides development in the unincorporated County and identifies appropriate locations and intensities for uses to occur based on the potential land use impacts of [1:30:51] data centers, staff proposed that these uses be limited in intensity reviewed through limited impact special review and allowed and light in general industrials owning districts. And then, uh, the third criteria is the amendment is in accordance with the Boulder County Comprehensive Plan. The Comprehensive Plan seeks to guide denser and more intense development to the municipalities while preserving the rural unincorporated lands for agricultural activities, low density residential development and other activities consistent with a rural character of the county. The proposed amendment allows data centers in a limited capacity while protecting the natural resources, environmental resources and rural areas of the unincorporated county. So staff find that the text amendment meets these criteria. And so today, uh, staffer recommending that the Board of County Commissioners approved docket DC - 26 - 003 text amendments to the land use code related to data centers. Um, with the following condition, um, show that it'd be adopted today resolution 2026 - 037, a resolution imposing a temporary moratorium on processing applications for data and detention centers and the unincorporated County pending consideration of Boulder County Land use code amendments, shall expire as to the moratorium on data center applications. The effective date of these regulations November 10th, 2026. And with that, uh, I will conclude my presentation and I'm happy to answer any questions that you have. Right. Thank you [1:32:15] so much Ethan. Commissioners Questions who wants to go first. I'm happy to start a conversation thing, Ethan, apologies for not being in person. I'm trying not to share my cold that I've got going on with folks in person. So thanks for that grace. I think a couple of things that you brought up, and I heard the statement about trying to capture as best as possible, what planning commission shared. And it just brings up the curiosity. If there's a, there's a lot happening around the country right now in regards to Data Centers. There's a lot of questions that I've seen, I've heard, webinars happening, conversations, meetings, um, on all sides of the question that I know was really concerning for me about natural resources when we think about land use that's connected to the comprehensive plan. [1:33:16] And so I want to ask just through all the research that you've done throughout the discussions, um, and the work that you all have been doing as a team. Do you think Boulder County. Should continue the mortorian to allow for more to like do you feel like there's a gap of research or information that would be helpful to the Board of County Commissioners to consider before we completed regulations? Or do you feel like what you've got right now is, is sufficient to say yes, here's, here's these next steps. And if you were having a hard time hearing me, just let me know and I can try and restate. No, no, I got your question. It's just a difficult one, I think for me to answer. So what I will say is that, um, whether or not the moratorium continues and we come back with additional information for the commissioners to consider that would be up to you all. Um, I will say that when we went through the processes of having these meetings earlier in May and June and July, um, the direction that staff received from the commissioners, which, uh, was, was to start from a place of trying to prohibit these uses or limit them. And so that's what staff is presenting here today. If the commissioners were interested in, increasing the amount [1:34:37] of power that we could allow before something would be allow for a data center, then staff could certainly, we could talk about extending the moratorium and coming back with additional information if that would be helpful. But given the direction that we received, this is where we're, we're starting. And so I hope that answers your question. Um, but if I didn't, just let me know. I think what I was asking more, you're right. We gave direction. And I, I think you've come here with, you know, what we've asked for. It was just more of a, I didn't listen to the recording, the conversation with the planning commission. So it sounded like there was an ass to have a meeting with the Board of County Commissioners to understand data centers. So it just was more of a curiosity from your analysis if based on that conversation and whatever was presented in that meeting. If there is something that Board of County Commissioners might learn that would. Add regulation, do something different with the regulation. My statement wasn't by any means. I think we should change the power limit. So. Does that help. Maybe? Yeah. Um, and I, I think the result of the planning commission hearing was the planning commissioners discussing whether or not the 75 kilowatts was appropriate. And whether or not we could potentially, the [1:36:08] sense that I got, and again, this is my perception was that the planning commission was maybe interested in allowing the use at a greater intensity, but with certain, um, certain provisions that would, uh, limit the impacts, um, and so I think that's why they wanted staff to come back with a look at what other communities were doing, which is something that we considered while we were drafting these regulations. Um, as well as, uh, some other thing, um, some potential other options. And so I think that's why planning commission gave us that direction. Okay. That helps me. I admit, I might've missed that in the initial piece. So I apologize if, if you talk to the focus of that discussion was around the 75 kilowatt versus either potential pieces as well of the regulations. Okay. That was my initial question. Thank you. All right. Commissioner Stolzman. [1:37:00] Thank you. I don't have any questions. Thank you for the presentation. Okay. Um, I have just one or two, I guess. I'm wondering, so the way this is structured is that if, uh, if you, if the use is. 75 kilowatts or less, it is allowed in the General Industrial Enlight Industrial. And if it's larger than that because it's not addressed, then it would not be allowed in the code. And so this limitation doesn't apply to, you know, the thing that I think I was expressing concern about that we'd be sensitive to that, you know, certain businesses have server rooms. And I don't know what they're, you know, I don't know what the energy usage is in that server room, but, you know, that we didn't want if the use that's otherwise allowed. And as an accessory to it or just part and parcel of their business, they do a lot of data processing. We didn't want to prohibit that. So I'm wondering just with that framing the 75 kilowatts of energy use, which isn't, it's not computing capacity. I don't believe like do you, do you feel like. Well, never mind. I don't know how to ask that question. This is, this is a tricky one because I can't conceptualize it, which makes it hard to, to pose a question that really would help [1:38:52] me understand. I guess I, I do, I wonder where the 75 kilowatts comes from. Why that? And, you know, what we're trying to do as address the consumption of power. That consumption of water. And some of the externality that I've only read about, I've not experienced. So we're, you know, the people talk about the noise, kind of the humming, um, maybe vibration and then because it needs done an interruptible power, you know, the generators come on. So we're trying to address those externalities. We're not, I don't, I mean, I think we don't make land use decisions because it's a bad, you know, it's a, it's a thing we don't like. So how does that 75 kilowatts relate to the, the thing we're trying to address. Yeah. So, um, the 75 kilowatts that staffer proposing would be related to information technology IT energy. And so that would be the energy that powers, um, things like servers networking equipment, other IT equipment. Um, and like I said, during the presentation, we think that power is a good proxy for, um, for dealing with some of the other land use impacts that are associated with data centers. Um, 75 kilowatts would be a fairly small data center. Um, like I said, other communities have been, uh, working to describe these. I know that generally they're talking about data [1:40:21] centers and the more hyperscale sense. And those are the larger ones pulling megawatts of power. Um, but the 75 kilowatts that we came up with was because of the direction and interest in starting from a place of limiting these impacts. Um, energy star, which is a federal program that's responsible for doing energy audits for different types of, uh, energy uses and facilities, defines a data center. And specifically says that in, in their literature, that wants a server room reaches 75 kilowatts. It starts to resemble something like a data center. Um, at least if it has those other characteristics that we, we defined, uh, for that specific use and then going back to some of the things that we're discussed at the previous hearings about the difficulty in defining this use while also allowing it to occur. I think one of the things that you may have been getting at earlier, um, in your question and correct me if I'm wrong is that in the land use code, when we are defining a use, we're defining a principle use that can occur on a parcel. And defining it what level that use can or cannot occur and how it occurs. And so in this instance, if there is a parcel and the light industry or our general industrial district and someone comes and says, I want [1:41:33] to build a data center that's less than 75 kilowatts and they go through the limited impact special review and they get approved to do that. They can do that. However, if there is an existing use in our code, no commercial or a business or other use. And someone just happens to have a server room that's incidental and subordinate to that use. Then we're not going to consider that a data center. That would just be part of, uh, an existing principle use that's permitted by the code. And so that's kind of how we've tried to address that tricky area of allowing server rooms to still occur while also prohibiting data center or limiting data centers as a principal use. Okay. Thank you. Um, so then, uh, I have two more specific questions. One, the city of Boulders responds notes, uh, that Boulder is a quantum hub quantum computing hub. That does take a lot of data processing. Um, I don't want to try to paraphrase it too loosely, but basically I read it to be, you know, might we might we be jeopardizing or inhibiting the ability of Boulder University Boulder or Colorado at Boulder to really fully develop the, the quantum computing, um, focus that they are, uh, working on by having this limitation. [1:43:08] I think limiting data centers to a certain size would impact the ability for some of that could impact the ability for some of that work to occur, but also, you know, municipalities can craft their own regulations that allow for certain uses in a data center use might be something that they allow for in the future. Or I'm not up to date on their regulations right now, but, um, they, they can allow for the use to occur within their, um, within their jurisdiction. But in our jurisdiction, you know, we would, we would be allowing the use to occur on general industrial and light industrial parcels of which there are only 107, um, so I don't know whether or not our regulations would impact their ability directly, given that they have their own opportunities to craft regulations. [1:43:53] But I could see that, you know, limiting it's something like 75 kilowatts rather than one megawatt might have an impact, but that's just in general. Okay. I mean, you're basically saying if it's important to the city of Boulder, they can allow them, I think, but you're being a lot more polite. Um, uh, um, my other question is whether we need to add any new provisions to the limited impact special review criteria to get at the specific, um, impacts of data centers that, in instances where they are allowed, uh, the specific impacts that we may want to be mitigated. In staff's proposal, we're not proposing anything like additional provisions in the use or changing the limited impact special review criteria, which would allow staff to review any proposed use and then condition to mitigate impacts that we might be concerned with. Um, and I know in the public comments, a lot of the concerns were related to noise or water, um, other environmental concerns, which if we had concerns with something someone was proposing, we could address those through limited impact special review. Um, so I think there's sufficient opportunity in the review criteria as it currently exists and the review itself is it currently exists. [1:45:19] To mitigate any concerns that we have. And for folks who may not be familiar with limited impact special review, um, I just want folks to know that at staff review, the proposal, but then that proposal ultimately comes to a public hearing before the Board of County Commissioners. Um, so just something to be aware of. So yeah, thank you. So do we have provisions that address like Excessive Water Consumption or consumption of energy such that, um, the grid becomes unstable or do we leave that to like the referral response from United Power or, or Excel energy or whoever's territory it's in. Um, I, the, the. The criteria and the limited impact special review are not that specific as it relates to those particular things, but it does talk about environmental impacts where other impacts that, um, might not be in accordance with the comprehensive plan. And then we do consider those things like referrals. Um, I think, you know, the reason you don't see, um, specific additional provisions in this draft is because with 75 kilowatts of, of power you're talking about a more limited impact that you, then you would see in a, in a very large structure. So if we did or even a larger structure, so if we did have any concerns, um, even though the criteria are not specifically related to addressing, [1:46:40] you know, power consumption, uh, one may be related to addressing water consumption, but I'd have to look at the criteria real quick. But I think there's sufficient guidelines and guidance in the criteria to address those issues, even though it's not specifically stated. Okay. All right. Well, those were my questions. Thank you so much. Uh, I think we are ready now to take testimony from the public. And if we could get the list. Here. Okay. So we will just take testimony from people in the order in which they signed up, uh, and we, uh, again, as a reminder, three minutes each. Uh, there's a, if you're testifying in person, on the screen behind the dais, uh, we ask that you start by stating your name. So first we will hear from Josh Maynard. Just right up at the podium here in the middle. Thank you, Josh. [1:47:40] Hi there. My name is Josh Maynard. I'm not fully knowledgeable about the current limits that you have on data centers. So apologies for not being as informed as one could. But I'm here to advocate to continue the moratorium just to find out potentially new info that we don't know yet kind of pertinent to your last conversation. Um, some things that I learned recently is the new study that came out suggesting that, uh, data centers can be contributing to colony collapse for bees. Um, and so I'd like to see some more data on that before we decide how we move forward. Um, I'd also really love to see, uh, the necessitation of reclaimed water in data centers, um, I'm sure you're all familiar with the considerations, uh, of water use in them, uh, and our potential problems with drought here. Um, if they used reclaimed water, that would reduce, uh, their impact significantly. The other thing that I'd like to see is, uh, specific violations set up ahead of time for noise or vibrational, um, violations. [1:48:50] I was just spending some time here listening to the, uh, overview. And it sounds like light in general industrial does have decibel limits, which is fantastic. Um, but really the concern is, uh, you hear about data centers in Michigan, um, that can be heard six miles away and felt, uh, almost as many miles away. And so I'd like to make sure that we don't run into those by, uh, addressing it head on beforehand. Um, and establishing, I didn't see anything in the regulations about vibrational regulations, but I did see stuff on noise regulations. Um, so I'd like clear finds, uh, defined ahead of time. Same with air pollution requirements. Love to have some fine set up ahead of time. So people that are investing in data centers here know what, uh, they're doing by exceeding these limits. Um, I also don't know, how do I put this. You got to start somewhere with regulation and a 75 kilowatts is probably a great place to start. [1:49:49] But because it's dependent on the energy source used to then produce those 75 kilowatts that can come with its own, uh, problems. So it might be interesting to regulate what, uh, energy sources can be used to make that ideally renewable since that's kind of part of the comprehensive plan. And I think that is, Oh, and then also if we're worried about quantum computing, um, most stuff is done on the cloud anyway. And so the cloud, uh, the speed at which you can converse with the cloud is light speed. If you have fiber optics. So I wouldn't worry about the size of the data centers that were restricting here because you can always do cloud storage and computing literally anywhere on the planet. And that's pretty much all I have. So thank you for my time. [1:50:37] All right. Thank you for joining us this afternoon. Jason Valerie. No one is coming forward. Oh, thanks for letting me know. Beth Ethan. Hello. I'm a Boulder Count Boulder County resident in unincorporated Boulder County. And I came today also to ask you to, um, could you just state your name, please. Thanks. And my name's Beth Egan. I also came today to ask you to continue the moratorium. I very much appreciate that the 75 kilowatt limitation is a useful proxy. I don't, however, think it's quite rigorous enough. And I do think that the limited impact special review code regulation should be amended now before the moratorium is lifted to address all of the externalities that were well aware of with regard to data centers. So that would be the water usage admissions noise vibration. Not only that, the efficiency of the data center itself. There are efficiency guidelines for how efficiently the data center uses the power that it's using. And I just wanted to say specifically with regard to water. I am one of the unincorporated Boulder County residents who recently installed a cistern. Every water usage in Boulder County affects every other water usage. And I don't think that should be dealt with on the back end. And that we should all be showing up here with respect to every single [1:52:14] 75 kilowatt data center that's seeking approval and having to express our concerns when we can deal with it on the front end now in the limited impact special review regulations. I also, um, did want to note, which is a lesser concern, but it was addressed by one of the supervisors. I think we should, um, include in the code an example of what we mean by, um, server room that subordinate and incidental. To a principal use. Perhaps I'm wrong. Perhaps that's crystal clear, but that seems like a potential loophole that data center and developers could walk through and it might as well be closed now. Um, and again, I just wanted to emphasize that we're well aware that data centers can overwhelm local infrastructure and that every locality has different local infrastructure concerns. I think on the front end before anything is allowed as a permitted use. There should be specific code regulations that address those concerns. Thanks so much. Okay. Thanks very much for your testimony. Giselle Hersfeld. I. Just. [1:53:37] Good afternoon Boulder County Commissioners, my name is Giselle Hersfeld and I'm here with the Rocky Mountain Peace and Justice Center. I want to begin by applauding the Boulder County Commissioners for passing a moratorium on two of the most dystopian and unethical forms of development plaguing our communities. Detention Centers and Data Centers. At the July 2nd meeting this year, the Voices of the Boulder County Community were loud and clear in their unanimous rejection of data center and detention center development in Boulder County. The people of Boulder County do not want more data centers here or anywhere. During this year's legislative session in Colorado, House Bill 1030 to incentivize the build out of data centers received such an overwhelming title wave of public opposition that its first hearing was postponed repeatedly throughout the session only to be postponed indefinitely without every evening to hear a single public comment. Across the U. S. people are rising up against data centers that have been forced into their communities which have led to unaffordable energy rates depleting freshwater supplies air pollution noise pollution and alarming climate impacts, which will lead to an escalation of natural disasters here and everywhere. Additionally, we must consider the ethical implications of AI and its ties to mass surveillance, militarism, human rights violations, and genocide, just to name a few. We should not be expanding [1:54:57] the development of infrastructure that serves as the foundation of a potentially dangerous and highly risky new technology, which the U. S. government is severely lagging on regulating. As AI tech companies continue to run rampant, even heads of major AI tech companies are urging a slowdown of AI technology and raising alarms regarding the potential existential threats posed by AI. An article published in The Guardian in September of 2026 should give everyone here chills. Its titled Anthropic Researchers say AI could cause human Extinction by 2030. This warning alone should be enough to give every county in the nation's serious pause before approving any new data center development. By passing a moratorium this year, Boulder County has been ahead of the curve on this issue. And again, I thank you and applaud you. Um, with the moratorium set to expire on December 2nd. I want to strongly and respectfully urge the commissioners to enact a permanent and comprehensive ban on data centers and Boulder County. You have the power to protect your constituents from this harmful development and I assure you that you have the backing and support of your community in this decision. Thank you for taking the time to listen to your community on this important issue. Okay. Thank you very much for your testimony. Uh, we will hear from Josef Bonaparte next. Hi everybody. Thank [1:56:16] you so much. I'm Yosepona board, Professor and Finance. I'll see you Denver. And I'm the author of both for about data center policy and facts versus myth. I just want to start with the I am independent researcher. I don't have any interest for other men group. I want to say two things here. First I want to start with the 75 kilowatt. I just want to give you a perspective. It's got one restaurant and third list three. 75 kilowatt. It's like a one restaurant. Boulder three. Basically it's a no. If you want to give them 75 that is an um that's not capability. So what I'm going to talk about it is what we should do. I think what we should do is two things. Number one is to continue the discussion which is redoing now. [1:57:04] Understand the problem and understand the opportunities. Let me talk with the opportunities and the problems. The opportunities are three. One is innovation. We want to keep Colorado in a forefront for innovation. Number two details. Cities Counties will have a very nice text based from Datasetting. Number three jobs jobs opportunity for the county for the cities, for Colorado. So Aniviation texted revenue and jobs. The problems are water, electricity. And ecology. Water every 1114 chat cost one bottle of water that I have it in my hand. That's a size. So it's cost water. It's zero technology solution. Yes. There is a circle water circle. You can do on this. You have a lot of water. Electricity. We should ask them to come with neutral electricity. Solar panel or wind ecology. The third one is ecology. So we're going to ask them to be far from the community. [1:58:10] So noise over any other things not to be there. I want to summarize what I see here. What I see here as I'm speaking with you on the girl before me, uh, Giselle, I think her name. As we speak all of us, we're using data center. We as the event now reason data setting. When she was reading her phone season. So we need that the son. The city need. The state needed caned. We saw the problem with AI. There are some downsides. So the challenge for us and the next step to six seconds is how to build data center safe for the community. And keep Colorado forefront of innovation. Offering job and revenue. I have solution to all the concerns by the community. I'll be more than happy to meet with you guys. Whenever you have time to tell you the solution for every problem. [1:59:03] And I want to finish with something Kim and if and for me to me yesterday. Thank you. Okay. Thank you so much for joining us. Uh, we have someone who just signed up with the name Nari. Hello. I am Nary. I wanted to come out here. I've been basically traversing the entire state. I've been to Pueblo. I've been degriely. I've been to Aurora. I've been to Denver. And these are all not in Pueblo. But the other places are all communities where data centers are being built or are proposed to be, uh, built. And I do want to commend, uh, y'all, for, uh, getting ahead of this before it becomes a huge issue. Cause usually it's not these hypothetical, what if a data center decides it wants to show up here. It's they're building it across the street from my house right now. And I don't know what to do. Those are the stories I've been hearing around the state. One thing that you might have trouble with, uh, with this definition of data center that you're using of 75 kilowatts is that the data centers aren't going to share with you the amount of energy they're going to be used. That's a trade secret. No city I've been in has been able to get that information from the data center. So they're either [2:00:37] producing some of the energy on their own. Yes. What is being used by Excel that can be a public record. But that's going to be difficult information for you to be able to grab. So just things to keep in consideration while we're trying to regulate these going forward. That'll be a tricky definition to use, uh, when you hit that line. I don't really have much, uh, substance to contribute on top of what Giselle was saying. Kudos to her for stepping out and saying like some of the real consequences of the data centers, uh, that are going up. Uh, but it might be worth reemphasizing just stories I've been hearing around the state, uh, that yes, there is the volume. Yes, the water issue usage, uh, Aurora has adopted that the water must be recycled. But some of the regulation that they're still struggling with is you still need to flush those systems out here and there, uh, which again, normal and fine. You can still build a data center with relatively low water usage, but it does need to get fleshed out. But you need to make sure that the water systems that you have are able to clean it once it gets into the sanitary process. Because right now again, things being protected by insider, uh, secrets. We don't. It's not just water all [2:02:03] the time. We don't know what's going to be in the water. Uh, when it's getting flushed out. So with the last few seconds, I have here. Just thank you for being ahead on this. I've been going around the state. I've also been collecting postcards to send to fill wiser to make sure that this gets regulated at the state level. He promised that he would provide some state level support for those. If you would like to send him a postcard, find me after this. And I will have you fill it out and you can send it to, I'll send it to him for you. Thank you for your time. All right. Thank you so much. Um, is there anyone in the hearing room who would like to testify on this docket who has not done so and I will ask Commissioner Stolzman to let me know of anyone is getting up in a protein. I see no movement in the room. Okay. Great. Then I think we've heard from everybody who wanted to speak to this land use docket. We will close the public hearing portion of public testimony portion of the hearing. Ethan. Would you have any comments you want to make that address the testimony? Yeah. I just make three comments. And if there's anything in particular, the commissioners want me to follow up [2:03:17] on I'm happy to try and do that. But, uh, fortunately for me, some of my colleagues in the back were able to pull up some of the relevant criteria in the limited impact special review as it relates to this use. And so one of them is the user activity will not result in over intensive use of land or excessive depletion of natural resources. And then it goes on. It's a very long paragraph, but it goes on, uh, to talk about structures and land disturbance and the use of sustainable construction techniques, resource, use, and transportation management should be things that are considered during a limited impact special review. Um, there's also a criteria as it relates to, uh, the activity or use not causing significant error, odor, water, or noise pollution. And then another that talks about the user activity will establish an appropriate balance between curtain and future economic environmental and societal needs by minimizing the consumption and inefficient use of energy materials, minerals, water land and other, uh, finite resources. So the criteria are, I think, specific enough to help us through the limited impact special review process with that. Um, I would also just like to clarify or remind folks that, uh, staff are here today proposing a definition and a 75 kilowatt limit on the IT energy. When the moratorium was put [2:04:25] in place, we had to define a data center and the data center definition and the moratorium allows for a facility up to 500 kilowatt hours. So staffer proposing something that's almost seven times less than that. Um, and then finally as it relates to data centers, maybe not giving us their information, um, annual reports or something that we could probably request through limited impact special review. And if that's not the case, uh, electric work in the unincorporated County has to be permitted. And I've spoken with our electrical permitting folks. And it sounds like it's pretty easy to spot some of these things. And so I think we have sufficient measures in place as it relates to some of those things to, um, uh, enforce the regulations as they're written. Um, I think those are the three things that I wanted to address, but like I said, if then particular you'd like me to touch on, I'm happy to do that. Okay. Great. Thank you, Commissioners. Any additional questions from Ethan based on the testimony or something that just came to mind. Thank you. Thanks, Ethan, for that. I, uh, and I appreciate the, the quick review on the limited impact special review. One of the pieces for me that I'm still trying to consider in this person and the discussion that we'll have here in a, [2:05:43] in a little bit is my concerns with interpretation. Um, and so I heard you list those off. And I was like, you know, it just brings me some pause and concern of, you know, some point in the future if we had a group of County Commissioners that, that had a different, you know, a set of values or had changed strategic priorities or something that maybe we can't imagine right now, but it's, it is a possibility. And so, um, and I, I think my question for you would just be given some of the, the public comment and additional asks of, um, doing what I kind of interpreted is doing additional research. If there was any of those pieces that, that brought you some, um, pause and what you would. Want to do some more research or investigate in any of the topics that were brought up. [2:06:35] Um, I, I don't think so. I think the regulations that are presented by staffer sufficient, we did consider the other impacts that would be related to a data center use. And again, I hate to repeat myself. But power is a good proxy. Right. So if we talk about the, um, I think someone kind of touched on it in their comment about the power use of power usage effectiveness of data centers. Right. When we talk about a 75 facility using 75 kilowatts of IT energy and we consider perhaps, um, uh, what that entire facility use would be if it had a power usage effectiveness of 2. 0, which is a very conservative estimate the entire facility would use 150 kilowatts of power. There's also a measure for water usage effectiveness. And for something that's using 75 kilowatts of IT energy when we did the math, it comes out to about 900 gallons, which is what, um, an average, uh, home uses about 300 gallons a day. [2:07:30] So you're looking at about three homes worth of water use in a day. And so when we considered the potential impacts that might come from allowing the facility at 75 kilowatts, we didn't put any of those additional provisions as it relates to noise because we have a noise ordinance as it relates to, um, water or power effectiveness, uh, or power. Because we felt like the use that we were allowing the impacts from that use would be, um, fairly small. Um, and that, that didn't necessitate additional provisions. And then if there were concerns in the future, those could be addressed through limited impact special review because if we, as we have acknowledged, um, this use is, is changing rapidly. Um, and so who knows what the future holds, but that's one of the benefits I think a discretionary review gives us is that we can, we can adapt to those changes in the future. So I would say that based off of what staff has seen, um, and what, what, uh, that these regulations are sufficient to address those concerns. Thanks for that. I wondered if there was in the limited impact special review if the piece in there that addresses the conversation around any restrictions or requirements for renewable energy. Um, there is that criteria in that addresses, uh, energy resource or resource energy usage, [2:08:55] um, but I think that there are a variety of things that you can condition throughout the limited impact special review. Um, it, I don't know that it specifically says that something has to have renewable energy, but it contemplates the type of energy that something is using and the resource intensity of it. And so there may be an opportunity in that respect to condition some sort of renewable source if that were the, if that were determined to be a mitigating factor for any land use review related to this particular use. Well, and I think what I'm not looking for policy that then would create mitigating factor opportunities for me. I feel like that's just not what I would want to create. I'm more interested in. How might we not allow data centers. And what would restrictions, what would be the most restrictive way to do that. [2:09:49] I would prefer to send a clearer message about not having data centers. Versus maybe somebody could interpret it this way. And then we could, if I, if I somehow with technology and, you know, in set amount of time could figure out how to do a totally renewable energy quote unquote, then I'd be okay. And so that's what I, that's what I'm trying to avoid. And so I also didn't see something that would address renownable energy restrictions and see it as a potential opportunity, but I just wasn't sure. If it would just be a condition if that's what you were saying or if there would be another or if that's something that we would need to talk about if we wanted to do this differently, either from a tiny standpoint or add any other, um, additional items for conditions now. So I think it's something that you could consider, like I said, through the limited impact special review process, those sorts of conditions, but given that 75 kilowatts is comparatively small for a data center. That's why you don't see a specific renewable energy requirement in this. Um, other communities have drafted provisions that require a certain amount of the energy to be renewable. So that's certainly something that communities are doing. But in those instances, the communities are also allowing or appear [2:11:11] to be allowing data centers of larger sizes in the megawatts or tens of megawatt ranges. And so that's why you're seeing those, um, I think some of those provisions. We could certainly draft one. But again, I don't think, I think based off of what we've got here that we have sufficient, um, sufficient regulations to, to, uh, limit the impacts of that use. Okay. And I just have one last question because there's been a little bit of equation on server room to a really small data center and just wanting to understand right now in an incorporative Boulder County for the industrial use that we're talking about. Do we know how many of those properties currently have server room and or is there a specific section of the code that talks about server rooms as incidental or just being able to be used completely? Maybe principal use. [2:12:11] So I don't know the total number of facilities that have server rooms in the unincorporated county. But I think, you know, it's this as staffer proposing the text, it establishes a principal use for a data center. So again, if somebody just wanted to build a data center on a light industrial parcel and it met the code and it was approved, they could do that. Um, unfortunately when you, it's my experience that when you write code, you can't write code for everything. And so sometimes it does require some interpretation. But again, based off of how our land use code works, you know, if a principal use exists and then it has a use that is incidental or subordinate to that use, we call them accessory uses. And we determine that a server room is accessory to, you know, someone who runs a, I don't know, a small facility and has, you know, a server, a couple of server racks in the closet. But, um, being a data center isn't their everyday use than we would call that we would make an interpretation that I think that's a server room and then we would allow that use to continue. Um, and so I think, you know, we've tried to address the concerns related to the principal use of a parcel as a data center, but also still [2:13:18] allow for server rooms, uh, server rooms to occur, recognizing that they would be a subordinate and generally smaller use. Um, and so that's just, there is no definition of server room in the code, but that is, that is what, you know, there is that provision and the additional provision section that talks about server rooms or accessory IT infrastructure being permitted. Okay. And I'm just having a land use. Reflection. On a docket that we had. I don't know, maybe in the last six months where there was a. Gymnasium. That was an accessory use to a property, to a home. And the gymnasium was much bigger. Than actual house. And so I'm just trying to like think about all the different loopholes and the ways that this could play out. And, um, and so I appreciate what you're saying, Ethan. And I'm just trying to figure out again, my initial question was, do we need more time? [2:14:25] Is there more restriction and upfront pieces that we need to consider? And so I'm listening to the public comment and just wanting to check in and see if anything, if there was any of those pieces again, as I started this, this piece of just curiosity that we, that, that you would think maybe we, maybe it would make sense for us to take a look at, but I'm, I'm hearing a strong no. And so I appreciate the, the conversation and the ability to have a little bit of dialogue as we consider a really important text amendment for Boulder County Land Juice Code. Uh, Commissioner Stoltzman, did you have any follow up? Yeah. Thank you. So the Colorado Sun ran an article yesterday where Michael Booth wrote quote Boulder County's poised to go full NIMBY, not in my Boulder Yard on potential data centers with commissioners voting on draft rules that would effectively shut down the concept by sharply limiting the power they could draw. And quote. [2:15:22] And then we heard today from Community members and we've heard from Community Members in previous comment, um, that they feel this does not go far enough to protect the community from the negative impacts that we know data centers can poise with effects on roads, noise, electricity, water light, safety, environment in the cost of living. So my question for you is, do you feel like this is threading the needle that will allow computing, um, in businesses and in the light industrial district. But sends a clear message that we're promoting health and safety and wellbeing of the community and won't allow for unfettered growth of data centers. Yes. Thank you. Nicely done. Um, uh, so I don't want to open a can of worms with my question, but as I was, but I may just do that. [2:16:13] As I was listening to some of the testimony about, you know, the amount of vibration or that they have to have, uh, you know, closed loop water systems or they have to use renewable energy or, you know, whatever the, you know, all the things that people are wanting to make sure that as we become more reliant on information technology, these, these things don't have all these deleterious, um, effects. I was, I was thinking about the distinction between regulating the land use and making sure that the land use is appropriate and that it doesn't have, uh, inappropriate impacts on the surrounding area. Excuse me. And regulating the business. And the reason I was thinking about that distinction is because there was legislation last year to try to get at the business itself or the use itself and how that use is done and how, how much water and how much electricity and what kind of backup power it has. State, um, although sometimes acts like it has lineous powers. These were not land use. This was not a piece of legislation that was regulating land use. [2:17:40] And so I guess I'm wondering with, with that little bit of, of, um, preface about. You know, what the, what that distinction is. And maybe it's not a firm distinction where we, we can say this is a general enlight industrial is the appropriate place to have this use, i. e. a data center that is 75 kilowatts or less or uses, you know, whatever the language is. And we also have the ability to condition things to prevent unwanted impacts on the surrounding area and on the environment and all the factors that you just identified, you know, that, you know, that is one sort of things that we can do through our land use powers. A great answer for that question. I would say in thinking about some of the things that we might include as additional provisions as it relates to the type of water, like the type of water system that a data center uses, some communities are prohibiting the use of evaporative cooling, which is the most water intensive use, like closed loop systems, which are less water intensive uses. And I would defer to an attorney, but I don't know that there would be a difference between us, including that in the code itself versus including it as a condition of a land use review as far as its effectiveness, if [2:20:01] that makes sense. Okay, yeah, I mean, I think you're saying there isn't any firm line between what you do in your land use regulations and what the legislature might do or what a municipality that has more plenary regulatory power might do. Here. Because I think that's what, you know, I know we are all concerned about the growth of AI and what that will do to our society. And that's its own problem. We're just trying to, we're trying to regulate a use that, in my opinion, does not belong in on incorporated Boulder County because we really don't want to have a growth of development and incorporated Boulder County. We do have some industrialized zoned areas. So that's why we're here. But in general, we don't want to have this use. So, all right. Commissioners, if there are no other questions, oh yeah, Commissioner Lawrence, you mean? [2:21:15] Thank you. Just a question. Ethan. What's the Boulder County Land use text amendment. Version of a ban. Of a specific use. So it's a little bit complicated. And I'm going to do my best to describe it. And so if I mess up or it's not clear, just please let me know because I know what I know, but I don't know what other people don't know. The land use code in Boulder County as it works right now is we define uses that are permitted in the unincorporated County, and we define how those uses are permitted and where those uses are permitted. We don't really talk about what uses our prohibited generally if someone comes in with a use. We try and determine whether or not it fits under an existing use category, which was part of the concern with this particular use, because we thought it might fit under general industrial or light industrial without any additional provisions other than the special review that that use requires. So generally, the easiest way to quote unquote prohibit a use in a code that is based off of allowing uses is to limit the impacts of that use. [2:22:20] And in order to do that, you have to define it. When we were going through the process of drafting the text for this, because our code works the way that it does, we did try and draft text that talked about defining data center in Article 18 of our code, which is where our definitions are. And then prohibiting that use in the general industrial definition. The problem that we ran into with that is because our code doesn't work that way. It made interpreting the provision itself difficult. And that just, we don't want to create an unclear code. So in the context of how our code works and how land use works and unincorporated Boulder County, we determine that the best path forward would be to define a limited use and then say that that use is permissive to a certain degree. And in thinking about it, right, rather than define 75 kilowatts as a IT infrastructure that's permitted or whatever, we chose to define it as a, just call it a data center use. That way, if somebody came in and said, well, can I have a data center? It's very clear for people who are looking at the land use code and aren't experts in reading land use code. And it's clear for staff who are interpreting the land use code that something that meets [2:23:26] these provisions is going to be considered in unincorporated Boulder County at data center. And then we put in the 75 kilowatts, um, in trying to define data centers if you just talk about things that store data and transmit data, um, you're just, you're talking about a server. And so how do you establish a limitation at what point a server becomes a data center? And if there is no clear delineation in there, then you have arguments in interpreting the code text about where that happens. And so I hope, I answered your question about why it's defined as a specific use and not outright prohibited, um, because we had to draw that sort of distinction between accessory IT infrastructure that currently exists, but also prohibit or like limiting the principal use. Um, does that answer the question? [2:24:13] Does that make sense. It makes sense. I, I think the way you started with that answer was to limit impacts is what you said. Which I think that makes, I mean, that also makes sense. And it also begs for me the question of should we not address some of the impacts that we're talking about now instead of leaving those up for interpretation, um, for later boards, uh, but that does, that does. Answer the question, um, that I was asking. So thank you. Okay. If we have no further questions for Ethan, then I think the time has come for us to deliberate and make a decision on this. Who would like to start us off. I'm happy to share my thoughts. Sure. Go right ahead. Great. As an elective representative, my primary responsibility is to the health and wellbeing of the community. Data Centers have the potential to negatively impact roads, noise, electricity, light safety, the environment and the cost of living. I'm really proud of the commissioners for looking to adopt land use codes that can protect our community from these negative externalities. In addition to the clear land use and compatibilities and community impacts associated with data centers, there are ethical and moral issues that require further exploration before we would allow unfettered development of these types of facilities. I would invite and welcome [2:25:48] other representatives around the state and country to join in our effort to promote healthy communities and address the impacts of data centers for everyone in the country. And I think that by limiting the use to 75 kilowatts of power were effectively mitigating the harms and impacts to the community and the externalities that our community members have raised concerns about. So I will be voting in favor of these regulations today. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Uh, Commissioner Lorcherman. What are your thoughts. Thank you. Yeah. I, um, thanks Ethan. Thanks for to the team for coming back with a through a process to be able to address. The more Torium that we placed in regards to the data center, the topic one right now in this docket. For me, I was interested in a conversation with the board around, um, continuing, um, more Torium to consider, um, putting in some more stringent conditions of that, what could be the limited social, or I'm sorry, sorry. I'm not feeling well. So I'm having our time here. The limited impacts to study or, um, so that's one piece I was hoping to have a little bit of conversation about. [2:27:07] And then otherwise actually doing a reduction, um, to what you were just talking to the 75 kilowatts. And part of it's because I feel like there is as we've all been discussing here all of these unknowns and all of these questions. And so it'd be too bad if we got to something that was, um. I just, I think it leaves it open to too many different questions that would still have the high impacts. And I think go in conflict with the Boulder County values and what we're trying to get here in regards to reducing the opportunity. Of data center damage in Boulder County. So those I was, I was, um, just going to share a couple of where I'm at as thoughts. I don't have a closing statement. Yet. Yeah. I think that's what we're all doing is just sharing where we are on, on what Ethan has proposed in consultation with his colleagues at Community Planning and Permitting. Um, I, um, I did have a number of questions which, uh, which Ian answered about whether the limited impact review criteria would allow us to consider these impacts that we are so concerned about. And, uh, and in my judgment, they are adequate to, to give us that latitude. Um, I also think there is plenty of room for the legislature to take action, uh, [2:28:50] that to require a certain things, uh, on a statewide basis so that communities aren't left, uh, to try to grapple with this on their own, uh, we're fortunate to have, uh, very good staff who have the ability to do this research. Some communities aren't so fortunate. And so I do think the room for the legislation. So that we can have one consistent standard on energy consumption, water consumption, uh, noise vibration, whatever the various externalities may be. But I feel that with regard to Boulder County, um, short of complete prohibition, uh, this 75, um, kilowatt does seem to be a good proxy for a lot of sleezed, um, data center that we can deal with in Boulder County. Um, you know, this is not the last word. If we find that, that we're not able to address some of these issues as people have testified better to do it up front than have a real case in front of us and realize that we actually don't have those tools. But, but, you know, we've had many, many kinds of cases come to us through that limited impact special review process that I think we've been able to, uh, we've had the latitude to address those concerns. [2:30:30] So I feel like what we've got is sufficient to allow us to move forward. I'll just ask Commissioner Salzman if the interest in reducing the kilowatt number. I do feel like the 75, um, provides quite a lot of regulation. I'm open if you would like to lower it to some other proposal I'm open to hearing what the number is. I think the reason the number and not just an outright ban, like some have called for is to allow for some computing and, um, differentiating between where computing ends and data center starts take some defining and definition. So that's where the number has come from. But if you'd rather that was 50 kilowatts or some other number I'm open to entertaining that, I'm always open to entertaining that all of the people that use, um, energy in the county are required to use renewable energy. So I'm also open to that in this case as well. [2:31:26] But, um, I don't think that that's been drafted day. But if we want to put additional environmental regulations on our building codes, I'm always supportive of that too. So I would be open to hearing what a different number is. Yeah. Thanks for that. There might've been body language and I just couldn't see. So that's why I thought I just ask specifically the 50 was the number that was coming to my mind. I don't have a calculation. I was trying to do some really just general online research looking at Scorpee thinking, you know, land use impact. So there was several different numbers that I saw. But I think from what you're talking about, of like, do we want to allow for computing of some sort in this particular area of an incorporate Boulder County? I get that, that makes sense to me. Um, and I'm just, I do have a concern about, um, having. Having, uh, 75 kilowatt or higher. As an option. And my goal here is to figure out how we can eliminate any possibilities and miss something that we have not thought about. [2:32:47] And as again as technology advances that then we're going to wish we would have had, um, some different restrictions. I think if you were in the room, you would see that Ethan May want to add something in. Can I just make a clarification? Um, the regulations that we're proposing would not allow a facility over 75 kilowatts. Only facilities up to or equal to 75 kilowatts would be permitted. So up to 50 kilowatt is, I'm sorry. Am I missing something? I was just correct. I think you may have misspoke and I was just correcting the, because you said data centers over 75 kilowatts. I just wanted to make it clear that this would those would not be permitted under this proposal. Oh, I was, thank you for, thank you. I, I was just sharing that I have a concern at C at 75 or over 75. [2:33:54] So I think what we're talking about here is 75, the right number. I don't know if it's the right number. I don't know that any of us knows it's the right number of Ethan had come to us and said 50 in his, um, in his draft regulation, um, you know, maybe we would be saying, well, how about 40? I, I really don't know. Um, I, I feel very ill - equipped. To, to say what is too much. You know, I think for me, the question is, will this use have impacts that we don't want it to have in Boulder County? It's not a question of do we want AI or not? It's, uh, because data, this data synergy used for all kinds of things. I mean, the growth of AI is what's really driving them. [2:34:50] But this is not how do we feel about AI. It's how do we feel about data centers? If we want to propose regulation that says 50 kilowatts, I think I could go along with that. I would just have to acknowledge that I can't, I don't have the background to make an intelligent. Judgment, um, on what is the right amount. Yes, come to my motion. I'm sorry. What did you say. Oh, I just, we, we need to move forward and make a motion. So if, if, um, unless the other provisions we want to talk about, if well, we are, all we want to deliberate on is the size of the data center. Well, it sounded like there wasn't, I'm sorry. I think we had just spoken at the same time. So that's why I didn't hear what you said. Um, I think it sounded like we weren't interested in on hold, you know, just taking more time to add any additional conditions or look at any more restrictions or specific. And instead leave that up for interpretation in the code, which is, um, that's what I heard, which is fine. Um, so for me, that's the only item. And I didn't hear any other. I'm happy to do a motion. If that's where we're at. I think that is. So. Okay. So let's [2:36:21] see how um, item 10A in regards to the land use code docket. On data centers, which is DC - 26 - 003. To, I moved to accept staff's recommendation with the change of, instead of 75 kilowatts, 250 kilowatts. Second. Annacond all in favor. Just one moment. Sorry Commissioner Levy. I think the one bit of advisement from our Kenny attorney and perhaps there was also something to consider around the condition. On the moratorium. Yeah. This is Eric. Oh, this is Eric Roger's assistic cardyterty. I just wanted to see if the board had any interest in an executive session under CRS24 - 6 - 4024B for legal advice related to this docket. Specifically as a related to the changes that we're making to the recommended to the recommended regulations. You're proposing that because you think we may need some legal advice. So. They like to make a motion to that effect? Um, and sorry, Erica, I just didn't hear if you read the citation. Yes. So it's CRS24 - 6 - 402 - 4B for legal vice - relate to this docket. So moved. Second. Okay. All in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. All right. We will be an Executive session and will somebody please send Commissioner Luciamin and me a link to that. And we will return shortly. Commissioners, are you ready. [2:38:17] Yes. We are. Thank you. Thank you so much. And we're recording. All right, thank you. We are back on the record after our executive session. We did have emotion in a second on the floor. And so I would call for discussion on the motion. I'm happy to add some discussion, Commissioner Levy. So just in my background, having set health and safety standards for different chemical exposures and factory settings, one of the things we often would do when looking at a lethal dosage or a standard is take a fraction of the standard. So you're not coming right against a maximum. So for example, if the lethal dosage of exposure is a certain concentration, if you took, say, a third of it, dosage and you knew you would come under it. I think we should take that same approach when we're considering the effects of data centers in our community. I think it's great that the staff have proposed using the energy star number with the 75 kilowatts. But for a Conservative approach to ensure we're not hitting right up against the thresholds of larger centers that will have negative externalities for noise and lighting and transportation and cost effects, that if we took a third of that off the top and brought it down to 50 kilowatts that we would be in a better position to [2:39:40] protect our community from a health and safety perspective. So I would support moving forward with the motion as presented. At 50 kilowatts. All right, thank you. And Commissioner Luchamine, any additional comments? Yeah, thanks for getting us started on this part of the discussion. I'm really looking, and I again, I appreciate what staffs brought forward. And giving us a number to contemplate, which I think is part of it. And that we tend to have discussion about all different types of number, whether it's whether Scorfit or numbers on different types of lighting or all the different things that happen in the land use hearing. For me, part of this is using energy as epoxy for all of the other negative externalities and negative impacts that we know right now. And again, those could change and will evolve in regards to negative impacts of data centers based on what we know right now. And so for me, it's using the different, just reducing that from an energy proxy standpoint is why I'm supporting 50 instead of the 75. [2:40:55] Okay, thank you. And the only thing I'll add is that we do have some criteria in our land use code for when it's appropriate to amend the text. And as Ethan explained, this is, it is in need of amendment to existing text in that we don't currently define this use. And so we would not have a mechanism for requiring a special use approval. It could potentially fall under some other definition of an allowed use in one of our industrial zones without the ability to impose conditions. Uh, it's not contrary to the intent and purpose of the code in that there are potential land use and other external impacts that have been mentioned. And so it is in need of regulation. And most importantly, it is in accordance with our Boulder County Comprehensive Plan in the Our Approach to Protecting Environmental Impacts and having compatibility with, uh, existing and surrounding uses. So I think the motion is, um, is well supported. So, uh, with all those comments, I would call for a vote all in favor of the motion as stated, say aye. Aye. Aye. All right. And so, uh, DC 26 - 003 is approved as amended. Uh, I do have a question, do we need a separate motion to repeal the moratorium or is that implicit in this. This is Eric Rogers. This is [2:42:42] the County Turner. I would suggest having a second motion just to clarify that the moratorium is terminated as to the data center issue. Okay. Thank you. I will move that the moratorium is terminated upon the adoption of this new code for data centers. Thank you. Okay. All in favor say aye. Aye. All right. So we have repealed the moratorium and we have, uh, enacted regulations to take that their place. We will now move on to, uh, dock it DC 26 dash 0 0 0 4. And these are text amendments to the land use code related to detention centers. And, uh, Ethan, I would, uh, I would invite you to share with us. Oh Commissioner Luchamine, I'm sorry. I'm just going to take a couple of minutes break. And if y'all want to go ahead and continue, you've got two commissioners. It's just totally fine. And if anybody else on staff is wanting to take a break, I would ask for a resist. Okay. Do we need a recess? That's no problem if we do. I think I heard that we do just now from Commissioner Lochimine. So, um, do we want to come back at 250. Uh, I think, well, let's see. I don't think we need 10 minutes here. I think five is fine. ## 11.b Public Hearing on Text Amendments to the Land Use Code related to Detention Centers [2:44:01] Thanks. Why don't we come back at 245. Thank you. Thank you so much, Chair. Hold on just a moment. And we're recording. All right, we are back on the record and we are ready to hear our docket labeled at DC26 - 004. And this is Land News Code Amendments related to Detention Centers. And Ethan is still with us and has been the senior planner on this project, Ethan. You have the floor. Good afternoon, Commissioners, members of the public. My name is Ethan Abner. I am a senior planner with Boulder County Community Planning and Permitting, and I'm back to present on docket DC - 26 - 004, text amends to the land use code related to detention centers. So again, it provides some background. The Board of County Commissioners expressed concerns at that work session back in May about recent trends and potential land use impacts related to detention centers and authorized staff to pursue text amendments to the land use code in order to address those concerns. The commissioners expressed concerns they were concerned because the code does not currently define detention centers as a use. It does not identify an appropriate scale of use, and it does not identify zoning districts where the use can and cannot occur. And so the Board of County Commissioners and members of the public, again, in that moratorium [2:45:35] hearing expressed interest in prohibiting these particular uses to go through the timeline real quick in May of 2026, we had that BOCCORC session regarding both data centers and detention centers in June of 2026 staff were authorized to amend the land use code, as well as a moratorium on applications for detention centers went into effect while staff updated or worked to update the land use code. On July 2nd. We held a public hearing on the six - month moratorium. In September of 2026, draft were finalized and sent on referral October 21st last month. We had planning commission, November 10th, today the Board of County Commissioners hearing. As a reminder, on December 2nd, 2026, the moratorium is set to expire. So just to cover some general land use concerns as they relate to Detention Centers, they have a variety of land use and PACs. Those generally might include being designed and operated for continuous habitation by people, sometimes adding people to places with limited infrastructure. And that relates to things like ability to get water supply removes sewage roads that would support traffic for this use. And there has been an emergency issue on the national scale related to the conversion of existing structures, like warehouses that were not approved for this particular use. Additionally, detention centers just by virtue of how they're designed. They might be [2:47:00] designed in ways that are not compatible with residential areas. That might include outdoor, bright outdoor security lighting, tall fences, or other prominent structures like guard towers. So to summarize the changes proposed by staff, refers proposing to define a detention center use as a facility where a persons are held in custody detained kept confined for any amount of time buying entity legally authorized to do so. This includes holding areas, prisons, jails, correctional facilities, penal institutions, or similar facilities, whether publicly or privately owned. And then we would put prohibitory language in 4 - 5 - 1 - 4G, which is our public or quasi - public facility other than listed use, um, to say that these uses are not permitted. So I'll give you a brief moment approximately 15 to 30 seconds to look at the proposed draft text. We would put the definition of a detention center in Article 18, which is where we define terms in the land use code. And then we would make it clear in 4 - 5 - 1 - 4 - G that the use does not include detention centers, which are not permitted under the code. So I'll give everybody just a minute to look at that. [2:48:17] Okay, and we can come back to if we can come back to this slide if we need to. Um, so we sent this out on referral, uh, and received referral received agency feedback from the city of Boulder who found that the proposed text appears generally consistent with the comprehensive plan. It's framework of directing urban development towards areas planned for urban services and maintaining the rural character of unincorporated areas. The city of Boulder also encouraged the county to consider whether the proposed prohibition is intended to apply to all detention facilities, including those that serve local regional public needs. And as this is drafted, it would apply to all detention facilities. Um, we received responses of no conflict from the Boulder County Conservation Eastment Program. The little Thompson Water District, town of Erie Longmont Fire, United Power Excel, the Boulder County Access and Engineering team and the NiWatt Sanitation District. We also received public comment throughout this process. 12 public comments that supported Prohibition of this use with one recommending a change to the language. Um, also folks commented back during the moratorium hearings expressing support for prohibiting this use. Uh, planning commission recommended approval of the docket with no changes. In order for a land use code text amendment to be adopted. It must meet Article 16 of the code, which lays out criteria for adopting [2:49:38] a land use code text amendment. Um, and that it requires that the, uh, proposal meets the following criteria. So first the existing text is in need of amendment. The code does not currently define the detention center use and appropriate intensity for that use or locations in which this use may or may not occur. The proposed text clarifies that detention centers are not permitted in unincorporated Boulder County and thus is consistent with this criterion. Criteria too, the amendment is not contrary to the purpose and intent of this code. The proposed amendment is not contrary to the purpose and intent of this code, which guides development in the unincorporated County and identifies appropriate locations and intensities for uses to occur based on the potential land use impacts of detention center staff repose that these uses not be allowed in the unincorporated county. Article three, the amendment is in accordance with the Boulder County Comprehensive Plan, which seeks to guide denser and more intense development to the municipalities while preserving the rural unincorporated lands for agricultural activities. Load density residential development and other activities consistent with a rural character of the county. So staffer recommending again, prohibition of this particular use because it's not consistent with a comprehensive plan. So staff are recommending that the Board of County Commissioners approved docket DC - 26 - 004 text amends [2:50:57] to the land use code related to Detention Centers, uh, with the following conditions. Um, that the resolution imposing a temporary moratorium. Expired effective the date of these regulations, November 10th, 2026. With that, I am happy to answer any questions that you have. Um, thank you. All right. Thank you Ethan. Commissioners Questions. Thanks Ethan. I appreciate. The follow - up on the request that was made previously and just sharing the process that you've gone through understanding what the planning commission, um, their statement was in the University of their vote. I have one logistical question on the side that you were just showing since we've already taken an action in regards to that moratorium that was previously put in place if we would need to do that. For this particular item. So that's just a logistical question first. Um, I will defer to our county attorney to correct me if I'm wrong here, but I believe that, uh, the language related to the moratorium during the last item was specifically focused to the data center portion of the moratorium since these are both appearing on the same moratorium. And so in this instance, since you passed regulations for that particular use, if you passed regulations for this use, we would withdraw the entire moratorium. I heard you that you were looking to the attorney to [2:52:27] get some confirmation. So I guess I was looking for the attorney things. This is Eric Rogers. Ethan stated it correctly. Okay. So I thought the previous section removed the moratorium, but you're saying it removed specific language of the moratorium. The portion of the moratorium that was specifically focused on data centers, yes. Okay. Okay. Um. Okay. Yeah. No, I don't have, I don't have other questions for you. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Kusha Stolzman, any questions? I don't have any questions. Thank you. Uh, thank you. I do have a question. And that is whether this would prohibit a halfway house sort of living arrangement. Halfway houses, um. Are used as a transition from a confined, you know, a locked environment to an unlocked environment. However, the person I believe is still legally in custody so that if they fail to return overnight, they would be considered an escapee. So. You've got custody parent detained kept confined. Um, I want to make sure, because I want to make sure we're not prohibiting halfway houses and incorporated Boulder County because they may be appropriate because they can be residential. So if, if we're, if we have a question about that, um, perhaps we want to add some language saying, uh, in a, uh, in locked, um, facility. [2:54:41] I can't tell. Ethan, are you, are you waiting for somebody to communicate with you? I was going to, no, I'm sorry. Yes. I was looking to see if there were, um, a discussion on this. And I was trying to think through the regulations that we have in places that relates to residential group homes. Um, and because I was trying to recall whether or not halfway houses are actually a use that are permitted under the code, um, or whether they aren't used that's permitted under the code. I would, if I erred on the side of caution, I would say that because someone is technically detained in a halfway house that it could fall under this definition. Um, but that would be my just quick read of what we're looking at here. I would have to do an additional look at, um, the code for, to answer the other question though. Yeah. This is Eric Corrector's. Oh, no, go ahead. Oh, it says to Catherine Tornia. I was just going to suggest that maybe we take a quick break and we could rather than speculate, just take a look at the code and make sure that we're all clear. We could come back in five, 10 minutes. [2:55:45] Okay. Or I think, um, you know, when we did the, the regulations update on group homes, um, I think we, I think we did address it because I know I wanted to make sure we weren't prohibiting them. So it might just be a simple matter of specifying, uh, and, in the definition that it is a locked facility where persons are held in custody. And then we don't, I would rather allow stuff to take a few minutes just to be able to answer that question. Okay. All right. So it is, it is, we'll call it, uh, three o'clock and a staff is 10 minutes enough. I think so. All right. We will. Return. At 3 10. We'll be in recess until then. When we last updated the code as it related to residential uses specifically related to group homes and changes to state law, it looks like when the definition for residential care facility was established, it specifically noted that a residential care facility does not include community corrections facilities, which we would assume as a halfway house. And also when the definition as it relates to household was changed to allow for group care homes under a certain size, that household definition also noted that community correctional facilities weren't considered as part of that definition. And so it looks like after [2:57:43] that change, the use for a halfway house or a community correctional facility was no longer permitted in our code. And so if we wanted to permit that, that is something that we could come back and do. But I think under what we were proposing here today, it would still be the case that that use is not permitted in the unincorporated county. I think for, well, we can talk about this during deliberation, but I would prefer that we not. Lump halfway houses, community corrections in with detention centers, what we're really trying to address here. And it just because we may want that kind of use elsewhere. We didn't do it via that particular docket, but I don't, I think it's a completely different kind of use than what we're really talking about and what has me hung up here is the word custody. And so I think if we, in custody is fine so long as we're only talking about a locked facility. So I think with the definition as written, if we just say a locked facility where persons are held in custody, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, the rest of that's fine. So we can, we can talk about this during deliberation, but, and I would welcome your input on that just because, you know, this is a, we took action in those other [2:59:15] cases on a particular thing we were trying to do where we were addressing the definition of family. And then we, and then that's, had some ancillary impacts. And now we're doing this with respect to detention centers. Ahead of this issue and defining this use and banning it. I'm well aware of lawsuits that have been filed all over the country that have successfully fought back against detention centers in locations like this because of the infrastructure problems that come with them. And of course there are other reasons that I know many people, including myself, support banning detention centers. Due process reasons human rights abuses, but those are also often tied to the repurposing of structures for unintended us and then the knock - on effects that come from that. And I'm very grateful that you instituted the moratorium and also grateful that you, with possibly the caveat of ensuring that halfway houses are exempted from this appear to be supporting both defining this and banning it. And thank you so much. All right, thanks for joining us. Giselle Hermsfeld. [3:01:59] Good afternoon, Boulder County Commissioners. My name is Giselle Hersfeld, and I'm here with the Rocky Mountain Peace and Justice Center. I want to begin again by applauding the Boulder County Commissioners for passing a moratorium on Detention Centers. The people of Boulder County were very clear at the July 2nd meeting and are still clear that we do not want attention centers here or anywhere. At the state level, there have been protests and vigils held every week at the GEO Ice Detention Center in Aurora showing that Coloradons do not want to see their neighbors taken away and locked up. Whether it's immigrant detention centers, tantamount to concentration camps or expanded incarceration of residents charged with low - level crimes in order to bolster the profits of the prison industrial complex. Our community should not be allowing the expansion of any industry that gets rich by locking people in cages. The issue is of particular urgency right now with the recent passage of proposition 132 here in Colorado. [3:02:52] The penalties for fentanyl sale and possession initiative. And I first of all want to thank the Boulder County Commissioners for opposing this measure. This initiative enacts stricter punishments for fentanyl possession lowers the bar for drug felony classifications and enforces mandatory minimum prison sentences. Analysts believe the measure will require 7. 5 million in additional spending on the Colorado Department of Corrections in the first year and 142 million in the first five years. Even more concerning is the possibility that this measure could overwhelm Colorado's existing prison space leading to Colorado reopening or building new prison facilities to the tune of 400 million dollars What we need is more investment in healing stability and recovery, not more incarceration. I also want to talk about ice detention Centers. As the great - granddaughter of a man who died in a concentration camp in Germany, and as the daughter of a Mexican immigrant in the U. S., I carry both the ancestral trauma and the present - day fear surrounding the mass detention of a population deemed as other. And with the current U. S. administration constantly spouting hateful and dehumanizing rhetoric, particularly against immigrants, our community must be at the forefront of efforts to provide safe refuge to immigrants. [3:04:03] There must be no allowance for detention centers on our county's land or in our county's ethics. With the moratorium set to expire on December 2nd, I want to strongly and respectfully urge the commissioners to enact a permanent ban on detention centers in Boulder County. You have the power to protect your constituents from this harmful development, and I assure you that you have the backing and support of your community in this decision. Thank you again for taking the time to listen to your community on this important issue, and thank you for doing the right thing. Okay, thank you very much. Is there anyone else in the hearing room who would like to speak on this docket. Commissioner Stolzman, if y'all again. I do not see anyone moving forward. Okay, thank you for your assistance. Uh, so we will close the public hearing portion or the public testimony portion of this hearing. Ethan, is there anything that you would like to add at this time where commissioners, any additional questions for Ethan. I would just reiterate, um, that this would prohibit detention centers in the unincorporated County, um, and if there are any specific questions, the commissioners want me to answer based on public comment. I'm happy to do that. Okay. Any - I don't have any questions. Thank you though. Alright. And Commissioner Stolesman, no additional [3:05:26] questions? No, I do have some discussion just on your topic, Commissioner Levy. Okay, alright, well, we can, and I have no further questions either. Uh, I'm supportive of moving forward. I think we all are, which is why we ask for the moratorium and then directed staff to draft land use code amendment to prohibit detention centers. We can put emotion on the table and then discuss my issue, or we can have some further discussion on it and see if what makes its way into a motion either way. I'm happy to move approval of dot. DC26004. And I'm in second that motion. Okay, and I would like to propose a friendly amendment that we approve the docket, but we modify the definition, uh, of a detention facility to specify that it is a locked facility where persons are held in custody, et cetera. And so thanks Commissioner Levy for the spirit of the point around halfway houses. I think for me, I would be more comfortable if we authorized staffs in a separate authorization to consider how we would want to include halfway houses and unincorporated Boulder County and address it head - on in the code so we can get public comment, understand which zone districts it might be in, how we might want to regulate it. My concern with just adding locked is with [3:07:03] technology, um, people are using ankle bracelets and watches and all kinds of different technology to detain people. And I just haven't fully considered all of the implications from inserting the word locked in the way that you're proposing. I think currently halfway houses are not allowed in unincorporated Boulder County the way the code is written. And so I'm open to considering that. I just think a separate effort with separate public comment and consideration for which zone districts could support that use. Like the water needs the transportation needs, the policing needs just so that we take the issue head on and don't inadvertently miscomment or feedback around the important issue that you're raising. And I acknowledge that it is an important issue. I just don't know all the implications of simply adding the word that you're proposing. [3:07:56] Um, yeah, thank you for that. Uh, I do realize that sometimes things that seem simple are more complex than they may appear. Um, my concern with directing staff to undertake a new process is, uh, from the information that Ethan provided to us, it sounds like we have already said that they are not allowed in residential zone districts. And that's where we were addressing. The definition of family and group homes and care homes. I forgot the exact title is on that. So we've taken care of that. Um, and I don't know whether it's the case that they would not be allowed halfway houses anywhere in Boulder County. I don't think we have a definitive answer to that. And I don't think we need a definitive answer. What I'm trying to avoid is just inadvertently making it impossible to have a halfway house in unincorporated Boulder County. [3:09:04] Uh, where that may not currently be the case. So I'm, I'm trying to just preserve the status quo. Um, yes, there's, there are other forms of technology that can monitor a person's location. But when you decide you're going to use an ankle bracelet or some other form of technology, that's generally used when a person is not confined. Uh, in a facility. It's used so that they can still, you know, they can be detained at home. If they're whereabouts can be monitored so they don't abscond from the jurisdiction, uh, but, um, but I don't believe, I mean, I think we, we do clearly distinguish in our facilities between Loch and Unlocked. For example, the, the Jo Peli Center is not a locked facility. So this, this, I would, I guess that's the story is not made by motion here is because, um, I don't want us to inadvertently prohibit something that, uh, that might still be allowed in Boulder County in unincorporated Boulder County. And I don't think it does any harm to them. Primary purpose of this provision to do that. So, um, I don't know that we actually had a second on my friendly amendment, uh, Commissioner Stolzman, you, which is. Started a discussion, uh, hear when it's not actually on the table, um, so Commissioner Luchamine, I'd be interested in your thoughts on [3:10:35] this. Thank you. I, I would be interested in separately asking staff, uh, to do some. I don't want to say research. I think they probably have a good idea, but doing some exploration in regards to where and we're in the current land use. Text. We could address the question around halfway houses. For me, it's the term of a facility that just feels very different than, uh, presidential home or a group home or a house or residential. So I, for me, it just feels like it's a, it's two different. Structures, two different areas of the code that we might. Treat differently. And so, um, I, I didn't, I didn't second. That particular for lay a member, but I appreciate the discussion. Okay. Well, I might just say one more thing about it, um, in hopes of, um, changing your mind here on whether to move forward with it at this time. Um, I believe, you know, in some instance says, uh, what we've always called the copper door could be considered, uh, could have been considered a halfway house. And I, I think most people would have thought of that as a facility. It had, uh, it had a capability of, um, of a kitchen and Joy dining and, you know, certain group activity centers where things were done. And so I don't, I don't think [3:12:21] the fact that we are saying facility versus a home actually. Helps with that distinction. So, uh, I don't know if you want to. Dinner and second emotion. And if you don't, then I do think we need to be quite cognizant of the fact that we may be making it impossible, um, without a lot of further process here by, by staff and the commissioners, it may be impossible to, to do additional forms of community corrections and unencorporated over county. Sure. Yeah. I'm, I hadn't heard, heard your question until right now. So I'm on the spot trying to respond to what you're asking. And so my comment is based on the way that I'm reading in real time, what you're presenting. Um, so I would have to do a lot more thinking about it and have, to make any change. But I am prepared to address what was in the packet and really want to appreciate the public comment this afternoon. Okay. All right. Well, I will, uh, of course withdraw my motion, uh, in any case, it's dead for lack of a second. Uh, so we have a motion to approve the amendments to the land use code as presented. And we have a second. And I think we can, uh, unless we want to have additional comment. We can simply adopt the findings that staff [3:13:55] made in the staff packet. And I think on my, if it's a right, Charlie, just in regards to the comments that you just mentioned, for me, this has been one of the most concerning issues that has come to not just current times over the last 18 months or so, but in a new way in the last 18 months, uh, and the, as you've heard me talk about pretty consistently. All of the topics are really important. All of the issues, all of the work that happens at the county. And yet when black and brown bodies are targeted are removed or detained and murdered in this country and the still areas, including in Colorado where detention centers are being built, constructed, maintained, et cetera, and funded. I think it was really important for this board to give the direction that we did and allow our staff to go through a process to get feedback and to really consider if having detention centers is something that we would do in our county. My hope is, um, I think Noray probably has already left. But if not, um, very interested in the postcard because Bill Weiser also told me, um, that he would not only look at Data Centers, but that he would close detention centers. And so, um, if I was there in person, I would have ran [3:15:25] and got a postcard, but I am hopeful that our elected officials around the state of Colorado are colleagues around the country will consider what they might do also in regards to Landy's code amendments to address both of these issues. Okay. Well, thank you for those comments. Commissioner Stolzman, would you like to make some comments? I just, I'm grateful for the staff for working on bringing this land use change, uh, forward for us today. Uh, we don't need to see the proliferation of detention of people in private facilities in our community. And there have been absolutely inhumane practices and unethical practices around the country. And this is a step in the right direction toward using our authority to put an end to that. So thank you. Yeah. I appreciate both of your comments. I want to compliment, uh, Giselle, she's still in the hearing room on, on her comments, um, I found them very eloquent and completely on point. And I agree with staff efforts in the direction at the Commissioners provided to prohibit detention centers in on incorporating for all the reasons stated, the Detention Centers in particular that are used in conjunction with immigration, uh, detention, um, in their inhumanine, um, I believe they violate people's constitutional rights just per se, uh, by locking people up who have not committed any crime. And then [3:17:01] they are, uh, forced to work, uh, for their food. They are treated without any human dignity, uh, because what they did was enter this country, uh, perhaps unlawfully. Often we have people detained that even entered the country lawfully and they're unable to access an attorney. We definitely don't want any, uh, any buildings in Boulder County use for that purpose. We don't want to allow new ones. Um, but I would take this beyond immigration detention centers, uh, we will, uh, unless the legislature is able to take action to blonde the effect of amendment 132. And I think it was 133 that dealt with life without parole for, uh, child trafficking. We will see an explosion in our prison population. And the state will be looking for any place possible to construct new, uh, prisons. And, um, and we don't need that in Boulder County. So this is our part to say that we don't condone these activities and Boulder County land will not be used to further them. So I think now that we've, we've all had a chance to, to support this amendment, uh, I would simply call for a vote on the motion that's in front of us. And I think it does need, well, we could do a separate amendment to repeal the moratorium. So why don't we just ferve the sake of [3:18:40] clarity? Go ahead and vote. I'll move to repeal the moratorium. Second. Oh, okay, all in favor of that motion. All right, so we have past this docket. We have repealed the corresponding moratorium that concludes our business for today, and we are adjourned. Thank you everybody. Thanks, Steph. Thank you.